MAFIA 51 - LONDON BY GASLIGHT [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

A summary of where I am, as much for myself as anyone else

1. damo Town
2. e.m.c ? edging towards non-Town
3. bozo ?
4. dargorygel townlean
5. xorxes townlean
6. Computer_Genius [bo] null
7. Chaqa VT
8. rdrivera2005 null
9. BunnyGo townlean
10. Vecna ?
11. Temasek22 ?
12. ND DrJ
13. frostwind scum
14. BionicMole ?
15. Hosuke ? (very quiet)
16. Kitsune townlean
17. DemRHK townlean
18. purplecow ?
19. FlaviusAetius probtown but hmmm
20. CmdrLikely ?
21. Vaporwave [Tom] ?
22. BobMcBob deadSCUM
23. KalelChase ?

[damo666]

Calling Chaqa voters.

You really should move. The VT expalanation is way more likely than scum. We can sacrifice Chaqa later on if doubts remain. At this point he is a bad lynch.

[ND]

Eh. Yeah @Damo

Obviously do what you will with thy vote but idk I for one am still considering. It's hard for me to do a massive post on my phone rn at work. I got to type my thoughts out later

[ND]

Why Is everyone voting frost what did he say or do I've been caught up in my thing.

[BunnyGo]

I’m going to say this again:

YOU ARE ALL VOTING TO 50/50 A DOCTOR ROLE WHEN WE DO NOT NEED TO. THIS IS A DAY 3 LYNCH, NOT A DAY 2.

Damo is shooting up my scumreads, I’m really happy n frost. I advocate anyone with at least half a brain staying away from this ND/Chaqa shit to read and consider a frost wagon.

Ok...so...we want to kill one of them tomorrow and one today, right? This is what you’re saying? WHEN WILL WE LYNCH BOTH IF NOT TODAY?

[BunnyGo]

My impressions are that I am the role I was given, and Vapor handled my role extremely well even though he didn’t know it. Thanks for asking such a finely tuned, worthwhile question.

Here it is @bunny

bump

I already responded why I thought he was being a pedant and just joking with you. Search “pedant” in the bot and you’ll find my post. I think it is NAI.

[Tom Bombadil]

@ND - who are you scumreading?

@damo - why did you vote me right after I subbed in with no explanarion and then put me as a ? In your reads?

[BunnyGo]

Agreed. I was going to vote for him when I saw nobody died: any of the scum teams should have gone for him. And our healers we're taken (maybe one saved him? maybe not). I think his team got unlucky targeting whoever. I also think most of his posts yesterday were saying little, but doing it loudly. Whenever asked to stake out an actual read, he deflected.

All that said: ##VOTE ND.

This.....seems really weird?

You were really liking ND's shit yesterday

bumppppppppppppppppppppp
bunny what the heck you did like what ND was doing, I dont remember any wagon forming around him...

See very start of D2 before I got to the claim I joined Chaq in voting on him.

[ND]

I'll post some thoughts and suspects later.

[FlaviusAetius]

I’m going to say this again:

YOU ARE ALL VOTING TO 50/50 A DOCTOR ROLE WHEN WE DO NOT NEED TO. THIS IS A DAY 3 LYNCH, NOT A DAY 2.

Damo is shooting up my scumreads, I’m really happy n frost. I advocate anyone with at least half a brain staying away from this ND/Chaqa shit to read and consider a frost wagon.

Ok...so...we want to kill one of them tomorrow and one today, right? This is what you’re saying? WHEN WILL WE LYNCH BOTH IF NOT TODAY?

One dies tonight.

[FlaviusAetius]

Why Is everyone voting frost what did he say or do I've been caught up in my thing.

I explained it in a post

[dargorygel]

Did both teams and Hyde really follow ND s crumbs?
ND, with all respect, doesn't usually get gear killed n1. In fact, vecna and xorxes were not hit. Unless they were hit and aren't claiming. Were one of the scum teams newbies? Did Bob's team tie? Was Hyde sleeping?
Chaqa, when claiming, said that he'd received notice that Hyde had not killed. Did ND receive such a notice?

[dargorygel]

And maybe most importantly... Is everyone traveling already?

[Chaqa]

Did both teams and Hyde really follow ND s crumbs?
ND, with all respect, doesn't usually get gear killed n1. In fact, vecna and xorxes were not hit. Unless they were hit and aren't claiming. Were one of the scum teams newbies? Did Bob's team tie? Was Hyde sleeping?
Chaqa, when claiming, said that he'd received notice that Hyde had not killed. Did ND receive such a notice?

I only said that *after* ND said his - I hadn't read the setup as thoroughly as I claimed and missed that, along with the Jack being an even-night killer part.

ND's claim seems really solid. Absorbing one kill (from a team who must have read him as Sherlock like I did) and the roleblock - likely he was hit by Team 2.

Team 1 likely hit the commuter

[CmdrLikely]

I agree with lynching Frostwind, but not today. Like people have said, his voting habbits appear non-town. We should lynch ND or Chaqa on principal that it will get us somewhere. Conceivably, it could be bad to kill a doctor... but we'd also be killing a Night Kill PR. Also, we have another doctor already. Arguably having the doctors coordinate is tricky and not guaranteed. So due to possible overlap, I'd only consider it more like 1 ½ doctors.
Anyways, everyone saying don't lynch ND or Chaqa are looking scummy to me.

[bo_sox48]

Do I have to vote today or tomorrow

[xorxes]

Do I have to vote today or tomorrow

Yes

[xorxes]

I agree with lynching Frostwind, but not today. Like people have said, his voting habbits appear non-town. We should lynch ND or Chaqa on principal that it will get us somewhere. Conceivably, it could be bad to kill a doctor... but we'd also be killing a Night Kill PR. Also, we have another doctor already. Arguably having the doctors coordinate is tricky and not guaranteed. So due to possible overlap, I'd only consider it more like 1 ½ doctors.
Anyways, everyone saying don't lynch ND or Chaqa are looking scummy to me.

Explain why you think lynching ND is a good option for today now that Chaqa has retracted his claim.

[FlaviusAetius]

Did I miss a case on frost? Why are you voting frost damo?

The biggest case on Frost is his vote pattern on D1, he voted every counter wagon to Bob without any reasoning. It look like a newbie scum trying to save his partner but he said he played on other site.


##vote Frost, by the way.

exactly, frost says he's a noob when he wants too, and says he's a pro when he feels like it, the two don't connect and he's flip-flopping
and the vote isnt that hard to believe, chaqa was supporting vapor too, and anyone who voted for computer_genius completely baffles my mind, and should be auto-suspect, but then moving off of computer_genius in your mind is suspect? hello?

@ND there's the argument for frost, weak at best

[Chaqa]

Like i said - if we can't find consensus anywhere else, lynching me is a safe play.