M1027: Community - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

One further comment, the Investigator has done a good job of hiding in plain sight, great performance so far. I hope everyone affords them the +1's and acclaim they deserve once the game is over. A truly outstanding member of the Town.

(Not inviting speculation on the Investigator's identity, please don't).

Wow now I know why you made this post :)

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

So sweet, who do you think it is? Rdr? Worcej? Heart? Jamie?

[worcej]

I have some of my own pseudo science here.

I assume 1-3 scum were on the kak train. Let's call it 2

7 people were not on the train. One is kak and one is me, known town to me.

That would mean 2 of 5 of ghug, rdr, sweet, bozo, Hamilton are scum. Could be 1of 6 or 3 of 5 as well. I doubt all 4 scum were on kak, nor that none were. The other townies in my second group should be able to see this the same way as me

Bringing this up again

Rdr is the name that stands out there.

Its funny, if the scum team is Ghug, Hamilton, Chaqa and Rdr, that's a very experienced squad.

And town is kicking their bottoms.

So I hate to meta, but I feel 99.99999% confident rdr is not scum here.

Scum rdr has conceded in 2 games where he was the last scum and had almost no odds of winning due to mechanics.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can the newbies kick the oldies asses?

[sweetandcool]

So sweet, who do you think it is? Rdr? Worcej? Heart? Jamie?

I think you are scum or investigator.

Heart is 2nd likeliest scum candidate.

All remaining players fit the profile of part of a scumteam that would NK damo.

[sweetandcool]

Can the newbies kick the oldies asses?

This is silly. It was an incredibly townsided setup and we've proven nothing.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Bringing this up again

Rdr is the name that stands out there.

Its funny, if the scum team is Ghug, Hamilton, Chaqa and Rdr, that's a very experienced squad.

And town is kicking their bottoms.

So I hate to meta, but I feel 99.99999% confident rdr is not scum here.

Scum rdr has conceded in 2 games where he was the last scum and had almost no odds of winning due to mechanics.

Rdr hasn’t beenn online in a while. Maybe he just hasn’t considered it?

Is it heart? Can’t be you, worcej, since you know you’ve already been caught.

Jamie maybe? I’ve been worried about him trying to buddy me, and in hindsight that might be the case.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can the newbies kick the oldies asses?

This is silly. It was an incredibly townsided setup and we've proven nothing.

No, it all depends on when investigator gets killed. They didn’t, this game, and thus they have secured a victory.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

So sweet, who do you think it is? Rdr? Worcej? Heart? Jamie?

I think you are scum or investigator.

Heart is 2nd likeliest scum candidate.

All remaining players fit the profile of part of a scumteam that would NK damo.

Well I’m not scum, and I’m certainly not experienced enough to have pulled off this investigator run.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

So sweet, who do you think it is? Rdr? Worcej? Heart? Jamie?

I think you are scum or investigator.

Heart is 2nd likeliest scum candidate.

All remaining players fit the profile of part of a scumteam that would NK damo.

Well I’m not scum, and I’m certainly not experienced enough to have pulled off this investigator run.

Why do you think I’m scum? Is it because of my plan and how I responded to criticism about it?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Now that I think about it, is there some sort of loophole we haven’t thought of? Does mafia see something we don’t? I’m starting to doubt the reason behind the mafia sticking it out.

[worcej]

Now that I think about it, is there some sort of loophole we haven’t thought of? Does mafia see something we don’t? I’m starting to doubt the reason behind the mafia sticking it out.

There is a chance scum can get to KiLo with a 50/50 depending on the scan results and if they hit the investigator here

[worcej]

If the investigator dies here and the scan is only one additional clear, I believe the game comes down to 2-1 with a clear in KiLo

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Now that I think about it, is there some sort of loophole we haven’t thought of? Does mafia see something we don’t? I’m starting to doubt the reason behind the mafia sticking it out.

There is a chance scum can get to KiLo with a 50/50 depending on the scan results and if they hit the investigator here

No, if investigator is not you, which I think it is not based on sweet’s reasoning, we will get either three clears of 5 total players, which we win no matter what, or we catch one of the mafia in the scan, also clinching the game.

[worcej]

Only person I know who would stick this out until the bitter end is Jamie if your analysis is correct

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I will make a spreadsheet because my professor is boring me to near death.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Only person I know who would stick this out until the bitter end is Jamie if your analysis is correct

That’s what I’ve started to believe too. Jamie was INCREDIBLY suspicious D1 and then suddenly dropped off the face of the earth.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Here ya go everyone! Just gotta pray worcej isn’t investigator.

If worcej is investigator, we have two clears of 5 people. If we miskill (2/3 chance), then we have a 50/50 chance of catching mafia. This is the only possible way we lose.

[Jamiet99uk]

Only person I know who would stick this out until the bitter end is Jamie if your analysis is correct

That’s what I’ve started to believe too. Jamie was INCREDIBLY suspicious D1 and then suddenly dropped off the face of the earth.

What do you mean? I'm here.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Only person I know who would stick this out until the bitter end is Jamie if your analysis is correct

That’s what I’ve started to believe too. Jamie was INCREDIBLY suspicious D1 and then suddenly dropped off the face of the earth.

What do you mean? I'm here.

Not dropped off like you stopped posting, dropped off as in you have had little controversy all the rest of the game. You’ve stayed extremely neutral throughout the rest of the game.