MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Jamie probably said something that ticked off the mafia. Deep analysis time.

[damo666]

His only mention of Bona D2 was saying he liked his VCA, so he either was avoiding mentioning him or it's not a crumb.

He did say this EoN1, though, which points to crumb:

crumb?

Jamie was the watcher.

Putting Bona in a different color than everyone else also feels crumby.

Oh sorry. Didn't spot Watcher. Read it as small town guy, doh!

[BunnyGo]

I cannot be up at EoN I'm afraid. I need to go to bed now as I must be up at 5am to catch a train.

If I die, kill Bona.

Plenty of time for scum to change their NK so townpoints for Bona here.

What does that mean?

[damo666]

So I don't think I'm giving anything away* by saying Bona is scum or doc.

* well I am but doesn't matter

I guess there's no point DKing Bona because if he's doc they'll NK him 2m

##vote Bunny

[damo666]

I cannot be up at EoN I'm afraid. I need to go to bed now as I must be up at 5am to catch a train.

If I die, kill Bona.

Plenty of time for scum to change their NK so townpoints for Bona here.

What does that mean?

I hadn't realised J was Watcher when I posted that.

[Bonatogether]

i claim doctor

i normally don't crumb but bozo at least caught onto my 'other necessary measures' comment d1

saved myself n1
saved bozo n2

believe it's a good idea to claim because jamie seems to have indicated that he scumread me based on visits and if i am counterclaimed, a 1-1 trade is good for town. i am also able to potentially dodge nks in the event there is no cc.

[BunnyGo]

Jamie probably said something that ticked off the mafia. Deep analysis time.

Oh…there you are. Where you been?

[Bonatogether]

oh haha damo

[BunnyGo]

So I don't think I'm giving anything away* by saying Bona is scum or doc.

* well I am but doesn't matter

I guess there's no point DKing Bona because if he's doc they'll NK him 2m

##vote Bunny

This is so stupid as to be mystifying

[BunnyGo]

I think real doc shouldn’t counter claim. I also think it’s time for mech discussion because our vig isn’t doing their job. But I’m at dinner with my kid and phone is below 9%.

So back later.

##vote damo

Vote scum

Then we talk mechs.

[Bonatogether]

the vig shooting me is the worst of all possible worlds

i would much rather a 1-1 counterclaim battle if i am going to be escorted to the god thread by the work of town

[BunnyGo]

Never mind. Bona’s claim is stupid.

##vote bona.

I’ll let others wxplain.

[damo666]

Never mind. Bona’s claim is stupid.

##vote bona.

I’ll let others wxplain.

Why can't Bona be doc?

[Bonatogether]

Never mind. Bona’s claim is stupid.

##vote bona.

I’ll let others wxplain.

if your point is why did jamie scumread me if he saw me visit myself n1, then i cannot explain why that is.

[damo666]

Someone help me out. What is Bunny seeing I'm not?

[BunnyGo]

No need for doc to claim. This is the dumbest fake claim ever.

[BunnyGo]

Never mind. Bona’s claim is stupid.

##vote bona.

I’ll let others wxplain.

if your point is why did jamie scumread me if he saw me visit myself n1, then i cannot explain why that is.

This damo

[damo666]

Never mind. Bona’s claim is stupid.

##vote bona.

I’ll let others wxplain.

if your point is why did jamie scumread me if he saw me visit myself n1, then i cannot explain why that is.

This damo

But before Bona posted that couldn't Jamie have see Target X (not Sweet) being visited by Bona?

[Bonatogether]

if your point is why did jamie scumread me if he saw me visit myself n1, then i cannot explain why that is.

This damo

But before Bona posted that couldn't Jamie have see Target X (not Sweet) being visited by Bona?

if he visited me n1, he would have seen me visiting myself, thereby showing that i am doc. therefore this is impossible

[damo666]

This makes no sense.

If Bona visited himself Jamie would know he was doctor, right? [Would he think RB RB'd themselves jic of being a watch target? No ofcn].

So why would scumBona say that he could say he saved anyone, no? [I'm assuming no message to unsaved save target]

I'm confused.

I'm also clearly non-doc town or a highly skilled scum actor.