MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[sweetandcool]

not to be a dick to y'all but a lot of dousing/s&c and you/koala is tedious to get through

i guess part of it is that i independently TR 3/4 of y'all and haven't made up my mind on koala yet

starting to appreciate why people glazed over when i used to get in arguments

That's fine. Mostly I've been hoping to enlighten Dousing. Probably spending too much time replying to Koala. Do they normally nitpick and come up with dramatic arguments? It just seems like they are constantly misunderstanding Bona in a really weird way.

But why do you care so much? Believe me, Bona can fend for themselves just fine in my experience...

Why all this effort to protect Bona? Should be just 1 of many "other townie" players on here...

Unless, of course, Bona is your Mafia teammate or if you are a Mafia trying to pocket a Townie-Bona, then I can see why so much effort.

Bona, question – what do you make of this dynamic you have going on with sweetandcool for the record?

I guess I care because I understand Bona and a lot of their thinking aligns with mine. Of course, you are correct that I could easily be Mafia and simply pandering to Bona. Similar to my suspicion towards Eden, but with roles reversed. At the very least, if I'm Mafia then I'm being incredibly obvious about favoring Bona.

[Bonatogether]

is this what it's like to be on the sidelines of epic wallpost arguments?

because i am so sorry fellas

wdym

not to be a dick to y'all but a lot of dousing/s&c and you/koala is tedious to get through

i guess part of it is that i independently TR 3/4 of y'all and haven't made up my mind on koala yet

starting to appreciate why people glazed over when i used to get in arguments

lame!

[snowy801]

I don't understand your reasoning here, sorry. I think you are either misunderstanding Bona or purposely misunderstanding him as he claims.

Let me try again...

The entire discussion is about a post of mine that Snowy says proves I'm Mafia – because I say "when" Bona flips Mafia. Implying that only a Mafia know for sure that it's "when" and not "if".

I said this is ridiculous.

Bona then said that actually Snowy is right and I'm mis-representing Snowy.

But if Snowy is right, and I did claim Mafia, that makes Bona Mafia as well, by definition.

Bona already posted again in response, but his meaning seemed plain to me, and his explanation matches that. Snowy has been pretty bizarre the whole game and I agree that the whole "if vs when" argument is utter nonsense.

But your conclusion that Bona is agreeing with Snowy is out of the blue and preposterous.

If it makes you feel better, I'm starting to slightly entertain the idea that you are severely misguided, like Dousing, but I'm not nearly convinced yet.

Still haven't analyzed you as promised, I will when I can.

I will point out that you're agreeing that an argument that I never made is utter nonsense. Now I never made it for a reason, so I accept any premises where you find me suspicious apropos of nothing, but it's important to know what you're agreeing with without realizing

World is a dark and dangerous place, gotta be careful about these little nuances

Also damo I need you stop thinking an end vote is the end to the day. I expect to wake up to exquisite European morning posts

[snowy801]

I resume passing the fuck out because I slept way too early and woke up even more way too early

[Bonatogether]

wdym

not to be a dick to y'all but a lot of dousing/s&c and you/koala is tedious to get through

i guess part of it is that i independently TR 3/4 of y'all and haven't made up my mind on koala yet

starting to appreciate why people glazed over when i used to get in arguments

That's fine. Mostly I've been hoping to enlighten Dousing. Probably spending too much time replying to Koala. Do they normally nitpick and come up with dramatic arguments? It just seems like they are constantly misunderstanding Bona in a really weird way.

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?g= ... oalaAttack
koala's last game (as town)

compare

[Bonatogether]

not to be a dick to y'all but a lot of dousing/s&c and you/koala is tedious to get through

i guess part of it is that i independently TR 3/4 of y'all and haven't made up my mind on koala yet

starting to appreciate why people glazed over when i used to get in arguments

That's fine. Mostly I've been hoping to enlighten Dousing. Probably spending too much time replying to Koala. Do they normally nitpick and come up with dramatic arguments? It just seems like they are constantly misunderstanding Bona in a really weird way.

But why do you care so much? Believe me, Bona can fend for themselves just fine in my experience...

Why all this effort to protect Bona? Should be just 1 of many "other townie" players on here...

Unless, of course, Bona is your Mafia teammate or if you are a Mafia trying to pocket a Townie-Bona, then I can see why so much effort.

Bona, question – what do you make of this dynamic you have going on with sweetandcool for the record?

this post is so sleazy

sweetandcool is my buddy. i'm not sure what you're trying to get with your question beyond trying to create a 'they're a scumpair!!!' thing

[Bonatogether]

if you had any critical thinking skills it'd be clearly evident this is the part i was referring to

OK – let me ask you directly in front of everyone then:

Hi Bona, what is your opinion on the fact that Snowy used my post that said "When Bona flips Mafia I'll say BOOM" to hardlock me as Mafia?

i don't know what he was doing but i see why he thinks that post is suspicious

[Bonatogether]

wdym

not to be a dick to y'all but a lot of dousing/s&c and you/koala is tedious to get through

i guess part of it is that i independently TR 3/4 of y'all and haven't made up my mind on koala yet

starting to appreciate why people glazed over when i used to get in arguments

Also, I really don't feel like doing what Koala wants and restating my position on them. It just seems like a big waste of time. But I feel like not doing so will discredit me.

Do you think I ought to do as Koala requests? Or will it reflect poorly on me if I don't? I think it's fair to Koala to at least have another look to make sure I'm being objective, but is a detailed post really necessary? Especially since I've already been detailed in the past?

if you're town, your objective is to kill scum

do what you think fulfills your win condition

[sweetandcool]

not to be a dick to y'all but a lot of dousing/s&c and you/koala is tedious to get through

i guess part of it is that i independently TR 3/4 of y'all and haven't made up my mind on koala yet

starting to appreciate why people glazed over when i used to get in arguments

Also, I really don't feel like doing what Koala wants and restating my position on them. It just seems like a big waste of time. But I feel like not doing so will discredit me.

Do you think I ought to do as Koala requests? Or will it reflect poorly on me if I don't? I think it's fair to Koala to at least have another look to make sure I'm being objective, but is a detailed post really necessary? Especially since I've already been detailed in the past?

if you're town, your objective is to kill scum

do what you think fulfills your win condition

Thank you for your opinion. I agree that killing Mafia is the primary objective. But along the way, not dying is helpful, and redirecting suspicion from a Townie to probable Mafia is helpful.

I suppose there has been plenty of back and forth between us and Koala, it's probably not productive at this point to keep arguing back and forth. I will give it one last look, but I'm going to avoid exhausting conversation.

[snowy801]

I lied haven't slept again yet, trying to

How do people feel about JimothyT

[sweetandcool]

Let me try again...

The entire discussion is about a post of mine that Snowy says proves I'm Mafia – because I say "when" Bona flips Mafia. Implying that only a Mafia know for sure that it's "when" and not "if".

I said this is ridiculous.

Bona then said that actually Snowy is right and I'm mis-representing Snowy.

But if Snowy is right, and I did claim Mafia, that makes Bona Mafia as well, by definition.

Bona already posted again in response, but his meaning seemed plain to me, and his explanation matches that. Snowy has been pretty bizarre the whole game and I agree that the whole "if vs when" argument is utter nonsense.

But your conclusion that Bona is agreeing with Snowy is out of the blue and preposterous.

If it makes you feel better, I'm starting to slightly entertain the idea that you are severely misguided, like Dousing, but I'm not nearly convinced yet.

Still haven't analyzed you as promised, I will when I can.

I will point out that you're agreeing that an argument that I never made is utter nonsense. Now I never made it for a reason, so I accept any premises where you find me suspicious apropos of nothing, but it's important to know what you're agreeing with without realizing

World is a dark and dangerous place, gotta be careful about these little nuances

Also damo I need you stop thinking an end vote is the end to the day. I expect to wake up to exquisite European morning posts

Sorry, yeah guess Koala sucked me in a little bit. Thanks for demonstration that the teensiest amount of defense can go a long way.

I think what I was trying to agree with is that your interest in that statement is baffling. Similar to your interest in the whole Bofa thing. Just seemed like odd statements to spend time on analyzing.

[sweetandcool]

not to be a dick to y'all but a lot of dousing/s&c and you/koala is tedious to get through

i guess part of it is that i independently TR 3/4 of y'all and haven't made up my mind on koala yet

starting to appreciate why people glazed over when i used to get in arguments

That's fine. Mostly I've been hoping to enlighten Dousing. Probably spending too much time replying to Koala. Do they normally nitpick and come up with dramatic arguments? It just seems like they are constantly misunderstanding Bona in a really weird way.

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?g= ... oalaAttack
koala's last game (as town)

compare

Why do I have to do homework?? ):

I will try to give it a look-see.

[sweetandcool]

I lied haven't slept again yet, trying to

How do people feel about JimothyT

Admired by the ladies, successful/sexy businessman. Squeaky keen. Did I miss any relevant details?

[snowy801]

hot take you should get as many votes as posts made

This, but we'd have to ban a few players

[snowy801]

Also I just finished d1 and I say we kill eden

##vote Eden

[sweetandcool]

Also I just finished d1 and I say we kill eden

##vote Eden

I'm sure you need to go back to sleep, but maybe you will explain your reasoning tomorrow.

[snowy801]

Also I just finished d1 and I say we kill eden

##vote Eden

I'm sure you need to go back to sleep, but maybe you will explain your reasoning tomorrow.

No I'm still reading

He's just so useless

And scum probably, but mostly the useless thing

[snowy801]

Also I see now that you're clearly town, so that does resolve some side questions I had

Feel bad doing Foxy so dirty but it do be like that all the time

[snowy801]

It further occurs to me that I have no particular reason to town read bozo, except my personal bias

[sweetandcool]

It further occurs to me that I have no particular reason to town read bozo, except my personal bias

I think my positive feelings towards bozo stem from the fact that while they don't post often, I tend to find their posts leaning towards insightful. And they don't seem to be sucking up to me.

Certainly not enough to town read them, but enough reason for me to not be focused on them.