MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[snowy801]

*No it is not.

(Nearly used the edit function there!)

Why not?

[President Eden]

Oh dear me an RPer
and why is m!gandalf into self harm this game, if I may ask?

What is the tradition/promise you are upholding?

Why, the time-honored tradition of voting for self and getting chewed out for bad "Townie Play" that I've done in all of my 3 prior games! Before you ask, I was Townie in 2 of them and Mafia in 1, real traditions must be upheld regardless of alignment.

Also the promise to be GandalfKoala that I made to ghug and the playerbase in general in last game / Discord that's-now-disappeared.

##Vote KoalaAttack

Yes please! Thank you Jamiet, save me from getting sucked into this thread too much again. Must... be... more... lurker!

Emc had this terrible habit of lurking and never laying down a vote until the last minute, so I developed a "tradition" of voting him first no matter what to punish him for bad town play. Then we rolled scum together, and I bussed him from the first page to his D1 death and went on to win the game.

The lesson is, if Koala is scum, so is Jamie.

mid

Question for the group – I postulate that the Suspicious individuals who were excitedly active in the Sign Up thread 24 hours before the rest of us honest hobbits could be Mafia?

And who then does this paint as being mafia?

mid++

[Jamiet99uk]

*No it is not.

(Nearly used the edit function there!)

Why not?

Because Foxcastle is attempting to use an example of his own previous behaviour when scum with EMC, to predict how I would behave as part of a theoretical scum pairing with Koala (who I have never been scum with).

The logical progression does not hold up.

I am not Foxcastle and I do not behave like Foxcastle does. We're quite different people.

[snowy801]

*No it is not.

(Nearly used the edit function there!)

Why not?

Because Foxcastle is attempting to use an example of his own previous behaviour when scum with EMC, to predict how I would behave as part of a theoretical scum pairing with Koala (who I have never been scum with).

The logical progression does not hold up.

I am not Foxcastle and I do not behave like Foxcastle does. We're quite different people.

Do you reject his premise that your vote appears as a bus?

[ghug]

Also, I seem to have a delete button and an edit button (though only for a limited time). Is this new?

Uh oh.

[ghug]

This is what a Bruce Forsyth used to look like:

##VOTE Jammy Dodger because I hate pictures.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why not?

Because Foxcastle is attempting to use an example of his own previous behaviour when scum with EMC, to predict how I would behave as part of a theoretical scum pairing with Koala (who I have never been scum with).

The logical progression does not hold up.

I am not Foxcastle and I do not behave like Foxcastle does. We're quite different people.

Do you reject his premise that your vote appears as a bus?

Yes. There's no way he could know at this stage whether or not I would be bussing.

[President Eden]

This is what a Bruce Forsyth used to look like:

##VOTE Jammy Dodger because I hate pictures.

cheugy take

[President Eden]

Because Foxcastle is attempting to use an example of his own previous behaviour when scum with EMC, to predict how I would behave as part of a theoretical scum pairing with Koala (who I have never been scum with).

The logical progression does not hold up.

I am not Foxcastle and I do not behave like Foxcastle does. We're quite different people.

Do you reject his premise that your vote appears as a bus?

Yes. There's no way he could know at this stage whether or not I would be bussing.

mid---

[snowy801]

Because Foxcastle is attempting to use an example of his own previous behaviour when scum with EMC, to predict how I would behave as part of a theoretical scum pairing with Koala (who I have never been scum with).

The logical progression does not hold up.

I am not Foxcastle and I do not behave like Foxcastle does. We're quite different people.

Do you reject his premise that your vote appears as a bus?

Yes. There's no way he could know at this stage whether or not I would be bussing.

Of course not. The question is merely whether this action in absence of further evidence resembled known prior bus votes.

[ghug]

Why did we let people keep talking in the signups after PMs went out?

[President Eden]

Why did we let people keep talking in the signups after PMs went out?

kouncil sux

[Jamiet99uk]

Do you reject his premise that your vote appears as a bus?

Yes. There's no way he could know at this stage whether or not I would be bussing.

Of course not. The question is merely whether this action in absence of further evidence resembled known prior bus votes.

Foxcastle's argument was that it resembled known prior bus votes cast by Foxcastle.

Do you find that argument convincing for some reason?

[Jamiet99uk]

Why did we let people keep talking in the signups after PMs went out?

Kestas's rules apply.

[snowy801]

Yes. There's no way he could know at this stage whether or not I would be bussing.

Of course not. The question is merely whether this action in absence of further evidence resembled known prior bus votes.

Foxcastle's argument was that it resembled known prior bus votes cast by Foxcastle.

Do you find that argument convincing for some reason?

Not convincing, merely interesting.

[Jamiet99uk]

Of course not. The question is merely whether this action in absence of further evidence resembled known prior bus votes.

Foxcastle's argument was that it resembled known prior bus votes cast by Foxcastle.

Do you find that argument convincing for some reason?

Not convincing, merely interesting.

It is interesting that Foxcastle would make such an unconvincing argument, I agree with you.

What do you think his motivation was?

[snowy801]

Foxcastle's argument was that it resembled known prior bus votes cast by Foxcastle.

Do you find that argument convincing for some reason?

Not convincing, merely interesting.

It is interesting that Foxcastle would make such an unconvincing argument, I agree with you.

What do you think his motivation was?

Not sure.

@Foxcastle what was your motivation?

[Jamiet99uk]

That was some excellent content right there.

Now it's time for bed.

[Jamiet99uk]

Just for Ghug here is a picture of a bed:

[worcej]

Why did we let people keep talking in the signups after PMs went out?

kouncil sux

Eden nailed it. /s

But more because I forgot to ask for it.