M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Bonatogether]

##vote tfb

[BusinessLamp]

does a tie result in no one going?

[Donny Dude]

rip bozo

[goldfinger0303]

##vote HR - who did a whole re-read but couldn't pick up that I was sheeping ghug as a joke.

[goldfinger0303]

And a big fuckin rip to bozo.

[kgray]

does a tie result in no one going?

yes

[ghug]

I find it concerning that HR and kgray both started suspecting celaph during N1, spent the majority of D2 voting for him, then contributed to celaph almost avoiding the DK.

Like this post. Rip bozo (I peeked).

[ghug]

I find it concerning that HR and kgray both started suspecting celaph during N1, spent the majority of D2 voting for him, then contributed to celaph almost avoiding the DK.

Kgray moved a lot earlier, and is in my null pool, but this is a fair observation.

Kgray has, I notice, also defended / supported HR in comments earlier tonight.

Pretty sure most of my “defense” of HR is just disagreeing with ghug’s iffy assumption that HR participating only near EOD D1 is scummy.

That's still a defense...

[Hellenic Riot]

##vote HR - who did a whole re-read but couldn't pick up that I was sheeping ghug as a joke.

Stop memeing, Jamiet is a bad vote compared to what's else is up there.

Never felt too strongly about celaph, so since ghug is off I'm off too.

##vote bob

This may well have been very hedged, but you were absolutely not saying it was a joke yesterday. Try again.

[kgray]

Kgray moved a lot earlier, and is in my null pool, but this is a fair observation.

Kgray has, I notice, also defended / supported HR in comments earlier tonight.

Pretty sure most of my “defense” of HR is just disagreeing with ghug’s iffy assumption that HR participating only near EOD D1 is scummy.

That's still a defense...

It's not actually it says nothing about HR as town vs scum, it says only that your case is based on nonsense, which actually only looks bad for you. You could be making a terrible case to get a miskill or pushing someone you know is scum but without having any good reason, like I did with Chaqa in that game where Flum could only vote.

[Donny Dude]

Hr, of your 3 scenarios do you feel is most likely?

[Hellenic Riot]

ghug you're so hard to please.

##vote celaph

Stop memeing, Jamiet is a bad vote compared to what's else is up there.

Never felt too strongly about celaph, so since ghug is off I'm off too.

##vote bob

Stop memeing, Jamiet is a bad vote compared to what's else is up there.

Never felt too strongly about celaph, so since ghug is off I'm off too.

##vote bob

Is this because I made a solid response to your scumread of me so you need to gloss over it real quick?

I haven't even seen your response. I'm stealing glances at this when I can, but my family came down for the weekend to help me out with repairs and I just finished with a contractor getting estimates

All right, I'm off til the end of phase. Whoever we end up on, I hope they're scum.

I don't like celaph or Vecna, of the leaders. Try to stay off them.

These were goldie's last four posts of D2. The celaph vote may well have been a sheep, but it didn't say it was a joke either at the time it was cast or much more importantly at the time near EoD when it was withdrawn. Ten minutes later the POV had changed to "Stay off celaph".


Come on Goldie. Take two for an explanation, before I have to set Jamie on you.

[Hellenic Riot]

Hr, of your 3 scenarios do you feel is most likely?

Scenario A makes the people I townread look the most townie, and I'm okay to handwave Bob's VCA away because I think he was extremely townie in his posting through both EoD's. So I lean toward that. Scenario B is also reasonably plausible though.

I find it very unlikely that TFB is a Mafia PR because of celaph's vote for him and because it makes people I don't really scumread look much worse.

I'd probably go 60 - 35 - 5 in terms of percentages.

[Hellenic Riot]

Friendly Advice: If you're gonna choke up and be unable to respond to a question, you should probably turn your activity indicator off.

https://i.gyazo.com/eace576d7bbc26da920 ... 1effb7.png

[Chaqa]

Friendly Advice: If you're gonna choke up and be unable to respond to a question, you should probably turn your activity indicator off.

https://i.gyazo.com/eace576d7bbc26da920 ... 1effb7.png

Mine shows no one here, to be fair. It isn't super accurate.

[Chaqa]

https://i.imgur.com/LI5Ve0f.png

[Hellenic Riot]

Friendly Advice: If you're gonna choke up and be unable to respond to a question, you should probably turn your activity indicator off.

https://i.gyazo.com/eace576d7bbc26da920 ... 1effb7.png

Mine shows no one here, to be fair. It isn't super accurate.

That's because I waited to see if he was writing an answer before posting that screenshot, else I'd look like the dumbass.

[Chaqa]

I want to ##Vote BusinessLamp

[Hellenic Riot]

https://i.imgur.com/LI5Ve0f.png

https://i.gyazo.com/fee1f7b4457c70092bf ... bd0cf7.png

As you can see, I took the screenshot a few minutes after my question when I noticed him crop up again, and then waited til he'd definitely gone away before posting. This ain't my first rodeo.

[Chaqa]

Or he could have gotten up from his computer, and it left the page open, and he hasn't even seen it yet.

BS like that is why I leave my activity hidden