M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[goldfinger0303]

Anyone want me to explain why I'm voting for Vecna?

To me it's just making mountains of not much. The majority of those posts are from the first half of D1, and you're taking some serious reads on statements that I don't think we're made very seriously. You accuse most of his posts being sarcasm and such, but those were first half of D1 posts.

At the very most, I would consider it slightly suspect behavior (mainly the inconsistency you said around Durga and buddying of blamp), but I would never advocate a case on Fox/Vecna based on that alone, when there's so many other targets that could have better cases made of them.

[goldfinger0303]

I asked bozo at least twice if he had any reads or other thoughts. He gave one rather uninspired list of names which he has done nothing with and then left. Just because people haven't been answering my questions which are trying to get something out of them, doesn't mean I didn't ask them.

I suppose I should just start asking rhetorical questions because they're more valuable according to your iso?

That's not the majority of your discussion with bozo though. Half of it dissolved into nonsense about other games, which is 100% on brand for what bozo does *every game* and is NAI. And don't give me sass, it won't deflect anything off of you. Yes, if you ask a rhetorical question that leads to a follow-up read or analysis, that's fine. That's what I tend to do. My point being though, is that I don't see a quality of effort from you. And if you actually are town, your flip won't reveal anything because you're so widely scumread.

[goldfinger0303]

Okay, "anything" was too strong. But it won't be as useful as you think.

[BobMcBob]

Okay, it's time to have some Actual Content TM and Non-Reactionary Ideas (C)!
Since apparently nobody liked Question Time.

Blamp is towncore, I doubt a new player, even one with this much survivor experience, would be this towny and, more importantly, coherent and self-consistent as scum.

I've already stated my case on Maniac. I don't think he's super scummy, but I do still doubt that he would only ever mention me as town. He is almost certainly trying to coast through at least these first couple of days without actually contributing much. There is potential he might do that as town too though, so only a scumlean.

Damo made a reads post. That's all the actual content he's done so far. Everything else has been one liners, bad maths and that's it? He asked why there was a celaph wagon and hasn't been called out for it, maybe I should do that. Does he understand any wagons?
That said, this is not all that out of the ordinary for damo, as bad as it may be. So I guess maybe null?

Foxcastle came in, insulted everyone for not being serious enough, and then proceeded to sarcastically joke about things for the rest of his posts. Vecna has been a marked step up from that. But still not good. He hasn't really contributed anything that feels like hunting yet, mostly just one-liners. There's a possible excuse of busy or not invested yet, but a decent wagon today, and if this stuff continues into tomorrow it starts looking even better.

That's enough soulless appeasement of the town for now, I will continue later after doing some other things.

[DemonRHK]

the ghug fake claim tell means little to me because any adept scum would know the situation and thus be able to fake a reaction that’s genuine? Perhaps would be more apt to knowing that they’re eventually going to be proven right?

You can look at my scum games. I ain't that adept.

I haven't done a lot this game, true. Neither have a LOT of people. Was my math stuff trying to make chicken salad out of chicken shit multiple bottles of sake in? Yea. WAs it valuble? Remains to be seen.

I think damo was much more disinterested D1 than a town damo is. I think his math he tried was wrong becuase he's not playing from a town perspective.

I like jamie's case of Vecna/Fox, and think that should be a wagon as well, but when most of the case is I am weird and not scummy, I call it as I smell it, horseshit.

It's not about wordcount alone damo. The wordcount is just an indicator you put in less work than:

- A player that subbed out.
- A player with a home emergency.
- Everyone. Literally.

damo and Vecna are both scummy. We flip one of these two as scum and the game becomes solvable. Neither have done shit and are content to let us circlejerk the celaph and bob wagons, which are likely TvT (Yes, I was scumleaning cel for D1 but not any longer).

[BobMcBob]

I asked bozo at least twice if he had any reads or other thoughts. He gave one rather uninspired list of names which he has done nothing with and then left. Just because people haven't been answering my questions which are trying to get something out of them, doesn't mean I didn't ask them.

I suppose I should just start asking rhetorical questions because they're more valuable according to your iso?

That's not the majority of your discussion with bozo though. Half of it dissolved into nonsense about other games, which is 100% on brand for what bozo does *every game* and is NAI. And don't give me sass, it won't deflect anything off of you. Yes, if you ask a rhetorical question that leads to a follow-up read or analysis, that's fine. That's what I tend to do. My point being though, is that I don't see a quality of effort from you. And if you actually are town, your flip won't reveal anything because you're so widely scumread.

Oh darn. Better not flip me then.

[DemonRHK]

Welcome to D2 btw. I am cosplaying Krellin. Get your complaints over harsh language PMs for the GMs ready.

[damo666]

@gold what is the w I haven't a?

[DemonRHK]

rdrivera - playing his usual solid town game. Towncore.

Also what in the KENTUCKY FRIED FUCKERY is this read??

[damo666]

@demon how dies miscounting the number of people whose name starts with B be indicative of my alignment. Don't be daft.

[damo666]

rdrivera - playing his usual solid town game. Towncore.

Also what in the KENTUCKY FRIED FUCKERY is this read??

An accurate one imo

[DemonRHK]

@demon how dies miscounting the number of people whose name starts with B be indicative of my alignment. Don't be daft.

Then how does shit ass word-count math determine mine?

You don't get it both ways.

[damo666]

@demon how dies miscounting the number of people whose name starts with B be indicative of my alignment. Don't be daft.

Then how does shit ass word-count math determine mine?

You don't get it both ways.

The metric itself was pants. Screamed of content for appearances sake. I was merely responding to Jamie's question.

[damo666]

I get to eat my cake and keep it.

[damo666]

##vote demonRHK

[Durga]

@demon how dies miscounting the number of people whose name starts with B be indicative of my alignment. Don't be daft.

Then how does shit ass word-count math determine mine?

You don't get it both ways.

LOL okay this is funny

[DemonRHK]

I get to eat my cake and keep it.

Can you do me a solid and slip your last teammate?

I wish I could take credit for gamesolving but Jamie has put in work.

I townread more people on the donny wagon, but the flum convo will not go away till one of flum or jamie is dead. Ghug is a meh 3rd wagon.

Anyone0 feeling a flash ##vote damo wagon?

I don't want to flash someone who said he won't be here for EOD but hmu tomorrow

...

Damo and Chaqa should start getting more pressure soon as they’re all playing extraordinarily lazy so far. HR is usually more obnoxious in his pushes as town so I’m a little confused that I didn’t actively hate him while he was pushing me this time. That unironically makes me think he might be scum. Especially now that he's link RDR to me, with an excuse to townread him after I flip.

...

RESPECT. THE. DEAD.

[goldfinger0303]

The NK probably implies one of my supposed towncore is scum.

@ghug silly reaction test

Chaqa no longer scum suspect

@Demo you just want to look at total wordcount as a metric

@Jamie from what pov and at what stage?

Basically 1 - ((PlayerCount-Bcount)C5/PlayercountC5)

I hate this post.

Damo, how can it be a silly reaction test if you now no longer suspect Chaqa of being scum? Would you have felt the same way if Chaqa claimed and nobody counter-claimed?

Also while I understand the interaction between Chaqa and ghug can be convincing, we cannot rule out that scum RB'd DeathLlama. There's only two PRs, and if they thought DL was one, it's a 50/50 chance its Doc. If I was scum I'd be roleblocking my kill every night. Why is nobody else even mentioning this possibility?

Reposting for damo.

[Bonatogether]

Okay, it's time to have some Actual Content TM and Non-Reactionary Ideas (C)!
Since apparently nobody liked Question Time.

Blamp is towncore, I doubt a new player, even one with this much survivor experience, would be this towny and, more importantly, coherent and self-consistent as scum.

This is terrible reasoning. I don't think it is entirely fair to say that blamp is inexperienced and that the survivor doesn't translate over, because clearly blamp is acting like a reasonably experienced player, so saying that he can't be scum is really just not true. Blamp is towny but nowhere near towncore or even a strong townread because we don't know how he'd be playing this as scum

[Bonatogether]

rdrivera - playing his usual solid town game. Towncore.

Also what in the KENTUCKY FRIED FUCKERY is this read??

An accurate one imo

he's not anywhere near towncore lmao