M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[DeathLlama8]

Im getting weird flum energy.
Lamp has the new person feel.

- flum had three shitposts when you said this, what was weird about it

Bona, you are cringe for this post, but I forgive you. But so long as you +1 my posts you are safe from any votes early in the game.

- initially scumread tfb (and also +1'd the ghug post) because it's an incredibly awkward response to some minimal early pressure. kind of "I'm obligated to respond to it because it scumreads me, but idk what to write" vibes. The later discussion with ghug seems fine though

you know that feeling when you walk/drive past a cop and your heart starts racing even though you are a law-abiding citizen?

that is how i feel any time i press the submit button

- this has probably been said but I have a hard time imagining new scum making this post so early

It's an incredibly lazy post for Bozo, and seems rather arbitrary even beyond that, as I don't think anyone has done anything super town-ish yet, but somehow he's classified at least 12 players as having done so. His list reeks of easy D1 kills.

- I'm not thrilled with the Bozo post either but this seems like a lazy attempt to attribute scum motivations to something that doesn't seem alignment indicative

- Donny's indignation during that interaction with celaph seemed pretty genuine. I don't see why it would be explicitly town-indicative but it feels townie to me?

[DeathLlama8]

Flum, what did you expect our reaction to the trust tell to be and are we doing that?

[DeathLlama8]

feeling a ##vote bobmcbob tbh

[DeathLlama8]

he's been vaguely around and throwing a lot of weird shade without really looking for mafia

like

Final thoughts for the night. Bona is cool. I have no issues with TFB. Ghug is making some odd logics but it's nothing alarming. Blamp is pretty cool. We're probably just gonna end up shooting lurker #2 at this rate, but as long as it's not goldfinger... sure, it's acceptable.

these are not the words of someone who particularly cares who dies d1

[bozotheclown]

I'm gonna need to explain why you have Donny and Rivera on here but not Bob, theflyingboat, Flum or Fox, please.

Bob and TFB seem to be trying to generate discussion. I get the feeling Foxcastle was looking for reactions with his one longer post. Fluminator said he was town.

Generating discussion on what? Memes? OOG factors? And Fox stated he was looking for laughs. You think that's towny, or do you think he was actually looking for some sort of alignment-indicative reactions? But mostly, you think Flum stating he's town is more town-motivated than two of the people on your list who actually provided some form of a read?

I don't know what OOG means, but yes, I thought it could be a type of reaction test. Fluminator saying he is town is a good indicator, certainly good enough for D1.

[Bonatogether]

I don't know about Kgray. Not very active so far outside of commenting on TFB and Ghug. Need to see more. No town vibes today. Kgray usually.... tries?

I find Ghug hard to read although there are some little tells he has, which I have my eyes, ears, and nostrils open for.

That's fair.
I do have to agree with your damo take above.
I was going to use blamp as a Durga reader but now don't think thats a good idea.

yeah this is definitely a bad idea. For one, Durga and I mostly communicate over voice calls and have never been in a game environment together, so the mode of communication does not lend itself for me to have any more knowledge than others. Also, I have no idea how good at this in general I am lmao. No idea how solid my reads will be or if I'll be way way off.

not to mention, while i appreciate the trust, using anyone else as an indicator feels like it would just be a way to scapegoat/transfer blame to that person later on.

blamp, this is a stupid take

also the sudden jump to talk formally from not even capitalizing makes me kinda scumread you cause i do that sometimes when i'm lying. also you go back to not capitalizing like a nerd next paragraph

[Bonatogether]

Im getting weird flum energy.
Lamp has the new person feel.

- flum had three shitposts when you said this, what was weird about it

Bona, you are cringe for this post, but I forgive you. But so long as you +1 my posts you are safe from any votes early in the game.

- initially scumread tfb (and also +1'd the ghug post) because it's an incredibly awkward response to some minimal early pressure. kind of "I'm obligated to respond to it because it scumreads me, but idk what to write" vibes. The later discussion with ghug seems fine though

you know that feeling when you walk/drive past a cop and your heart starts racing even though you are a law-abiding citizen?

that is how i feel any time i press the submit button

- this has probably been said but I have a hard time imagining new scum making this post so early

It's an incredibly lazy post for Bozo, and seems rather arbitrary even beyond that, as I don't think anyone has done anything super town-ish yet, but somehow he's classified at least 12 players as having done so. His list reeks of easy D1 kills.

- I'm not thrilled with the Bozo post either but this seems like a lazy attempt to attribute scum motivations to something that doesn't seem alignment indicative

- Donny's indignation during that interaction with celaph seemed pretty genuine. I don't see why it would be explicitly town-indicative but it feels townie to me?

2) what 'early' (what does that work even mean when we're not even past page 50) pressure boat man recieving?

3) people said that for me after the whole 'kill the highposters' thing and they said it for sabi after the scumteams townslip and it was not good for them

[bozotheclown]

I will say it is somewhat impressive how many posts Bona has made without saying anything, but that's D1 Bona I guess?

Do you think Chaqa and Demon still merit spots on your list after today's posts?

Can you explain your view on Donny further?

Non-posters italicized. People who have made public preemptory excused have been underlined.

What do you make of rdr's defense of you?

Maybe not for DemonRHK, but Chaqa's attempt to wagon me based on questionable logic and and a mischaracterization of my post does not seem town motivated.

Donny, like Bonatogether, had posted a lot, but had not seemed to take a position on anyone despite the high number of posts.

rdrivera's defense could be town motivated or a pocketing attempt, but I do not recall rdrivera ever trying to pocket me when he was mafia.

What did Demon do that made you change your mind, and do you not think he's just as likely to be attempting to pocket you as Rivera?

Also, Donny townread ghug so you are incorrect in saying he has not taken a position on anyone.

Maybe RHK qualifying his defense with saying it was low effort made me less likely to think it might be pocketing. Maybe RHK has mastered the art of pocketing with just enough criticism to alleviate the suspicion of pocketing.

[Bonatogether]

he's been vaguely around and throwing a lot of weird shade without really looking for mafia

like

Final thoughts for the night. Bona is cool. I have no issues with TFB. Ghug is making some odd logics but it's nothing alarming. Blamp is pretty cool. We're probably just gonna end up shooting lurker #2 at this rate, but as long as it's not goldfinger... sure, it's acceptable.

these are not the words of someone who particularly cares who dies d1

??????????

he hasn't shaded anyone?

[kgray]

he's been vaguely around and throwing a lot of weird shade without really looking for mafia

like

Final thoughts for the night. Bona is cool. I have no issues with TFB. Ghug is making some odd logics but it's nothing alarming. Blamp is pretty cool. We're probably just gonna end up shooting lurker #2 at this rate, but as long as it's not goldfinger... sure, it's acceptable.

these are not the words of someone who particularly cares who dies d1

idk I've really vibed with some of his posts and I don't think it's that scummy to not care who dies d1. Unless we get lucky with someone being obvscum it's pretty hard for me to make reads d1, let alone champion a wagon.

[DeathLlama8]

2) what 'early' (what does that work even mean when we're not even past page 50) pressure boat man receiving?

like you and kgray calling him scummy on page 7 or smth

3) people said that for me after the whole 'kill the highposters' thing and they said it for sabi after the scumteams townslip and it was not good for them

yeah obviously it's not ironclad halfway through d1 but i wouldn't want to kill the lamp today

[bozotheclown]

I will say it is somewhat impressive how many posts Bona has made without saying anything, but that's D1 Bona I guess?

Do you think Chaqa and Demon still merit spots on your list after today's posts?

Can you explain your view on Donny further?

Non-posters italicized. People who have made public preemptory excused have been underlined.

What do you make of rdr's defense of you?

Maybe not for DemonRHK, but Chaqa's attempt to wagon me based on questionable logic and and a mischaracterization of my post does not seem town motivated.

Donny, like Bonatogether, had posted a lot, but had not seemed to take a position on anyone despite the high number of posts.

rdrivera's defense could be town motivated or a pocketing attempt, but I do not recall rdrivera ever trying to pocket me when he was mafia.

What did Demon do that made you change your mind, and do you not think he's just as likely to be attempting to pocket you as Rivera?

Also, Donny townread ghug so you are incorrect in saying he has not taken a position on anyone.

Donny's read of ghug falls too much within the range of potential pocketing for me to conclude it is town motivated.

[BusinessLamp]

##Vote Bozotheclown

It's an incredibly lazy post for Bozo, and seems rather arbitrary even beyond that, as I don't think anyone has done anything super town-ish yet, but somehow he's classified at least 12 players as having done so. His list reeks of easy D1 kills.

It is 11 players, and I never said they have all done something "super town-ish" yet, I only implied they have posted at least one thing that seemed to me to have a town motivation. That is a significant mischaracterization when you are trying to start a wagon on me.

wouldn't it be better to list the people you thought were town and why? rather than just giving a list of people you seemingly feel nothing about

[kgray]

Bob and TFB seem to be trying to generate discussion. I get the feeling Foxcastle was looking for reactions with his one longer post. Fluminator said he was town.

Generating discussion on what? Memes? OOG factors? And Fox stated he was looking for laughs. You think that's towny, or do you think he was actually looking for some sort of alignment-indicative reactions? But mostly, you think Flum stating he's town is more town-motivated than two of the people on your list who actually provided some form of a read?

I don't know what OOG means, but yes, I thought it could be a type of reaction test. Fluminator saying he is town is a good indicator, certainly good enough for D1.

OOG is out of game, like the puzzle thing boatman was talking about. Basically irrelevant, and therefore I don't understand why you think talking about those kinds of things would be towny.

I'll assume you're trolling with the last sentence because I can't see you being that silly as either town or scum lmao

[Bonatogether]

2) what 'early' (what does that work even mean when we're not even past page 50) pressure boat man receiving?

like you and kgray calling him scummy on page 7 or smth

3) people said that for me after the whole 'kill the highposters' thing and they said it for sabi after the scumteams townslip and it was not good for them

yeah obviously it's not ironclad halfway through d1 but i wouldn't want to kill the lamp today

we literally said he wasn't being scummy then you dummy

[BusinessLamp]

im already voting sabi

You are voting for Chaqa.

That is an interesting oversight from bona.

What do you think it could indicate?

[DeathLlama8]

lmfao guess I'll go back to lurking

[DeathLlama8]

boatman seems scummy to me based on his posts so far

[Bonatogether]

You are voting for Chaqa.

That is an interesting oversight from bona.

What do you think it could indicate?

say what you think

asking stupid questions does nothing

[DeathLlama8]

boatman seems scummy to me based on his posts so far

seconded