M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

Do we want to just hammer Durga? lol

##unend

Never gonna happen, need 9.

A bit odd you unend once someone else supports it.

[BesharamSabi]

VOTE COUNT VERSION 3.03

RISE AND SHINE

Durga (7) kgrey ghug BusinessLamp TheFlyingBoat goldfinger0303 Jamiet99uk damo666
Hellenic Riot (4) Maniac rdrivera2005 Chaqa BobMcBob
goldfinger0303 (1) Hellenic Riot
Vecna (1) DemonRHK
TheFlyingBoat (1) Bonatogether

Non-votes Donny Dude, Durga, Vecna

DURGA IS SET TO BE SENT TO THE GALLOWS

EOD IS IN 8.5 HOURS

The Dingo Fence in Australia is longer than the distance between New York City to London.

[Tom Bombadil]

##CALL GM

Maniac is not meaningfully participating in the game. Can you replace him please.

If a player is being subbed out for failing to adhere to participation rules, there will be a GM post announcing the substitution.

[damo666]

Do we want to just hammer Durga? lol

##unend

Never gonna happen, need 9.

A bit odd you unend once someone else supports it.

You didn't support it, merely suggested it. I don't want to hammer, as I said before I was just stressing I'm not moving.

[Chaqa]

##unend

Never gonna happen, need 9.

A bit odd you unend once someone else supports it.

You didn't support it, merely suggested it. I don't want to hammer, as I said before I was just stressing I'm not moving.

Weird

[ghug]

The above post is Maniac nothing us discussing his town meta and attempting to replicate it, without making any meaningful contribution to the game.

We're now in the middle of D3 and he hasn't made any attempt to find scum.

This was my first reaction to this, but he actually made a legitimate post this phase:

##vote HR

His D1 vote could be trying to save scum buddy Bob or TFB.
His D2 vote could be moving from scum buddy Celaph to Scum Buddy TFB for town cred.
What really jumps out to me though is his strong scum reading of Celaph and then almost zero advocating for his daykill especially in final minutes when it was still likely. HR I’m general strikes me as a leader who when he is convinced someone is scum will push that kill. His sliding on to someone who he hasn’t really expressed a strong scum read on seems out of town!HR character.

[ghug]

I dont like the way damo progressed on blamp and just gave it up after minimal pressure.

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

Scumread this, kgray. I dare you.

[Chaqa]

Damo must be town because he fell for the bofa joke

[Jamiet99uk]

Do we want to just hammer Durga? lol

##unend

Never gonna happen, need 9.

Interesting that you remove your endvote as soon as someone else is considering it.

[Jamiet99uk]

The above post is Maniac nothing us discussing his town meta and attempting to replicate it, without making any meaningful contribution to the game.

We're now in the middle of D3 and he hasn't made any attempt to find scum.

This was my first reaction to this, but he actually made a legitimate post this phase:

##vote HR

His D1 vote could be trying to save scum buddy Bob or TFB.
His D2 vote could be moving from scum buddy Celaph to Scum Buddy TFB for town cred.
What really jumps out to me though is his strong scum reading of Celaph and then almost zero advocating for his daykill especially in final minutes when it was still likely. HR I’m general strikes me as a leader who when he is convinced someone is scum will push that kill. His sliding on to someone who he hasn’t really expressed a strong scum read on seems out of town!HR character.

So one legitimate post per phase is your threshold for "meaningful participation"?

Pretty low bar.

[damo666]

Do we want to just hammer Durga? lol

##unend

Never gonna happen, need 9.

Interesting that you remove your endvote as soon as someone else is considering it.

I've addressed this.

[ghug]

I dont like the way damo progressed on blamp and just gave it up after minimal pressure.

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

Bona’s insistence that it should’ve been boatman is weird but I see no reason why he’d fake all that emotion as scum when boatman was (incorrectly imo) calling him out for being “too weird” like an hour before. Bona would steer away from that if he were scum. Also he always latches on to a read like that as town, as I mentioned D2.

I'm torn on this. It's over the top, and he's all about the too scummy to be scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

##unend

Never gonna happen, need 9.

Interesting that you remove your endvote as soon as someone else is considering it.

I've addressed this.

##End

[kgray]

I dont like the way damo progressed on blamp and just gave it up after minimal pressure.

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

Scumread this, kgray. I dare you.

I mean I don't townread it

[Maniac]

##CALL GM

Maniac is not meaningfully participating in the game. Can you replace him please.

Jamie, just fuck off, carry on fucking off until you get to fuck off land and when you get there fuck off some more

[ghug]

The above post is Maniac nothing us discussing his town meta and attempting to replicate it, without making any meaningful contribution to the game.

We're now in the middle of D3 and he hasn't made any attempt to find scum.

This was my first reaction to this, but he actually made a legitimate post this phase:

##vote HR

His D1 vote could be trying to save scum buddy Bob or TFB.
His D2 vote could be moving from scum buddy Celaph to Scum Buddy TFB for town cred.
What really jumps out to me though is his strong scum reading of Celaph and then almost zero advocating for his daykill especially in final minutes when it was still likely. HR I’m general strikes me as a leader who when he is convinced someone is scum will push that kill. His sliding on to someone who he hasn’t really expressed a strong scum read on seems out of town!HR character.

So one legitimate post per phase is your threshold for "meaningful participation"?

Pretty low bar.

He's making multiple posts and not all of them are trolling. That's enough for me.

[ghug]

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

Scumread this, kgray. I dare you.

I mean I don't townread it

Why not?

[kgray]

Scumread this, kgray. I dare you.

I mean I don't townread it

Why not?

I don't know, I don't really have an opinion about it I guess. I was thinking about looking to see if town!damo or scum!damo is more likely to be open to outside input for his assumptions/conclusions but I haven't done that.

[kgray]

Anyway I have pretty much zero doubts that Durga is scum at this point

[ghug]

Anyway I have pretty much zero doubts that Durga is scum at this point

That's where I'm at too.

##VOTE HR