M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

Donny is the only one I trust now

i think we can trust bona too

I feel pretty good about Bozo, Donny, and Jamie.

[ghug]

why do you doubt boatman is mafia?

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

kargy looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

FTFY

[Chaqa]

Also RDR

[Bonatogether]

Is this a scumslip?

Is this scum theater?

Are we scum buddies?

probably

[kgray]

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

bob looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

The idea that I'd bus for 99.9% of a day and then move off right before I got any credit for it deeply amuses me

i mean it's not like you actually pushed celaph 99.9% of the day, you moved when boatman had traction and could've died instead of celaph, and i yelled at you to do it so you had an excuse. it's not an impossible scenario

plus you get to make this exact argument

[BobMcBob]

why do you doubt boatman is mafia?

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

bob looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

Oi! I made a very high effort post containing a thoughtful analysis of celaph's iso and then backed off.

[ghug]

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

kargy looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

FTFY

Also you misgendered yourself.

[TheFlyingBoat]

i don't believe town makes the moves that you made, such as literally ignoring everything people told you (kgray telling you my meta) and asked you (my question as to why you were phrasing things as though you hadn't done legitimately scummy things)

I mean you can't have it both ways. I can't be attacked for using what others give me as your meta analysis and applying it to what I see from you and then also attack me for not taking kgray's word as the word of god on the matter. I weighed them both against each other and given your most recent town game vs the games from a year ago that kgray mentioned, I figured I'd like basing my read on the common refrain wrt your meta style over kgray's analysis from games that were played a year ago that I didn't have the ability to read myself.

When did I EVER attack you for using what other people told you? You only talked about m1016 or whatever the fuck you were prattling on about. You keep not reading beyond the first fucking sentence of my messages in these dipshit 'responses' you keep pushing out for some reason.

Those games are not from a year ago, those are from like, 5, 6 months ago? You could also take kgray's word, or ask @bob or whoever else was in those games.

kgray literally said the vt game was probably from a year ago when I asked her how old it was to aid my search

[BobMcBob]

Is this a scumslip?

Is this scum theater?

Are we scum buddies?

Is this a PR claim?

[kgray]

Donny is the only one I trust now

i thought you were my sidekick

can i take his place?

[bozotheclown]

why do you doubt boatman is mafia?

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

How do you think that tallies with how long the TFB wagon took to overtake celaph and start consolidating?

I am not sure I understand the question, but there were other available counter wagons until EOD.

[kgray]

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

kargy looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

FTFY

who's kargy? they sounds like a terrible player

[rdrivera2005]

Why do I get the feeling I could give you my username and password, let you log into my account, let you read my town role pm, and then still have you come back and tell me I was scum?

This is an exact facsimile of my relationship with Ghug.

Well, I do kinda like your deciding vote on celaph.

I thought my vote was deciding but then I look the bot.

Anyway, great outcome I said I can't see town emotion on Celaph today.

I don't think TFB is scum. Bob still possible.

[Bonatogether]

Donny is the only one I trust now

i thought you were my sidekick

can i take his place?

sure

[Hellenic Riot]

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

How do you think that tallies with how long the TFB wagon took to overtake celaph and start consolidating?

I am not sure I understand the question, but there were other available counter wagons until EOD.

Yes. My question is why you think the didn't the scum consolidate on them

[Bonatogether]

I mean you can't have it both ways. I can't be attacked for using what others give me as your meta analysis and applying it to what I see from you and then also attack me for not taking kgray's word as the word of god on the matter. I weighed them both against each other and given your most recent town game vs the games from a year ago that kgray mentioned, I figured I'd like basing my read on the common refrain wrt your meta style over kgray's analysis from games that were played a year ago that I didn't have the ability to read myself.

When did I EVER attack you for using what other people told you? You only talked about m1016 or whatever the fuck you were prattling on about. You keep not reading beyond the first fucking sentence of my messages in these dipshit 'responses' you keep pushing out for some reason.

Those games are not from a year ago, those are from like, 5, 6 months ago? You could also take kgray's word, or ask @bob or whoever else was in those games.

kgray literally said the vt game was probably from a year ago when I asked her how old it was to aid my search

you're like, great at reading posts but terrible at really understanding them

[Hellenic Riot]

How do you think that tallies with how long the TFB wagon took to overtake celaph and start consolidating?

I am not sure I understand the question, but there were other available counter wagons until EOD.

Yes. My question is why you think the didn't the scum consolidate on them

*scum didn't consolidate

[Bonatogether]

When did I EVER attack you for using what other people told you? You only talked about m1016 or whatever the fuck you were prattling on about. You keep not reading beyond the first fucking sentence of my messages in these dipshit 'responses' you keep pushing out for some reason.

Those games are not from a year ago, those are from like, 5, 6 months ago? You could also take kgray's word, or ask @bob or whoever else was in those games.

kgray literally said the vt game was probably from a year ago when I asked her how old it was to aid my search

you're like, great at reading posts but terrible at really understanding them

you're totally ignoring the point of the post

[bozotheclown]

And now I can't claim they all sheeped me. Dang & Blast.

Why didn't you change your vote back to celaph before EOD?

Because jumping between the two main wagons is very liable to cause a tie and I'm not that much of an idiot.

I think you had to move back without increasing the risk of a tie, and I would expect you would be motivated to see celaph DKed.

[Chaqa]

I think HR is nearly confScum based off wagonomics.

He'll be my preferred vote tomorrow