M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[kgray]

The other thing I've done so far today is iso tfb's day 2 and look somewhat into the case on him, and it's okayish. I would rather vote celaph though. I don't think TFB has been particularly scummy, although he has certainly been strange. And I like the celaph wagon.

did you read celaph's d2 and if so did it change your mind?

[TheFlyingBoat]

You're basing this off reputation and hearsay??
Although defensive, I dont like TFB using meta of others read of bona as a way to hedge. It feels weak and more like looking for a reason to scumread someone.
Is your read of bona still null?

Yeah I was coming around on him and was thinking about bumping him up to slight town because he was making better posts and promising some interesting analysis for a while but then it never came and looking back that EOD that I previously handwaved away is a little more sus than I gave it credit for

did you miss my post where i said i was busy for like, most of the day

Probably.

[Hellenic Riot]

@TFB

Do you really not have any better scumread than a slot that has been essentially absent for 95% of the game? What do you think about the other wagons? What do you think about your own wagon & the people on it?

[kgray]

I think a tfb wagon also makes sense. I feel like his game so far has been agree with Jamie over something stupid, push that, watch Flum get killed despite thinking he;'s town (?), and then disappearing

Was scrolling back through the thread and noticed this. I am not sure where any of my D1 posts make you think I thought Flum was town, given I spent 7 hours hammering the fact I think he was scum, articulating reasons I think others could be tied to him as a scum team member, and explicitly pushed others like bozo to vote for Flum at the EOD (also why I found the claims that I was trying to get other wagons going to save Flum or whatever ridiculous) and I don't think it's fair to accuse me of disappearing when I have the 8th highest post count, the 2nd highest word count, middle of the pack post count for today, and the highest word count today.

If breaking up my reads list into 18 posts and making my long responses with grouped posts into like 6 posts would make you think I am more engaged, maybe I'll do that next game, but this is is silly. I've also already responded to your claim that I only respond when summoned which is also off base.

this would be the scummiest most overly-defensive post i've ever seen if it wasn't from you

[Durga]

I think a tfb wagon also makes sense. I feel like his game so far has been agree with Jamie over something stupid, push that, watch Flum get killed despite thinking he;'s town (?), and then disappearing

Was scrolling back through the thread and noticed this. I am not sure where any of my D1 posts make you think I thought Flum was town, given I spent 7 hours hammering the fact I think he was scum, articulating reasons I think others could be tied to him as a scum team member, and explicitly pushed others like bozo to vote for Flum at the EOD (also why I found the claims that I was trying to get other wagons going to save Flum or whatever ridiculous) and I don't think it's fair to accuse me of disappearing when I have the 8th highest post count, the 2nd highest word count, middle of the pack post count for today, and the highest word count today.

If breaking up my reads list into 18 posts and making my long responses with grouped posts into like 6 posts would make you think I am more engaged, maybe I'll do that next game, but this is is silly. I've also already responded to your claim that I only respond when summoned which is also off base.

there was this whole thing at the end where you said you thought he was town ultimately but didn't move off him? or am i misremembering that

[kgray]

i kinda want to flash someone but idk who

[BesharamSabi]

VOTE COUNT VERSION 2.09

TheFlyingBoat (5)
Bonatogether Durga Chaqa celaph kgray
celaph (4)
Hellenic Riot Vecna ghug goldfinger0303
BobMcBob (4)
Maniac rdrivera2005 Donny Dude damo666
Vecna (4)
Jamiet99uk TheFlyingBoat bozotheclown DemonRHK
Unvote (1)
BusinessLamp
goldfinger0303 (1)
BobMcBob


BOATMAN IS GOING TO BE EATEN BY TERMITES

EOD in 30 minutes

[Bonatogether]

Why?

it's just obviously bad

No, give an actual answer.

they go from soft scumreading each other to instantly both townreading each other (or not being as aggro) in a way that set off every alarm bell for me

[Chaqa]

Jamie leave me alone before I vote you

You don’t like it when other people joke?

Where is the joke

Ok Jamie

[Durga]

i kinda want to flash someone but idk who

best comedic value would be jamie

[Bonatogether]

I wasn't saying the EOD was weird for town. I was saying it was him trying to replicate his normal weirdness but in the attempt to do so created something that weird for bona and didn't seem right.

Do you have a link to that game?

no i don't remember the numbers. he was scum in jamie's multi-mafia alien game and a VT in the mini that ghug ran.

Wait if it's multi that doesn't count much, does it? He basically has an extraordinarily long leash to hunt scum in a townie manner. As for the mini do you remember vaguely when it was so I can search for it myself?

> boat man claims i'm weird without evidence
> kgray dispute this, cites evidence
> boat man ignores it despite having 0 context

[TheFlyingBoat]

I think a tfb wagon also makes sense. I feel like his game so far has been agree with Jamie over something stupid, push that, watch Flum get killed despite thinking he;'s town (?), and then disappearing

Was scrolling back through the thread and noticed this. I am not sure where any of my D1 posts make you think I thought Flum was town, given I spent 7 hours hammering the fact I think he was scum, articulating reasons I think others could be tied to him as a scum team member, and explicitly pushed others like bozo to vote for Flum at the EOD (also why I found the claims that I was trying to get other wagons going to save Flum or whatever ridiculous) and I don't think it's fair to accuse me of disappearing when I have the 8th highest post count, the 2nd highest word count, middle of the pack post count for today, and the highest word count today.

If breaking up my reads list into 18 posts and making my long responses with grouped posts into like 6 posts would make you think I am more engaged, maybe I'll do that next game, but this is is silly. I've also already responded to your claim that I only respond when summoned which is also off base.

there was this whole thing at the end where you said you thought he was town ultimately but didn't move off him? or am i misremembering that

You're misremembering that. The closest I came was when I said in the night I wish he showed the level of caring about defending himself he did at the very end of the day way earlier.

[DemonRHK]

i kinda want to flash someone but idk who

damo? rdr?

[BobMcBob]

The other thing I've done so far today is iso tfb's day 2 and look somewhat into the case on him, and it's okayish. I would rather vote celaph though. I don't think TFB has been particularly scummy, although he has certainly been strange. And I like the celaph wagon.

did you read celaph's d2 and if so did it change your mind?

I read it last night and I just went and read the things I missed and it hasn't changed my mid that much. He looks perhaps a bit better for putting some more thoughts out though.

[Bonatogether]

##vote TFB

I don't feel like he's coming at things from a towny perspective and he's a much better cw than Bob.

boat man's scummates have given up on him

pack it in boys, we gottem good

[ghug]

i kinda want to flash someone but idk who

Jamie?

[TheFlyingBoat]

no i don't remember the numbers. he was scum in jamie's multi-mafia alien game and a VT in the mini that ghug ran.

Wait if it's multi that doesn't count much, does it? He basically has an extraordinarily long leash to hunt scum in a townie manner. As for the mini do you remember vaguely when it was so I can search for it myself?

> boat man claims i'm weird without evidence
> kgray dispute this, cites evidence
> boat man ignores it despite having 0 context

I literally pointed to what I thought was weird this game about you earlier and then in response to kgray's response about your style I also point to M1020 explicitly where I draw differences in your narrow vs wide style. This requires straight up ignoring my posts to post.

[BobMcBob]

i kinda want to flash someone but idk who

Goldie with me!

[Bonatogether]

What's the case? Do you think scum!Jamie can pull off that kind of tunnel on flum? I'd rather get tfb because I felt he was encouraging and leeching off of Jamie d1 and still kinda is d2

Yes, I absolutely believe scum Jamie is capable of an intense tunnel over catching someone in a lie. Do you not?

He spent most of today coasting on the townreads he's earned, and the recent Chaqa push is entirely based on willful misinterpretation.

What will it take for us to have a game together in which you don't scumread me?

Do I have to send you nudes?

literally never say that again please

[BusinessLamp]

i kinda want to flash someone but idk who

i hope this is just baiting responses, i feel slightly more confident about today's setup