M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[TheFlyingBoat]

it is seeming more and more likely scum was on the celaph wagon.

Unless it's 2 of like HR, Donny, Damo, Gold, Maniac

When you say this do you mean that there was a scum member on the celaph wagon? If so, that's fairly obvious given Vecna was on it. If you're saying one of the remaining scum was on it, I'd like to know why you think that and if you think it is a 1-1 split or a 2-0 of the remaining scum on the celaph bus.

[kgray]

I don't think we can use VCA to eliminate anybody and I have convincing (imo) reasons to think Maniac is town. I do not believe the fake claim comes from scum and I do not think it was an attempt to out the real cop.

I have just realized I am using VCA to eliminate bob from my scumpool, so I should be less black and white about that statement. But I think that two flipped scum trying to make him a wagon is a lot more of a reason to townread bob than someone putting a deciding vote on a widely-townread scumbo like celaph. I mean at this point, everyone pushing hard for the celaph counterwagon was town. I think it's pretty safe to assume scum gave up on him (which was very rude, I would have never).

So, I take it you think scum did not bus celaph outside of vecna?

No, I was making the opposite point. I think voting for celaph doesn't necessarily indicate a super high level of towniness. It's a factor but it's not the most important one to me.

[Chaqa]

it is seeming more and more likely scum was on the celaph wagon.

Unless it's 2 of like HR, Donny, Damo, Gold, Maniac

When you say this do you mean that there was a scum member on the celaph wagon? If so, that's fairly obvious given Vecna was on it. If you're saying one of the remaining scum was on it, I'd like to know why you think that and if you think it is a 1-1 split or a 2-0 of the remaining scum on the celaph bus.

Besides Vecna.

Probably 1-1, but maybe 2-0.

[TheFlyingBoat]

it is seeming more and more likely scum was on the celaph wagon.

Unless it's 2 of like HR, Donny, Damo, Gold, Maniac

When you say this do you mean that there was a scum member on the celaph wagon? If so, that's fairly obvious given Vecna was on it. If you're saying one of the remaining scum was on it, I'd like to know why you think that and if you think it is a 1-1 split or a 2-0 of the remaining scum on the celaph bus.

Besides Vecna.

Probably 1-1, but maybe 2-0.

Would you say it was more like 2-0 than 0-2 or the other way around?

[kgray]

@boatman, why does this matter to you? Not trying to be rude, serious question.

[Chaqa]

When you say this do you mean that there was a scum member on the celaph wagon? If so, that's fairly obvious given Vecna was on it. If you're saying one of the remaining scum was on it, I'd like to know why you think that and if you think it is a 1-1 split or a 2-0 of the remaining scum on the celaph bus.

Besides Vecna.

Probably 1-1, but maybe 2-0.

Would you say it was more like 2-0 than 0-2 or the other way around?

Hmmm.

It depends, really, and new info will help. Every nightkill from here on solidifies the picture.

Right now I would say 1-1 > 0-2 > 2-0, but that could change in time.

If I had to pick most likely scum on the celaph wagon, it would be Donny or Rivera right now.

[TheFlyingBoat]

@boatman, why does this matter to you? Not trying to be rude, serious question.

To improve my read and understanding of Chaqa?

[kgray]

@boatman, why does this matter to you? Not trying to be rude, serious question.

To improve my read and understanding of Chaqa?

Did it help?

[TheFlyingBoat]

@boatman, why does this matter to you? Not trying to be rude, serious question.

To improve my read and understanding of Chaqa?

Did it help?

I think so.

[Jamiet99uk]

To improve my read and understanding of Chaqa?

Did it help?

I think so.

So your read on Chaqa has changed or intensified or what?

[Maniac]

No detailed reads from me I’m afraid. But as I
Could be be a nightkill,you might like to know my opinions.

Town Pool
Chaqa
Donny Dude
ghug - strong town
goldfinger0303 - not a candidate for now
kgray
rdrivera2005?
TheFlyingBoat

Scum pool - not ordered
Jamiet99uk
Hellenic Riot
damo666
BobMcBob

[Jamiet99uk]

I've given mine already.
RESPECT THE DEAD.
Come at me, scum.

[Chaqa]

RESPECT THE DEAD

Especially bona

[Jamiet99uk]

RESPECT THE DEAD

Especially bona

This was his final post, therefore I agree with you Chaqa:

pretty sure jamie is town as well

[ghug]

What?

Damo said Vecna was a goon, Vecna was in reality the RB, so I feel like Vecna being the RB would be on your mind since you were allegedly RB'd.

In the context of his post, I understood it to simply mean he wasn’t The Godfather.

Besides, I doubt Vecna unilaterally decided the roleblock, he probably just entered whatever order Durga and other more active scum told him to.

What's relevant is that he was still a useful role himself.

[ghug]

Plus like his entire argument makes sense regardless

How does Vecna being roleblocker matter when the PRs are all dead????

He was just a goon in all but name

Not when he died?

[ghug]

Jesus, I thought this was a veteran group.

Oh no we fucked up. Scum are going to kill gold. That would be terrible for us.

[Jamiet99uk]

Ghuggius Aetius.

[Chaqa]

I’m the Fruit Vendor

[Chaqa]

I’m giving fruit to TFB tonight