M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[BunnyGo]

Sorry? I don't understand what that has to do with why scum!Durga would immediately call out jasnah as fake claiming.

You asked how scum!Durga would know which of us was fake (assuming that Jasnah is town)? The answer is:

1) Scum!Durga knows neither of us is scum
2) Scum!Durga knows I'd never fake a CC as town
ergo
3)Scum!Durga instantly knows which of us is faking it.

Oh, this happened after you CC'd. Missed that.

Maybe that clears up your confusion with Eden too?

[kgray]

You asked how scum!Durga would know which of us was fake (assuming that Jasnah is town)? The answer is:

1) Scum!Durga knows neither of us is scum
2) Scum!Durga knows I'd never fake a CC as town
ergo
3)Scum!Durga instantly knows which of us is faking it.

Oh, this happened after you CC'd. Missed that.

Maybe that clears up your confusion with Eden too?

I don't know. Maybe I should reread the whole thing and then reread him a third time. But maybe I won't anyway.

[worcej]

me are awful

Indeed...

[worcej]

Yeah, actually.

TFB actually had an explanation, but it doesn't make sense - just because I put an end vote on someone doesn't make me explicitly scummy when numerous others have already done that.
Snowy's had no explanation at the time.
Durga sheeped Snowy. Of note, few of her votes seem to have conviction behind them...
Chaqa's reasoning was made awhile ago, but then does it when suggestion a 50/50 or no kill. dafuq?

I think I clarified that putting an end vote in and of itself doesn't make it seem scummy to me. It is the fact that it was in a situation that could pretty quickly result in a hammer that seemed suspect to me. No other end happened in such a scenario besides Bunny's which I thought was sus as well at the time, but after coming to the conclusion he was the miller, I ruled out the possibility of him being scum for now. Fluminator is definitely my biggest scum read right now, but I have seen no will from anyone to pursue a wagon on him. Right now I view it as three way race between you, jasnah, and Bunny and I have incredibly strong town reads on both of the latter two.

Why would it matter so much that I ended anyways - it's not like there was 7 other people doing it.

Do you think scum!worcej would rush to slam an end and think it'd work to silence the thread or something?

[BunnyGo]

Oh, this happened after you CC'd. Missed that.

Maybe that clears up your confusion with Eden too?

I don't know. Maybe I should reread the whole thing and then reread him a third time. But maybe I won't anyway.

Both options sound reasonable. I'd probably not reread.

Good night.

[Durga]

Everyone can read Sabi or doom?

I thought this said "Can everyone read Sabi or doom" until I realized it was rhetoric but since I was halfway through my answer anyway

I was going to say Doom struck me as pretty towny in his few posts. They held curiosity and conviction shared with a common unwillingness to be burned from being wrong that seemed natural to me

Sabi I think have been oddly cautious and unwilling to make waves, and I'm keeping an eye out. Also I feel like she's been making situation inappropriate comments but I'd have to actually revisit whether that impression is based

I dunno what I'm doing anymore. Just ready to die in N1 at this point.

Why do you think you're gonna die n1

[President Eden]

I think I'm supposed to like the worcej wagon based on the names on it... but I don't. Kind of makes me wonder what I got wrong.

I think I get where Boat is coming from although I disagree. And Durga is sheeping snowy, which is fair enough I guess. So I suppose this is directed to snowy and Chaqa, why worcej?

Chaqa's vote is particularly perplexing, as the only reason he doesn't want to kill both jasnah and Bunny is because the Oracle allows us to learn one of their identities... but that only works if we vote one off, yet Chaqa is on neither of them, and in fact on the wagon that happens to be the strongest contender besides either of them. Surely you should be voting jasnah here Chaq?

[TheFlyingBoat]

I think I'm supposed to like the worcej wagon based on the names on it... but I don't. Kind of makes me wonder what I got wrong.

I think I get where Boat is coming from although I disagree. And Durga is sheeping snowy, which is fair enough I guess. So I suppose this is directed to snowy and Chaqa, why worcej?

Chaqa's vote is particularly perplexing, as the only reason he doesn't want to kill both jasnah and Bunny is because the Oracle allows us to learn one of their identities... but that only works if we vote one off, yet Chaqa is on neither of them, and in fact on the wagon that happens to be the strongest contender besides either of them. Surely you should be voting jasnah here Chaq?

I mean the obvious way to square the circle where both of your read on liking me as town and not liking the worcej is to just assume I am a dumb town...wouldn't be the most far fetched thing ever haha. Like I said though my worcej read is weak at best and fluminator is my ideal wagon.

[snowy801]

I have no idea why there's 4 votes on worcej either

I wanted to shift the overall mood from 50/50 jasnah/Bunny to "let's look at how people reacted to this assuming either or both is town" and worcej at the time very recently did something fairly scummy.

Also stop distracting me this game isn't going to reread itself

[worcej]

And I default back to the votes on me are awful.

[worcej]

For all this talk of not letting PRs dominate the game and wanting to play, those same people are playing rather lazily.

[snowy801]

It did strike me as being odd, but I haven't parsed through the who's and the why's yet.

Also repeatedly yelling "me vote bad me vote bad" isn't really useful or impressing anyone, is my most recent take on worcej

[snowy801]

For all this talk of not letting PRs dominate the game and wanting to play, those same people are playing rather lazily.

Who? Be specific in your accusations. Who spoke of not letting PRs dominate, and who's being lazy?

[worcej]

It did strike me as being odd, but I haven't parsed through the who's and the why's yet.

Also repeatedly yelling "me vote bad me vote bad" isn't really useful or impressing anyone, is my most recent take on worcej

I don't expect it to be. Remember, I suck.

[worcej]

For all this talk of not letting PRs dominate the game and wanting to play, those same people are playing rather lazily.

Who? Be specific in your accusations. Who spoke of not letting PRs dominate, and who's being lazy?

Durga for one. She's being incredibly hostile at people's reads against her and being lazy with her votes.

[snowy801]

I'm inclined to feel the implication of "lazy" is "lazy town", but I imagine it could be used either way. Do you feel Durga is being lazy because she's complacent and can't be arsed, or is she doing it as scum?

[Chaqa]

I think I'm supposed to like the worcej wagon based on the names on it... but I don't. Kind of makes me wonder what I got wrong.

I think I get where Boat is coming from although I disagree. And Durga is sheeping snowy, which is fair enough I guess. So I suppose this is directed to snowy and Chaqa, why worcej?

Chaqa's vote is particularly perplexing, as the only reason he doesn't want to kill both jasnah and Bunny is because the Oracle allows us to learn one of their identities... but that only works if we vote one off, yet Chaqa is on neither of them, and in fact on the wagon that happens to be the strongest contender besides either of them. Surely you should be voting jasnah here Chaq?

Nah I misunderstood the Oracle lol, see one of my last posts

I just haven’t updated my vote yet

##Vote jasnah

[snowy801]

Alright PGTE just updated and you lost me

Plug for random fantasy webnovel:
https://practicalguidetoevil.wordpress.com/

Good night folks

[ghug]

I think I'm supposed to like the worcej wagon based on the names on it... but I don't. Kind of makes me wonder what I got wrong.

I think I get where Boat is coming from although I disagree. And Durga is sheeping snowy, which is fair enough I guess. So I suppose this is directed to snowy and Chaqa, why worcej?

Chaqa's vote is particularly perplexing, as the only reason he doesn't want to kill both jasnah and Bunny is because the Oracle allows us to learn one of their identities... but that only works if we vote one off, yet Chaqa is on neither of them, and in fact on the wagon that happens to be the strongest contender besides either of them. Surely you should be voting jasnah here Chaq?

He already said he forgot it was a death oracle

[Chaqa]

I don’t think I ever picked up on that in the setup review either, to be fair… I’m assuming I must have, but, well.. it’s about 50/50