M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[Bonatogether]

what's everybody's MBTI

yes this is on-topic

if you tell me it's just astrology for nerds you're right but we're still fighting

intp or something

[Bonatogether]

Completely Fallible Human Yet GM Vote Count Day Four The First
(Through post 9067)

snowy801(4) - worcej, BunnyGo*, Vecna, Doom427
ghug(3) - Durga, kgray, Jamiet99uk
Jamiet99uk(2) - ghug, snowy801
BesharamSabi(1) - BesharamSabi
Chaqa(1) - President Eden*
Doom427(1) - Tom Bombadil
President Eden(1) - TheFlyingBoat
Vecna(1) - Chaqa*

Unvote(1) - Fluminator
Not Voted(2) - Bonatogether, rdrivera2005

Currently, SNOWY801 is set to be killed.

22.5 Hours remain in Day 4

##vote jamie

still in the middle of my snowy reread, probably will change

What did you see in that Vote Count that caused you to choose me?

Why am I your top scumread?

The wagon is big and I scum you for not being memorable aside from the dueling Eden series of posts.

I'm rereading snowy so I might change, and I'll definitely try to be on for EoD to vote one of those wagons.

[Bonatogether]

The stinkiness of my wagon suggests that the remaining scum aren't Tom/kgray/Jamie specifically, at least. Would be useful if we could ever flip any of them.

I scum this post

Then vote for the scum who posted it, maybe?

I vote who I want

[Tom Bombadil]

I will not likely be on at deadline. I am comfortable staying in ghug.

[ghug]

Rocks fall, everybody dies!

BOZOTHECLOWN was the MAFIA GOON
CHAQA was the MAFIA GOON
GHUG was the MAFIA GOON
TOM BOMBADIL was the MAFIA GODFATHER

GOD QT: HERE

why are you so sure that Chaqa didnt just mention his teammate as his inno?

That would be a very risky strategy.

I think it's significantly less likely given it was day 1, too.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Boat, I'm having trouble getting from your evidence to your conclusions. Can you explain more how you've reached the reads you have from your analysis?

I second this. A lot of effort went into TFB's wallpost there, but I'm not sure I can see how some of those conclusions were reached on the basis of the analysis presented.

@TFB: I don't wish to appear self-obsessed but you listed me in the POE pool and then didn't really mention me again at all. Is there a reason for that?

You didn't appear in a majorly interesting way in the votes on conf town. You kinda floated through when you joined our wagons if and when you did. You're not in the higher parts of my PoE basically

[TheFlyingBoat]

ooh forgot to change my vote after changing my mind on Eden. ##vote Snowy

[Fluminator]

I'm introverted, but ENTP descriptions describe me better.
Also time to actually put in effort today

[Jamiet99uk]

I will not likely be on at deadline. I am comfortable staying in ghug.

Inside Ghug?

How does Ghug feel about that?

[Fluminator]

Rivera. Can you give one non-vague answer why you are voting me?

Because you defended Bozo all day long on D2 with a bullshit reason he is easily sorted, which I don't agree. This is non-vague.

There is the more vague one that I can't follow your logic many times which is not usual as I think you are a pretty solid player.

This is pretty strong.
It did feel weird that you were saying "Bozo is easily sorted later" at the moment. It's a perfect excuse to not vote someone without being wrong per se.

[ghug]

I will not likely be on at deadline. I am comfortable staying in ghug.

Inside Ghug?

How does Ghug feel about that?

So, so good.

[ghug]

Mmmmm hmmmmbadil

[snowy801]

Lewd

[Jamiet99uk]

Sexual

[Fluminator]

Im more worried why Chaqa thinks I could be scum at all here after I let him completely off the hook on D1 after his swear on chipotle thing.

Regardless, there doesnt seem to be much of a point to try and make a rational argument why its chaqa/flum (or Chaqa/TFB), since the ammount of chaotic luck they wouldve had to harnass to hit all those requirements is just blegh. Cant shake the feeling though that Chaqa is way too happy currently, even though he completely bumbled the cop PR if he's telling the truth.

Its probably going to come down to me having to die (i can sadly see the rational argument, even though my inner spirit animal feels I should fight it tooth and nail, and that you all should be embarrased for even considering me as scum). Maybe that means after you just kill the right targets that im embarrasingly misreading or whatever, I dno. Or town just ends up throwing this as was expected.

Honestly this is more or less where I'm at. This game is pretty much won and it's just a matter of time my being here or not won't make a huge difference (I think? Surely even you guys can't fuck this up right)

im currently in suspicion/conspiracy phase and having that gloomy feeling were getting majorly punked at least somewhere.

Its sort of a bad phase for town atm, because both scum and town are currently operating the same (if it is correct to assume that scum is in the poe pool, which is a pretty major IF).

If youre town, you realize its bad to want to kill of the PRs/clears right now, so you go and target whoever you know is capable of pulling off their current play as scum.

If youre scum, you do the survivalist thing and make sure youre the last one to die in the PoE pool to give whoever is your teammate the best chance at winning, and hopefully suspicion of the other pool overtakes before its your turn.

I was hoping to prevent this apathy from seeping in later on when we would eventually kill off Bozo, but the fact it set in much earlier now.....not sure if its bad per se, since it wont come later at the more crucial stages, but it sure feels meh currently.

I think the apathy is caused by the knowledge that we're going to get almost no new information for a very long time.
I was trying to combat that apathy by getting us a new known flip for us very soon to keep momentum going, but some people were very keen to stop any new info from potentially coming.

[Fluminator]

Like I recognize my plan wouldn't have worked because so many players threw suspicion on the 1% chance of "WHAT IF DAMO WAS COP" that it successfully misted TFB into wasting the shot (love you TFB but I disagree with that action so much lol).

I definitely feel like we have some very vocal scum still in this game pushing the overton window to ideas that shouldn't be in it yet.

[President Eden]

A :bonk: on all your houses

[snowy801]

Like I recognize my plan wouldn't have worked because so many players threw suspicion on the 1% chance of "WHAT IF DAMO WAS COP" that it successfully misted TFB into wasting the shot (love you TFB but I disagree with that action so much lol).

I definitely feel like we have some very vocal scum still in this game pushing the overton window to ideas that shouldn't be in it yet.

Still don't think Eden's scum if that's where you're going. I'd be beyond impressed

[Fluminator]

Dang, I'm going through Jamiet's previous games and you get scum a lot buddy.

[Fluminator]

And you GM a lot. Thank you for that!