M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[President Eden]

If brainbomb actually took a gun and claims to take a gun - and note that neither have been confirmed in the game, although it seems likely he did take one - then it's literally impossible for all of brainbomb, ghug, and Chaqa to be town and truthfully claiming their takes. One must be mafia, and based on our current info (with no way to know how to weight the likelihood of 9, 10, or 11 Town roses), it's more likely than not that 1-2 are.

Rivera, I'm not sure why you dislike my posts to this point when we're substantively on the same page.

[Hamilton Brian]

D1ing Chaqa would actually be pretty funny since this is ostensibly his last game on WebDip Mafia because he’s been D1d too many times.

Egregious trolling.

##Vote Foodcoats

[brainbomb]

the only thing scum cares about right now is in this order

how do i avoid pressure
who can i miskill
what items did my scum partners grab which they may know by now
what town can we kill n1 that didnt take a n1 rose

the last point can only be found by town players claiming items and activation times. which is uneccessary. which makes me think the wagon on me couldve been opportunistic by scum - or an attempt to garner free claim info about if I am killable and when, or a general opportunity to remove a player who had high accuracy last game.

I thought it was possible people wanted to throw me off my game by using an excuse to vote me but I dont think ghug has been at all insincere, and damo probably doesnt think im important enough to get rid of so cheaply

[brainbomb]

If brainbomb actually took a gun and claims to take a gun - and note that neither have been confirmed in the game, although it seems likely he did take one - then it's literally impossible for all of brainbomb, ghug, and Chaqa to be town and truthfully claiming their takes. One must be mafia, and based on our current info (with no way to know how to weight the likelihood of 9, 10, or 11 Town roses), it's more likely than not that 1-2 are.

Rivera, I'm not sure why you dislike my posts to this point when we're substantively on the same page.

technically every town who took a rose should want scum to think they took a gun so n1 is fair game for nk especially if its a n1 rose

[brainbomb]

chaqa would take a rose as scum since he dies alot.

[snowy801]

Hello everyone, it's been a while.

I just want to clarify the position regarding these guns, in that people are assuming optimal play as the mafia would be to take gun, hence people with guns are more likely to be mafia, correct?

I have my own thoughts on the matter but I want to know whether people (in particular President Eden) is echoing these thoughts.

Though the topic is somewhat exhausted, I would like to echo the sentiment that reading your 9th post in a row is rather annoying, brainbomb. If you could consolidate your thoughts into a post, and wait for someone else to respond in turn I think it would do the world a favor.

I'd like to hear elaborations on two opinions in particular:

#83: damo claims brainbomb is "laughably easy" and I would like to hear your elaboration on this opinion

#120: macca - two things:
1) you say you sees the case on brainbomb, please explain what it is you see on this matter
2) On Jamiet: "Man's as scummy as a scummy thing on a scummy day wearing scummy clothes." - what exactly do you find about him scummy?

[snowy801]

Also I would like to perhaps start a bandwagon on

##vote Johnny Big Horse

It may be new player syndrome (I am not certain he's new, but it feels like it), but his tone seems rather off somehow

Only four posts, but such as it is:
http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?g= ... ig%20Horse

[ghug]

optimal town play was to take a rose the only reason anyone wouldve taken a gun as town was to give town a 1 shot vig

were all on the same page on that right?

I mean I think optimal town play was to take a rose if you thought people were going to mostly take guns.

I think now we'd probably prefer a few more town guns, but such is life.

[ghug]

Two things I'd like not to see end of D1:

a) recursive kill of Chaqa

b) immediate kill of brainbomb

Hopefully the sober second thoughts can offer some reconsiderations.

However, the thread so far has felt like when your SO tells you not to squeeze that pimple, but you do it anyway.

D1ing Chaqa would actually be pretty funny since this is ostensibly his last game on WebDip Mafia because he’s been D1d too many times.

##VOTE Chaqa

I think Chaqa's town for his gun claim.

(I have a horse in this race, obviously, but I didn't realize there were only 11 townies when I claimed mine, so his is townier)

[TheMadMonarch]

Hello everyone, it's been a while.

I just want to clarify the position regarding these guns, in that people are assuming optimal play as the mafia would be to take gun, hence people with guns are more likely to be mafia, correct?

I have my own thoughts on the matter but I want to know whether people (in particular President Eden) is echoing these thoughts.

Though the topic is somewhat exhausted, I would like to echo the sentiment that reading your 9th post in a row is rather annoying, brainbomb. If you could consolidate your thoughts into a post, and wait for someone else to respond in turn I think it would do the world a favor.

I'd like to hear elaborations on two opinions in particular:

#83: damo claims brainbomb is "laughably easy" and I would like to hear your elaboration on this opinion

#120: macca - two things:
1) you say you sees the case on brainbomb, please explain what it is you see on this matter
2) On Jamiet: "Man's as scummy as a scummy thing on a scummy day wearing scummy clothes." - what exactly do you find about him scummy?

It's mostly the gun thing for BB.

I was being a little funny with my assuredness, but I really don't like the way he went after BB. Granted, I don't like Jamie and often get false positives on him.

[ghug]

Hello everyone, it's been a while.

I just want to clarify the position regarding these guns, in that people are assuming optimal play as the mafia would be to take gun, hence people with guns are more likely to be mafia, correct?

I have my own thoughts on the matter but I want to know whether people (in particular President Eden) is echoing these thoughts.

Though the topic is somewhat exhausted, I would like to echo the sentiment that reading your 9th post in a row is rather annoying, brainbomb. If you could consolidate your thoughts into a post, and wait for someone else to respond in turn I think it would do the world a favor.

I'd like to hear elaborations on two opinions in particular:

#83: damo claims brainbomb is "laughably easy" and I would like to hear your elaboration on this opinion

#120: macca - two things:
1) you say you sees the case on brainbomb, please explain what it is you see on this matter
2) On Jamiet: "Man's as scummy as a scummy thing on a scummy day wearing scummy clothes." - what exactly do you find about him scummy?

Hi snowy. Nice to have you back.

Could you please quote posts rather than giving numbers? I am very lazy and would much rather ignore you or vote you out than go find them.

[ghug]

Also I would like to perhaps start a bandwagon on

##vote Johnny Big Horse

It may be new player syndrome (I am not certain he's new, but it feels like it), but his tone seems rather off somehow

Only four posts, but such as it is:
http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?g= ... ig%20Horse

##VOTE John

Players are more likely to think their team is disadvantaged, so his assumption about the rose count is a scumtell.

[snowy801]

Hi snowy. Nice to have you back.

Could you please quote posts rather than giving numbers? I am very lazy and would much rather ignore you or vote you out than go find them.

I can probably do that, just gotta remember how to do this forum nonsense. Here' I'll use you as a test

[Chaqa]

I have read nothing of this setup except that I got to choose a gun. Easiest choice of my life, I thought, though it turns out the roses are needed to stop us from losing, so…

You should probably know in full disclosure that the only reason I'm not voting you is because I feel bad you got day 1'd twice in a row

don't be a bich

[Chaqa]

Also ghug is bussing and Chaqa is defending

Game solved

Que?

[Chaqa]

Anyway ##Vote worcej

[brainbomb]

ghug, please call johnny by a more exciting name than john. could you have made that more boring

[ghug]

ghug, please call johnny by a more exciting name than john. could you have made that more boring

That was the point. There's irony in shortening his excellent name to something so mundane.

[Jamiet99uk]

should anyone be claiming item and night use? seems like we dont want scum to know exactly who is killable on which nights

Some people have claimed their items already. I advise absolutely NOT claiming which night you'll be active. This helps scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm certainly seeing the BB case, however:

##VOTE Jamie

Man's as scummy as a scummy thing on a scummy day wearing scummy clothes. I'd shoot him if I had a gun (I do not).

No I'm not.