M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[brainbomb]

Don't Shoot:

damo
brainbomb
Me
Brian
snowy
Johnny Big Horse

Maybe Shoot:
worcej
Macca
rivera
emc

Shoot:
ghug
Jamie
Chaqa

no posts by eden about damo N1, and yet somehow damo is top of the do not shoot list?

strike this, there is indeed 1 post by eden implying damo is probably town. there is not a reason given however.

[President Eden]

I think you've got at least two mafia among bb, ghug, Chaqa, Jamie.

emc is probably town because trying to flip him out of nowhere made no sense at all. Based on his actual performance he's null, but the push on him makes me think he's town.
rivera, JBH, snowy seem town. damo can probably be in that pile too.
No idea what to make of Macca or worcej.

how did damo go from being a probably in the town pile, to top of the do not shoot list?

They’re not sorted by priority... you really think I’d put myself third? Cmon man

[brainbomb]

OK I'M FED UP

I no longer wish to play in game dominated by one player whose posts are 99% are not 'on point'.

I will no longer sign up for games where I think this will happen.

I will nevertheless continue to try my best in this game despite the fact it is being made unenjoyable.

Otherwise speaking, I think damo almost certainly town from 1) Lack of joke in entry post and 2) his lovely depressive rage here, so strongest read for moment

this could just be a legit take on the game but if damo is scum this is heavily a reinforcing the idea type of post. and its bizarree how emc thinks the opening damo post was grouchy.

[brainbomb]

pretty weird eden

[snowy801]

@Snowy:

Given that you were the recipient of Damo's fury, do you agree with Brainbomb that Damo was being fake, or do you think it was real?

Whilst I am cautious in dealing with this delicate topic, you may infer by my own response that I believed it to be real. Especially in a context of conversation where we were speaking of lying about personal circumstances in game, I felt that his emotions were true, and that he exceeded boundaries by bringing meta consequences (want to quit, will leave community unless x) into the conversation.

I was surprised, even before brainbomb posted, that damo wordlessly came back and started playing again, and wondered similar thoughts. The incongruity, if it is there to be found, is here I think.

[ghug]

You're posting more, I guess?

I've got my eye on you.

I invite you, then, to continue threatening me with a good time

##vote ghug

If you are correct and all President Eden is is overly confident in himself, how do you feel about his assertions that there are likely 3 scum in yourself, Chaqa, brainbomb, and Jamiet in the context of not knowing what the N1 reveals were? You previously stated numerous times that you believe PE is scum for tone and context but not, if I recall, because of his arguments.

Do you believe he is likely one now, given what you know?

I'm not sure I totally understand what you're getting at.

The substance of PE's arguments is a big part of my scumread. His logic has been repeatedly lazy and not representative of how I imagine town PE would think about the game. I've said as much

As for the rest of it, two of his scumreads look like town. He wouldn't have known that was going to happen if he were scum, so I'm not sure why the night results change anything.

[brainbomb]

to go from oh yea damo is probably town to
hey better put damo as DEFINETELY DONT SHOOT

[ghug]

Certainly there's a world where scum conspire to lie about a claim like this; not saying it is happening here but I think it would be pretty naive to rosily accept it without at least some question.

But why wouldn't town Chaqa shoot Jamie? Who do you think better candidates were?

I think emc and Johnny are better candidates and also Brain if you want info. Jamiet wasn't particularly scum read D1 and posts a lot so it's easier to sort. I would never choose him as a shot target D1 and I am town.

Would you choose Jamiet?

I think brain would be really good for info, and I think it makes them good for a flip today. Interested about EMC and Johnny; why would they be better candidates?

WOuld I choose Jamie? I don't know. Based on performance on D1, perhaps not. So in my thinking, who were the people I was feeling lots of energy about...brain, PE, snowy. They might have made for better targets/resolutions on N1 for the gun.

Since when does Brian care so much about info?

[Jamiet99uk]

pretty weird eden

Do you think President Eden townread you more than he townread himself?

[Jamiet99uk]

I was surprised, even before brainbomb posted, that damo wordlessly came back and started playing again, and wondered similar thoughts. The incongruity, if it is there to be found, is here I think.

If he was faking, wouldn't he have carried on faking by posting "Sorry for losing my temper" or something, to maintain the pretence, before carrying on?

[brainbomb]

compare this:

rivera, JBH, snowy seem town. damo can probably be in that pile too.

`````````````````````````````````

Don't Shoot:

damo
brainbomb
Me
Brian
snowy
Johnny Big Horse

Maybe Shoot:
worcej
Macca
rivera
emc

Shoot:
ghug
Jamie
Chaqa

```````````````

[Chaqa]

Don't Shoot:

damo
brainbomb
Me
Brian
snowy
Johnny Big Horse

Maybe Shoot:
worcej
Macca
rivera
emc

Shoot:
ghug
Jamie
Chaqa

no posts by eden about damo N1, and yet somehow damo is top of the do not shoot list?

That is pretty odd.

[snowy801]

I was surprised, even before brainbomb posted, that damo wordlessly came back and started playing again, and wondered similar thoughts. The incongruity, if it is there to be found, is here I think.

If he was faking, wouldn't he have carried on faking by posting "Sorry for losing my temper" or something, to maintain the pretence, before carrying on?

It is possible. My first thought was that he, like myself, intended to simply put the event behind and go on with the actual game.

[Hamilton Brian]

Since when does Brian care so much about info?

Always interested in it. Probably haven't explicitly stated it. Nor do I always have a solid use for info. But care? Yeah, I care.

[brainbomb]

there is only one time where eden ever mentions damo all game and its n1 where he says he is probably town. there is only one momen where damo ever mentions eden and its day 1 where he says eden is kinda sus.

[ghug]

I was surprised, even before brainbomb posted, that damo wordlessly came back and started playing again, and wondered similar thoughts. The incongruity, if it is there to be found, is here I think.

If he was faking, wouldn't he have carried on faking by posting "Sorry for losing my temper" or something, to maintain the pretence, before carrying on?

I think he was drunk and then a little embarrassed about it afterwards.

[snowy801]

there is only one time where eden ever mentions damo all game and its n1 where he says he is probably town. there is only one momen where damo ever mentions eden and its day 1 where he says eden is kinda sus.

Eden is kinda sus, I tell no lie

Eden, what made you say you're stupid and unvote? What exactly went through your head there?

[snowy801]

I also think the people truly flying under the radar aren't people like macca and emc, but worcej and rdrivera.

The truly exceptional lurkers are more noticeable than the barely passable, and I know a lot of people townread rivera... why?

Not sure, just a thought.

[damo666]

Yeah my anger was alcohol fuelled and my posts were ott for which I apologise.

As snowy says I'd rather put in behind us

Vecna made post entreating us to adhere to our agreed code of behaviour and that is good enough for me.

PS It was not fake and I am town.

Cheers,

Damo

[snowy801]

Yeah my anger was alcohol fuelled and my posts were ott for which I apologise.

As snowy says I'd rather put in behind us

Vecna made post entreating us to adhere to our agreed code of behaviour and that is good enough for me.

PS It was not fake and I am town.

Cheers,

Damo

I also apologize for what I said. Civility should not be conditional, and I often forget that. Sorry.