M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[celaph]

I think Chaqa is scum, one of ghug/rdr is scum (leaning ghug atm), and I'm not sure who the third is. ##vote Chaqa

I don't think that there is an open and shut case on him, but I have a hard time building a scumteam assuming town Chaqa. Removing Damo, JBH, Chaqa, and myself rdr, ghug, worcej, and emc are left. I liked damo's of worcej/emc likely not being scum together and while I can see that an rdr, ghug, worcej/emc team is possible, it wouldn't be my top bet. For one, I think ghug would have used his comment about rdr bussing to move to Chaqa's wagon.

That's all you have to say?

Is there something you want me to address or are you just here to throw shade?

I've been around for a day and a half and Chaqa's done exceptionally little in that time. He hasn't pushed scumreads nor defended townreads outside of Jamie. There is no reason to townread him. That said, I think that is a weaker reason to scumread him as similar arguments about lack of solvy-ness could be made about emc and I and I know that at least I'm not scum.

I think the much stronger argument is that by townreading damo and JBH, I very quickly run out of scenarios were town Chaqa makes much sense.

[damo666]

I'm leaning towards a Chaqa/rd/celaph scumteam.

Then move to Chaqa

##vote Chaqa

[celaph]

I'm leaning towards a Chaqa/rd/celaph scumteam.

RD and Celaph

##VOTE Celaph

I like how you say this like you've been arguing this all along. Anyways, care to explain your move?

[ghug]

I think Chaqa is scum, one of ghug/rdr is scum (leaning ghug atm), and I'm not sure who the third is. ##vote Chaqa

I don't think that there is an open and shut case on him, but I have a hard time building a scumteam assuming town Chaqa. Removing Damo, JBH, Chaqa, and myself rdr, ghug, worcej, and emc are left. I liked damo's of worcej/emc likely not being scum together and while I can see that an rdr, ghug, worcej/emc team is possible, it wouldn't be my top bet. For one, I think ghug would have used his comment about rdr bussing to move to Chaqa's wagon.

That's all you have to say?

Is there something you want me to address or are you just here to throw shade?

I've been around for a day and a half and Chaqa's done exceptionally little in that time. He hasn't pushed scumreads nor defended townreads outside of Jamie. There is no reason to townread him. That said, I think that is a weaker reason to scumread him as similar arguments about lack of solvy-ness could be made about emc and I and I know that at least I'm not scum.

I think the much stronger argument is that by townreading damo and JBH, I very quickly run out of scenarios were town Chaqa makes much sense.

I largely agree with the conclusion (in fact I made a very similar post earlier in the day), but we're at MILO, and there's a lot left to solve. I expect you to be probing more, eager to figure things out. Apathy has been a good scum indicator for you in the past.

[damo666]

The scumteam imo is:

Chaqa ghug emc

[ghug]

I'm leaning towards a Chaqa/rd/celaph scumteam.

Then move to Chaqa

##vote Chaqa

I feel better about rd, and I'd prefer competitive wagons (with careful EoD consolidation on the leader to prevent a last-minute scum rush).

You've changed your mind on Chaqa again?

[ghug]

I'm one of the two people in this game who actually care about figuring it out right now. Scumreading me is absurd.

[rdrivera2005]

I'm one of the two people in this game who actually care about figuring it out right now. Scumreading me is absurd.

Why, because you keep saying obvious things and play in a cautious way? Or beucase you are basing your vote on POE and because "rd like to bus".
This looks like a perfect way to justify a vote on me tomorrow after Chaqa flip scum.
I am also starting to suspect the way JBH is following you like a puppet, but I will wait for tomorrow to dig on this (if the game is going and I am still alive).

[damo666]

I'm one of the two people in this game who actually care about figuring it out right now. Scumreading me is absurd.

It's [partly] a consequence of you being so reluctant to vote Chaqa.

[Chaqa]

I didn’t switch because I haven’t been on my phone. Checking in while we eat in between rides

##Vote rdr

[damo666]

I'm leaning towards a Chaqa/rd/celaph scumteam.

Then move to Chaqa

##vote Chaqa

I feel better about rd, and I'd prefer competitive wagons (with careful EoD consolidation on the leader to prevent a last-minute scum rush).

You've changed your mind on Chaqa again?

Chaqa gambling there would be at least one town gun seems much more likely than a team shooting JBH and holding fire n3.

[damo666]

Watch emc vote rdr. You can read the script.

[damo666]

Einstein!

Speak.

One and half more page...

and.......

[e.m.c^42]

Sorta feel like I'm tunneled to stupid, all things considered, but still have scumread on ghug.

Seriously?

Yes, since coming down to it you remain as one clear scumread which didn't go away, and I don't think I'm wrong here. You've been all detached (remaining so) and never really seemed to have a stake in things, which is different from your more usual spicy self.

In addition, even though you've been talkative within usual range, dunno, you never really seemed to drive discussion way I remember you did as town? This combined with vague dourness (+points before) has me at ##vote ghug

[worcej]

I'm one of the two people in this game who actually care about figuring it out right now. Scumreading me is absurd.

Who is the other one trying to figure it out to you?

I would say there are only 3 people not trying (emc, Chaqa, celaph [though some posts now show some sign of trying]) who are trying to not figure it out right now.

[e.m.c^42]

But I guess that point also applies to Chaqa, since with some reread and sleep on it, I feel right now he would be more annoyed as town? So sorta scum point there. But if he's like stoned then he wouldn't be, so metric isn't as steady.

[dargorygel]

Vote Count 4.05
Chaqa: (4) worcej, rdrivera2005, celaph, damo666
Rdrivera2005: (2) ghug, Chaqa
Celaph: (1) Johnny Big Horse
ghug: (1) e.m.c^42

Everyone has done their votin' thang.

Chaqa has the most votes.

With only an hour and a half to go.

The parrot and the cat and the squirrel are doing warm-up exercises in the back room. Hoping to get put in the Announcement Part of the Game.

[e.m.c^42]

Einstein!

Speak.

One and half more page...

and.......

Switched to some backreading on bot, typing now lol

[ghug]

Sorta feel like I'm tunneled to stupid, all things considered, but still have scumread on ghug.

Seriously?

Yes, since coming down to it you remain as one clear scumread which didn't go away, and I don't think I'm wrong here. You've been all detached (remaining so) and never really seemed to have a stake in things, which is different from your more usual spicy self.

In addition, even though you've been talkative within usual range, dunno, you never really seemed to drive discussion way I remember you did as town? This combined with vague dourness (+points before) has me at ##vote ghug

We've killed the people I wanted killed 3/3 days, and usually I wanted them killed before others. This doesn't reflect particularly well on me overall, but does really call into question the claim that I haven't been driving things.

[ghug]

I'm one of the two people in this game who actually care about figuring it out right now. Scumreading me is absurd.

Who is the other one trying to figure it out to you?

I would say there are only 3 people not trying (emc, Chaqa, celaph [though some posts now show some sign of trying]) who are trying to not figure it out right now.

Damo.

Rd is not trying. You kind of of are, I suppose, but not very hard. JBH has announced that he's giving up and sheeping xorxes.