M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[ghug]

##GM-Note

Xorxes has replaced Jamiet99uk

Omg

Jamie I forgive you.

[xorxes]

From what I was reading, damo seems the towniest out of everyone, really putting in the effort.

I think emc is town just because the little he has said seemed always spot on.

I wasn't sure about rivera until he said what he said about people not voting for Chaqa, since Chaqa has seemed the scummiest out of everyone to me.

Not completely sure about JBH, either extremely clueless newbie, or crafty newbie scum. Number of shots tonight should be informative.

worcej hard to read because so absent, but I think he can read damo, and he is not reading him genuinely from my pov.

ghug opaque as usual, could go either way. Could replace JBH depending on what happens tonight.

Did I forget anyone?

[e.m.c^42]

##GM-Note

Xorxes has replaced Jamiet99uk

Xorxes! Glad to see you back, it has been awhile.

Hi! Why are you not scumreading Chaqa?

Considering I've been sorta ignoring him for null read, prolly POE scumread then. But I always want to townread him on principle, up to point of letting self die as town when it was TvS, so have been leaving it alone recently lol

When he's particularly active it's easy to townread but his lower effort meta is not good for me.

[xorxes]

brain-celaph: I thought brain was townish, celaph not so much. Another possibility.

[ghug]

brain-celaph: I thought brain was townish, celaph not so much. Another possibility.

What do you find scummy about celaph?

[e.m.c^42]

Hi! Why are you not scumreading Chaqa?

Considering I've been sorta ignoring him for null read, prolly POE scumread then. But I always want to townread him on principle, up to point of letting self die as town when it was TvS, so have been leaving it alone recently lol

When he's particularly active it's easy to townread but his lower effort meta is not good for me.

But given your overall read skills will go take look again, maybe something will ping.

[xorxes]

brain-celaph: I thought brain was townish, celaph not so much. Another possibility.

What do you find scummy about celaph?

Nothing really, I just didn't find anything that screamed towny.

I could have missed something, I think I've read everything but not always with full attention.

[xorxes]

I think town!Chaqa with a gun would have been much more invested in the game, like that game when he was neighborizer. He enjoys having power as town.

Also, why weren't more people on board with flipping JBH? Even if he is town, it wasn't a bad flip, as in that case it deprives scum of a sure kill tonight.

[xorxes]

@Johny Big Horse, how did you make you decision of picking a rose for night 2?

[damo666]

I think town!Chaqa with a gun would have been much more invested in the game, like that game when he was neighborizer. He enjoys having power as town.

Also, why weren't more people on board with flipping JBH? Even if he is town, it wasn't a bad flip, as in that case it deprives scum of a sure kill tonight.

I did my best to get him daykilled but obviously most townsfolk think he is misguided town.

[Johnny Big Horse]

From what I was reading, damo seems the towniest out of everyone, really putting in the effort.

I think emc is town just because the little he has said seemed always spot on.

I wasn't sure about rivera until he said what he said about people not voting for Chaqa, since Chaqa has seemed the scummiest out of everyone to me.

Not completely sure about JBH, either extremely clueless newbie, or crafty newbie scum. Number of shots tonight should be informative.

worcej hard to read because so absent, but I think he can read damo, and he is not reading him genuinely from my pov.

ghug opaque as usual, could go either way. Could replace JBH depending on what happens tonight.

Did I forget anyone?

I'm that bad?

[Johnny Big Horse]

@Johny Big Horse, how did you make you decision of picking a rose for night 2?

Guessed? I didn't pick night one because I wasn't sure how things worked, and I figured by night 2 I might have a clue.

[Johnny Big Horse]

I think town!Chaqa with a gun would have been much more invested in the game, like that game when he was neighborizer. He enjoys having power as town.

Also, why weren't more people on board with flipping JBH? Even if he is town, it wasn't a bad flip, as in that case it deprives scum of a sure kill tonight.

I did my best to get him daykilled but obviously most townsfolk think he is misguided town.

Village idiot I guess. But why would they try to kill me night 2. Unless it was a townie, and that might make sense. Remove the noise.

[xorxes]

From what I was reading, damo seems the towniest out of everyone, really putting in the effort.

I think emc is town just because the little he has said seemed always spot on.

I wasn't sure about rivera until he said what he said about people not voting for Chaqa, since Chaqa has seemed the scummiest out of everyone to me.

Not completely sure about JBH, either extremely clueless newbie, or crafty newbie scum. Number of shots tonight should be informative.

worcej hard to read because so absent, but I think he can read damo, and he is not reading him genuinely from my pov.

ghug opaque as usual, could go either way. Could replace JBH depending on what happens tonight.

Did I forget anyone?

I'm that bad?

Your scumread of Jamie was really bad, yes. Basically the only way he could be scum is if you are scum as well. This was explained to you but you kept insisting.

[xorxes]

@Johny Big Horse, how did you make you decision of picking a rose for night 2?

Guessed? I didn't pick night one because I wasn't sure how things worked, and I figured by night 2 I might have a clue.

You thought you would be a likely kill as early as night 2?

And why did you pick a rose instead of a gun though? You seem very confident in your reads, so you could have used it to kill a scum.

[xorxes]

I think town!Chaqa with a gun would have been much more invested in the game, like that game when he was neighborizer. He enjoys having power as town.

Also, why weren't more people on board with flipping JBH? Even if he is town, it wasn't a bad flip, as in that case it deprives scum of a sure kill tonight.

I did my best to get him daykilled but obviously most townsfolk think he is misguided town.

Village idiot I guess. But why would they try to kill me night 2. Unless it was a townie, and that might make sense. Remove the noise.

It doesn't make a lot of sense that they would try to kill you night 2, right? So why did you pick an n2 rose instead of an n3 one, or a gun?

[Chaqa]

I think town!Chaqa with a gun would have been much more invested in the game, like that game when he was neighborizer. He enjoys having power as town.

Also, why weren't more people on board with flipping JBH? Even if he is town, it wasn't a bad flip, as in that case it deprives scum of a sure kill tonight.

TBH I was planning to be more involved, but literally the day the game started, my girlfriend's parents told her they're selling the house she rents, so I'm just not super invested or active at the moment since we're in crisis mode.

[xorxes]

I think town!Chaqa with a gun would have been much more invested in the game, like that game when he was neighborizer. He enjoys having power as town.

Also, why weren't more people on board with flipping JBH? Even if he is town, it wasn't a bad flip, as in that case it deprives scum of a sure kill tonight.

TBH I was planning to be more involved, but literally the day the game started, my girlfriend's parents told her they're selling the house she rents, so I'm just not super invested or active at the moment since we're in crisis mode.

If you are town and JBH is scum, it's very likely we lose tonight. You had to be very confident that JBH was town to not push for his flip. You were the one with the most info on this matter.

You never wavered day 3 from rivera/worcej/HB as the scumteam but didn't really push them much. Do you still think it's rivera and worcej? Who is the third one?

[dargorygel]

Xorxes is replacing Jamiet99uk

[xorxes]

Chaqa and/or worcej are also the ones most likely here to concoct a plan where JBH claims to have been shot, so that fits with my theory.

Although I suppose brainbomb and emc could go along with it as well.

In any case, the plan would only have been needed to give Chaqa cover, since they would have needed to account for a missing gun. Otherwise it doesn't make that much sense.