MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Bonatogether]

I don't really believe on this. Everyone have some tells, usually you work hard to avoid doing it.

My main difficulty as scum is evolving my reads. As you know the answers it's hard to naturally change a read over some posts or some action without being forced. And when town you are always changing your mind and having second thoughts.

I've only played one scum game - in a set up that is not analogous to this, in that it had 2 scumteams and I could genuinely be hunting and do townie behaviors. People didn't account for that and so I was able to get by with a lot of scummy stuff because people said my hunting stuff was actually good and had effort. I have not played as scum in a one scum team vs town set up. Among Us is vaguely comparable to this but not really due to the much shorter rounds and the main sources of information not being publicly verifiable, such as locations and pathing. Here everyone has the same record of what was said, by who, and in a timestamped fashion.

I think it's understandable for Bona to not know his own scum tells assuming he hasn't played much scum. Is there anyone alive who can speak to Bona's performances as scum on discord?

Secondly, the highlighted line is just a lie. We all thought that your play was incredibly anti-town, but assumed that scum would back down under the pressure you were under. We thought you were town not because you were a good hunter, but because of your boldness.

Oh well. @yavu has played mafia with me on discord, although I don't think when I was scum.

[Bonatogether]

Scum are slow to vote

Why?

What do you mean why? I don't know why.

I was making the vaguely humourous point that it looked like only townsfolk had voted at that time. (Although some doubt on Chaqa).

Unfunny

[Bonatogether]

I really don't get why you're pushing on Bona so hard.

Did you read that exchange? Bona avoided questions asked to him, and left rather than engage in hunting.

See this post:

that's beside the point

Okay, neglect that point.

Bona let’s solve together.

What do you think of damo’s roleblock claim given vecna’s reads and the lack of an item claim?

I answered this.

[Bonatogether]

I've only played one scum game - in a set up that is not analogous to this, in that it had 2 scumteams and I could genuinely be hunting and do townie behaviors. People didn't account for that and so I was able to get by with a lot of scummy stuff because people said my hunting stuff was actually good and had effort. I have not played as scum in a one scum team vs town set up. Among Us is vaguely comparable to this but not really due to the much shorter rounds and the main sources of information not being publicly verifiable, such as locations and pathing. Here everyone has the same record of what was said, by who, and in a timestamped fashion.

I think it's understandable for Bona to not know his own scum tells assuming he hasn't played much scum. Is there anyone alive who can speak to Bona's performances as scum on discord?

Secondly, the highlighted line is just a lie. We all thought that your play was incredibly anti-town, but assumed that scum would back down under the pressure you were under. We thought you were town not because you were a good hunter, but because of your boldness.

This had been the crux of my Bona Townread so far, and the note the people did similar things in our scum game (see above, I wasn't watching him) confirms my belief that he is a scumbo.

Confirms? Do you have alternative reasoning aside from piggybacking off of other people?

[Bonatogether]

I will soon come back and read the game. For now ##vote Macca
U don't know much about the Bona case but it seems scum motivated. Don't fall on a trap

yavu is town here. no reason for scum to make this post (although only given the knowledge that I am town)

[Bonatogether]

##end

uhhhhhh

Hammering at lylo?

Why the fuck?

[Bonatogether]

This makes me worried that we have it wrong and Damo wants us to end before we change our minds.

yes

[Hellenic Riot]

Day Six Vote Count 1.0:

Macca573 (5): Chaqa, rdrivera2005, celaph, yavuzovic, damo666
Bonatogether (4): foodcoats, Jamiet99uk, kgray, Macca573
kgray (1): Bonatogether

Currently MACCA573 is set to be daykilled.

You have 21 hours and 10 minutes remaining.

[Bonatogether]

This makes me worried that we have it wrong and Damo wants us to end before we change our minds.

If I were scum would I be that daft?

It's a good tactic from townpov if you like at the current votes.

If Bona and Macca are both scum Bona could self vote, get a tie and a scum victory.

We need a minimum of 6 votes on one wagon excluding the top 2 wagons themselves.

My end vote is designed to concentrate minds, force the issue ad push scum into a corner.

If it's SvS wouldn't it be early to tie it? EoD is in 21 hours.

This assumes both macca and I are scum. What happens if either of us is town? Then you've done fucked up.

[Bonatogether]

This makes me worried that we have it wrong and Damo wants us to end before we change our minds.

If I were scum would I be that daft?

It's a good tactic from townpov if you like at the current votes.

If Bona and Macca are both scum Bona could self vote, get a tie and a scum victory.

We need a minimum of 6 votes on one wagon excluding the top 2 wagons themselves.

My end vote is designed to concentrate minds, force the issue ad push scum into a corner.

What if I endvote with my vote on Bona. What do you think of that?

>:(

[Bonatogether]

I think hammering near EoD tomorrow when we have consensus would be fine, but ending now is a bit much.

If today is Macca v. Bona though, I'm basically staying on Macca.

Idk what you mean by consensus, there's a bare majority of town. A single scum who people trust can mess things up.

[Bonatogether]

This makes me worried that we have it wrong and Damo wants us to end before we change our minds.

If I were scum would I be that daft?

It's a good tactic from townpov if you like at the current votes.

If Bona and Macca are both scum Bona could self vote, get a tie and a scum victory.

We need a minimum of 6 votes on one wagon excluding the top 2 wagons themselves.

My end vote is designed to concentrate minds, force the issue ad push scum into a corner.

It's 6-4 at the moment. After a tie and a NK we're at 5-4, still winnable.

it only takes a single scum to move at t-0:01 to give them the win. Tying is not a viable strategy.

[Bonatogether]

I'm fairly convinced it's Macca Yav Bona and Chaqa/Jamie.

Can we not just kill Macca get a NK and proceed?

If Macca is town I don't care if we lose anyway. Won't be my fault.

https://media.tenor.com/images/438e3ed3 ... /tenor.gif

Actually though this is an incredibly scummy thing to say.

[Bonatogether]

I confirmed? I only rephrased your claim

Your stating of the obvious is confirmatory evidence of your guilt.

this is absolute bullshit

damo is overeager scum

[Bonatogether]

I will soon come back and read the game. For now ##vote Macca
U don't know much about the Bona case but it seems scum motivated. Don't fall on a trap

Why do you think the Bona case is scum-motivated if you don't know much about it? Do you think me, Jamie, food and Macca are the scumteam? Why is Bona more likely a trap than Macca?

food is 100% scum

[Bonatogether]

This makes me worried that we have it wrong and Damo wants us to end before we change our minds.

If I were scum would I be that daft?

It's a good tactic from townpov if you like at the current votes.

If Bona and Macca are both scum Bona could self vote, get a tie and a scum victory.

We need a minimum of 6 votes on one wagon excluding the top 2 wagons themselves.

My end vote is designed to concentrate minds, force the issue ad push scum into a corner.

Aren't we in mylo, not kylo?

both suck

[Bonatogether]

It's 6-4 at the moment. After a tie and a NK we're at 5-4, still winnable.

Yeah okay how does damo of all people not know this?

Am I not allowed to make a mistake?

i think i might have said a similar thing but this is just so scummy

[Bonatogether]

I am not going to vote the following today or tomorrow

kgray
rdr


err that's it

There is no tomorrow dummy

[Bonatogether]

> Getting the numbers wrong becuase he is not paying attention
> End voting without due cause
> Having suddenly unlikely "scumreads"

Are these the mating cries of the Scumdamo?

yes

##vote damo

[Bonatogether]

I know there's a day to go but surely you can see the danger of the situation.

Town should could consolidate. Scum will have to bus.

Macca is today's vote. Last one on is scum.

There's more than 24 hours left.

I'd like you to talk about your scum read on me.

You're just one of the possible 3rd/4th person

that is a scumread