MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[rdrivera2005]

Yes, town have no option other then kill the Wolf at this point.

If you can get a scum for sure we might let you alive, but it's too risky.
If we miskill and you eat a town it's game over and if we miskill and you try to eat a scum and fail is also game over. So, the only way to let you alive is to correctly kill a scum, but it's an all in move that I don't think town should take.

##vote HB

[foodcoats]

By re-coding D1 votes with new information (and, yes, continued assumptions - namely Jamie, darg, damo, all of which I feel very good about), we know there must be at least one RHK busser necessarily, because the scum team is at least RHK+Macca+rdr+yavu+(Busser). For this reason I remove my townreads of the other votes on the RHK wagon, pending additional review.

DemonRHK (7)
foodcoats Vecna celaph Chaqa Bonatogether kgray Maniac

Kakarroto (4)
damo666 dargorygel brainbomb DemonRHK

Hamilton Brian (3)
yavuzovic worcej rdrivera2005

brainbomb (2)
ghug Hamilton Brian

dargorygel (1)
Kakarroto

Maniac (1)
Jamiet99uk

Bonatogether (1)
Macca573

[dargorygel]

Foodcoats us right? Why not Jamie us right?

"Us" ?

*Is and *is

[dargorygel]

##vote hamilton

[foodcoats]

If you asked me to shoot my best shot right now I'd say it is hands down Macca, Bona, Yavu, Celaph.

I've scummed all of these except yavu, who has to be in by process of elimination. If Chaqa or kgray are scum... well... mindblown.

[foodcoats]

It almost seems to easy for it to be those four, but how am I ever going to wagon kgray and Chaqa, who have both been working their tails to solve?

Only real question mark is RDR, and I would not even consider him until we shimmy-ding-dong at least three out of the other four. Bona/RDR is really the axis, but at this point I think bona is flailing scum.

[dargorygel]

Is there a downside to ending?

[damo666]

By re-coding D1 votes with new information (and, yes, continued assumptions - namely Jamie, darg, damo, all of which I feel very good about), we know there must be at least one RHK busser necessarily, because the scum team is at least RHK+Macca+rdr+yavu+(Busser). For this reason I remove my townreads of the other votes on the RHK wagon, pending additional review.

DemonRHK (7)
foodcoats Vecna celaph Chaqa Bonatogether kgray Maniac

Kakarroto (4)
damo666 dargorygel brainbomb DemonRHK

Hamilton Brian (3)
yavuzovic worcej rdrivera2005

brainbomb (2)
ghug Hamilton Brian

dargorygel (1)
Kakarroto

Maniac (1)
Jamiet99uk

Bonatogether (1)
Macca573

Looking at the timing of the day 1 votes the most likely busser is you food.

[damo666]

Is there a downside to ending?

Yes. The NK will happen sooner.

[damo666]

I thik we can assume town do not have a gun (unless with someone who isn't up to date yet).

Another reason we shouldn't end. Not yet anyway.

[foodcoats]

Demon's big wall post is obsessed with Celaph and bona. He mentions Chaqa once as a town read. Does not mention kgray or Macca here.

So bona had a very odd set of fubar'd quotes. That was odd. Celaph then came in trying to do some sort of Rorschach interpretation of the mess. I felt meh about bona's post but celaph felt gross here.

NOTE: I had this typed after reading through 42 and was intending a vote here. I caught the claim but intend to leave this and what follows alone for my thought process at that time without the vote attached however)
Dargo's entire don't jump to conclusions followed by immediately doing that was god awful.

damo's reluctance to vote jamie is also off. not wanting to vote people D1 is, well, normal. But to that point jamie hadn't done much and had limped in the game. It almost seems like a tactic to avoid pressure, but that's not something I'd normally expect from damo.

food asked for a list way back when, currently I am scum on darg (see above), cona for a lot of the odd stuff with bb early and the messy expla9i8nation of townreads, with sus on celaph if that would flip red for the white-knighting of the quote disaster

(Post claim)
I am scumreading bona, damo, rdr (lack of substance in posting. I feel rdr has few but impactful posts and I ain't seeing that)

toewn on brain, vecna, chaqa

food feels like he's shotgunning everything at the wall and is a townlean. Jamie feels uninvested and is a monor scumlean. As stated a scum bona make me think scum cel is possible (Might be anyway but that post would be really odd as scum covering town.

##vote bona

[foodcoats]

By re-coding D1 votes with new information (and, yes, continued assumptions - namely Jamie, darg, damo, all of which I feel very good about), we know there must be at least one RHK busser necessarily, because the scum team is at least RHK+Macca+rdr+yavu+(Busser). For this reason I remove my townreads of the other votes on the RHK wagon, pending additional review.

DemonRHK (7)
foodcoats Vecna celaph Chaqa Bonatogether kgray Maniac

Kakarroto (4)
damo666 dargorygel brainbomb DemonRHK

Hamilton Brian (3)
yavuzovic worcej rdrivera2005

brainbomb (2)
ghug Hamilton Brian

dargorygel (1)
Kakarroto

Maniac (1)
Jamiet99uk

Bonatogether (1)
Macca573

Looking at the timing of the day 1 votes the most likely busser is you food.

That's why I'm purple, I am the busser.

[damo666]

By re-coding D1 votes with new information (and, yes, continued assumptions - namely Jamie, darg, damo, all of which I feel very good about), we know there must be at least one RHK busser necessarily, because the scum team is at least RHK+Macca+rdr+yavu+(Busser). For this reason I remove my townreads of the other votes on the RHK wagon, pending additional review.

DemonRHK (7)
foodcoats Vecna celaph Chaqa Bonatogether kgray Maniac

Kakarroto (4)
damo666 dargorygel brainbomb DemonRHK

Hamilton Brian (3)
yavuzovic worcej rdrivera2005

brainbomb (2)
ghug Hamilton Brian

dargorygel (1)
Kakarroto

Maniac (1)
Jamiet99uk

Bonatogether (1)
Macca573

Why can't it be Jamie rdr Macca yav (no bussers)?

[foodcoats]

I wonder why Demon was trying to tell us that if bona flips scum, celaph is probably scum. There's no way to figure it out, really, it's all WIFOM. But... he obviously had an IDEA there. He wanted to plant some idea in town... to create a miskill, or to let a buddy go deep.

Just not sure which yet.

[foodcoats]

By re-coding D1 votes with new information (and, yes, continued assumptions - namely Jamie, darg, damo, all of which I feel very good about), we know there must be at least one RHK busser necessarily, because the scum team is at least RHK+Macca+rdr+yavu+(Busser). For this reason I remove my townreads of the other votes on the RHK wagon, pending additional review.

DemonRHK (7)
foodcoats Vecna celaph Chaqa Bonatogether kgray Maniac

Kakarroto (4)
damo666 dargorygel brainbomb DemonRHK

Hamilton Brian (3)
yavuzovic worcej rdrivera2005

brainbomb (2)
ghug Hamilton Brian

dargorygel (1)
Kakarroto

Maniac (1)
Jamiet99uk

Bonatogether (1)
Macca573

Why can't it be Jamie rdr Macca yav (no bussers)?

After today's vote kill, someone will die from the NK, and it will be 6-4.

So if we miskill a townie, we lose. Done.

So I am going to have to slot some people as VERY LIKELY TOWN, DO NOT VOTEKILL.

Right now, based on all the evidence, Jamie is VERY LIKELY TOWN, DO NOT VOTEKILL. Just like you, and darg, and even, honestly, Chaqa and kgray.

My ONLY point of hesitation right now is rdr.

I'm open to other interpretations. But, convince me. YES, of course anything IS "possible." But we can't miskill. So I'm almost never going to kill Jamie unless you show me a very good reason to that's better than the others.

[foodcoats]

Like, based on iso's and behaviour throughout the game and POE, it is, hands down, lock me in, yavu celaph bona macca.

I could be wrong, but I think I can make good arguments about all of these players being scum.

Yavu is actually the one I've been townreading! But yavu's posts at EON4/beginning of D5 were really dumb and sketchy, and by POE, in he goes.

[damo666]

There must be at least 2, probably 3 and maybe even all 4 scum in

Jamie Macca rdr yav

Jamie is the least sensible vote of these. I suggest we vote Macca tomorrow.

[foodcoats]

Alright I'm off to do some in-person housework.

[foodcoats]

Also if you are town do not end-vote, we need to keep hashing through this.

Gotta catch'em all!

[Chaqa]

Well played HB, it’s a tough role to draw.

You have provided some very valuable info to town.

Voting for you now sucks but town is forced to do it - you could choose to go on a rampage and duel down the mafia. This is so obvious that yavu and Chaq now look awful.

##VOTE Hamilton

Oh yeah like I’d mask off to save the Werewolf, lmao

I think Jamie shouldn’t have even revealed it.