MAFIA 63: THE SCOURGE [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

If I were Cop, I would be scanning worcej right now.

I wouldn't

Not to start a dumb thread, but who would you scan instead?

celaph

[Chaqa]

If I were Cop, I would be scanning worcej right now.

I wouldn't

Not to start a dumb thread, but who would you scan instead?

Bozo survey time?

[rdrivera2005]

When rdr posted this the cotes were

Bon 5
ghug 4
brain 4

Would a scum rdr post this? I think not.

Good point Damo. I know I am probably a daykill at some point after last day, I see no problem with that, but at least I want to force scum to risk neck pushing my kill.
Chaqa is probably lazy town.

Getting called lazy town by a guy with half the posts I have. :kappa:

Quantity not equals quality.
Believing all scum were on Bona wagon is lazy.

[Chaqa]

Good point Damo. I know I am probably a daykill at some point after last day, I see no problem with that, but at least I want to force scum to risk neck pushing my kill.
Chaqa is probably lazy town.

Getting called lazy town by a guy with half the posts I have. :kappa:

Quantity not equals quality.
Believing all scum were on Bona wagon is lazy.

A 8-7 vote on the roleblocker with last minute swings?

Seems more likely than bussing ghug on Day 2.

[celaph]

I wouldn't

Not to start a dumb thread, but who would you scan instead?

celaph

It's going to be so boring when you get inno on me though.

[Hamilton Brian]

I wouldn't

Not to start a dumb thread, but who would you scan instead?

celaph

Really? Because of their "I'm the person that fits that description the best." response?

[bozotheclown]

But FWIW, at least now you're starting to use my actual behavior for content.

Then worcej voted for ghug all D2, without ever pushing for ghug to be the DK.

This is not true. Here is my vote:

Also, ##vote ghug

Eden made the point, just agreeing with it via my vote.

Which was because Eden made a long-winded post regarding ghug that was my same opinion.

I'd probably wait a day, but not much longer.

I'll reconsider if you make yourself seem townie, as I kinda did last game, brief bouts of emotion not withstanding.

Reading this leads me to invalidate any portion of your ND concern on my case - if it was a driving factor, it should not matter who filled the slot.

This was me pushing on him for his voting reasons - it was curious how his position on if to flip my slot or not would be dependent on people. If ND was scum, as he was portraying, why would he be inconsistent with applying his vote?

I don't think that ghug makes for a good kill today.

Rereading town PR ghug from last game I felt that much of his play now aligns with his play this game. He was very open that his D1 vote last game was more for someone he didn't want to play with than for someone who was particularly scummy. He
said as much.

That was D1 that, we are now on D2 and he expressed similar laziness. That's the beef I have with it.

This was me disagreeing with celaph's opinion on ghug and pointing out the flaw in his (celaph's) logic to not flip ghug.

Also of note: celaph is in the 'suspect for trying to protect ghug' group.

Do you buy Jamie's argument that I scumslipped?

No - but that rabbit hole is a definite town!Jamie move, so I town him like Eden is.

In general, you’re just here to me. This is a concern in that I expect more pot stirring and action, but really you’re just on the defense.

This was me specifically saying why I suspected ghug.

So... how did I not push for his DK exactly?

OK, but those read like very weak pushes, and it is very likely someone was bussing ghug.

[bozotheclown]

With all of these strange connections between ghug, PE, brainbomb, and BunnyGo, I think they could all be scum together. Also, with the potential mutual bussing between ghug and ND/worcej, as well as the reasons I previously suspected the ND/worcej slot, I think the remaining scum are worcej, PE, brainbomb, and BunnyGo.

In what universe does a mafia team driving the discussion that dominantly still completely fail to protect its own from the day 2 kills? EOD2 is an astonishing failure of that team to protect itself. It should have been trivial to whip votes onto somebody like Bona throughout yesterday if that were the team.

Why do I ever bring up BunnyGo's posting history and spend two hours compiling data to prove it during a night phase as mafia there?

I think you may be right about brainbomb, and I haven't written off worcej yet, but the narrative of this game doesn't make sense with that team.

That is what happens with bussing sometimes.

I may be wrong about you and/or BunnyGo, but what you did would be a good distancing move, like what BunnyGo did to Jamie in M62.

[bozotheclown]

That was D1 that, we are now on D2 and he expressed similar laziness. That's the beef I have with it.

This was me disagreeing with celaph's opinion on ghug and pointing out the flaw in his (celaph's) logic to not flip ghug.

Also of note: celaph is in the 'suspect for trying to protect ghug' group.

So... how did I not push for his DK exactly?

@bozo, if you're going to be scumreading people for not wanting to DK ghug then I have no idea why you're targeting worcej. As he pointed out here, I'm the person that fits that description the best. If you want other people who disliked the ghug wagon you can consider aaro or Durga (now flum). If I can find 3 people who were more hesitant to DK ghug and don't fit your scum narrative then perhaps your reason for scumreading worcej is poor.

To be clear, I think aaro is the least suspicious person on this list by far. I have to cherry pick because he revised his view on ghug as scumlean and ultimately voted for him. To be fair to myself, I also started liking the idea of the ghug wagon, but I didn't push for his death nor did I vote for him. And I think worcej pushed for ghug's death more than both of us. The Durga/Flum spot on the other hand needed no cherry picking.

I am not scum reading anyone for not wanting to DK ghug, if my theory is correct, all the remaining scum were bussing him at some point, with 2 on his final wagon.

[bozotheclown]

Getting called lazy town by a guy with half the posts I have. :kappa:

Quantity not equals quality.
Believing all scum were on Bona wagon is lazy.

A 8-7 vote on the roleblocker with last minute swings?

Seems more likely than bussing ghug on Day 2.

I would be surprised if there were not at least 2 scum on ghug's wagon.

[Hamilton Brian]

Quantity not equals quality.
Believing all scum were on Bona wagon is lazy.

A 8-7 vote on the roleblocker with last minute swings?

Seems more likely than bussing ghug on Day 2.

I would be surprised if there were not at least 2 scum on ghug's wagon.

Think the 4 vanity voters are more town?

[Chaqa]

Personally, I would scan Bozo or EMC.

[Hellenic Riot]

Getting called lazy town by a guy with half the posts I have. :kappa:

Quantity not equals quality.
Believing all scum were on Bona wagon is lazy.

A 8-7 vote on the roleblocker with last minute swings?

Seems more likely than bussing ghug on Day 2.

This is the exact idiotic logic you used last game to say that nobody would bus teacon D1, when two people bussed teacon D1.

[Chaqa]

Quantity not equals quality.
Believing all scum were on Bona wagon is lazy.

A 8-7 vote on the roleblocker with last minute swings?

Seems more likely than bussing ghug on Day 2.

This is the exact idiotic logic you used last game to say that nobody would bus teacon D1, when two people bussed teacon D1.

yeah, except Teacon didn't actually get flipped.

I don't consider it "bussing" unless the person is actually DK'd

[aarodactyl]

I’m much busier today then yesterday but I wanted to pop in and say that making a list of who people would cop scan seems like a bad idea. And I’m a bit disappointed by the people who have contributed to it.

[Chaqa]

I’m much busier today then yesterday but I wanted to pop in and say that making a list of who people would cop scan seems like a bad idea. And I’m a bit disappointed by the people who have contributed to it.

It's pretty much just getting consensus out there from more people. The cop is effectively outed due to brainbomb's shenanigans anyway. We got lucky that ghuggles was the Roleblocker. As long as the Doctor stays hidden, the Cop is essentially free to run amok.

[President Eden]

I’m much busier today then yesterday but I wanted to pop in and say that making a list of who people would cop scan seems like a bad idea. And I’m a bit disappointed by the people who have contributed to it.

I wasn't expecting this to turn into that, I just wanted to give our Cop guidance since our Cop this game is a big fan of my play.

[celaph]

I’m much busier today then yesterday but I wanted to pop in and say that making a list of who people would cop scan seems like a bad idea. And I’m a bit disappointed by the people who have contributed to it.

It's pretty much just getting consensus out there from more people. The cop is effectively outed due to brainbomb's shenanigans anyway. We got lucky that ghuggles was the Roleblocker. As long as the Doctor stays hidden, the Cop is essentially free to run amok.

DOCTOR

You are the DOCTOR. Each day you must vote for a suspect. Each night, you may visit a player by PM'ing the GM with the order ##SAVE <NAME>. At the end of the night, if they have been targeted by the mafia you will save their life. You will know if you successfully performed a save. Your target will be notified only if they have been successfully saved. You may visit yourself. You may not visit the same player on consecutive nights. You win when all of the Mafia have been eliminated, or nothing can stop this from happening.

It doesn't matter how well the doctor stays hidden. They can't perma-save the cop.

[aarodactyl]

I’m much busier today then yesterday but I wanted to pop in and say that making a list of who people would cop scan seems like a bad idea. And I’m a bit disappointed by the people who have contributed to it.

I wasn't expecting this to turn into that, I just wanted to give our Cop guidance since our Cop this game is a big fan of my play.

I looked back and saw only Chaqa was in support of making it a survey. I'll retract some of my disappointment

[aarodactyl]

I’m much busier today then yesterday but I wanted to pop in and say that making a list of who people would cop scan seems like a bad idea. And I’m a bit disappointed by the people who have contributed to it.

It's pretty much just getting consensus out there from more people. The cop is effectively outed due to brainbomb's shenanigans anyway. We got lucky that ghuggles was the Roleblocker. As long as the Doctor stays hidden, the Cop is essentially free to run amok.

DOCTOR

You are the DOCTOR. Each day you must vote for a suspect. Each night, you may visit a player by PM'ing the GM with the order ##SAVE <NAME>. At the end of the night, if they have been targeted by the mafia you will save their life. You will know if you successfully performed a save. Your target will be notified only if they have been successfully saved. You may visit yourself. You may not visit the same player on consecutive nights. You win when all of the Mafia have been eliminated, or nothing can stop this from happening.

It doesn't matter how well the doctor stays hidden. They can't perma-save the cop.

Celaph, don't you know that reading the rules makes you scum? Can the vig please shoot celaph?