Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[Tom Bombadil]

This needless claiming is not good

[thamrick]

Someone catch me up. Who shot Ezio?

We don't know.

Yavuz claims cop. Says he has a guilty scan on ND.

[rdrivera2005]

Someone catch me up. Who shot Ezio?

Nobody assumd the shot until now.

[thamrick]

Someone catch me up. Who shot Ezio?

Nobody assumd the shot until now.

What?

[Tom Bombadil]

Hipfieing Ezio is mornonic as town or scum. So it’s NAI, but I’ll call the person an idiot once I find out who it was

[DemonRHK]

Yes. We were told when SuperSteve was Miller

&&VOTE ND

I still want an answer on which night you investigated, and who you investigated the other night.

Brainbomb, you know.
First night brainbomb, second night ND

Welcome to my one contribution.

Yavu is lying and scum. No one visited brain N1. I've literally said this multiple times today.

##Vote Yavu

##End

[Tom Bombadil]

I wish yavu hadn’t outed especially since there was a chance scum didn’t pick up his hints earlier. Yavu - in future games don’t feel the need to out - you were doing a good job signaling. And if you got killed we could have figured out you had a guilty scam on ND.

[Tom Bombadil]

Oh. That’s interesting

[DemonRHK]

@MANIAC: If you want to shoot me to prove my claim and get 1 for 1, I'm down.

[thamrick]

@RHK - that's what I wondered.

Okay. Now it's interesting. I still think shooting ND is a good play, pending ND's response.

ND flips VT - Yav is lying. We lynch Yav

ND flips Miller - RHK is lying. We lynch RHK

ND flips Scum - RHK (or Yav if ND is Godfather lol) is lying. Jackpot. We get 2 scum.

ND claims PR it gets more interesting.

[DemonRHK]

Either:

A) Yavu just screwed the pooch royally for his team.

B) Yavu shot as scum and is trying to bait CC to go down with him.

C) Someone else was badly exposed and Yavu is the sacrifice fly to try to get them under again.

[DemonRHK]

@RHK - that's what I wondered.

Okay. Now it's interesting. I still think shooting ND is a good play, pending ND's response.

ND flips VT - Yav is lying. We lynch Yav

ND flips Miller - RHK is lying. We lynch RHK

ND flips Scum - RHK (or Yav if ND is Godfather lol) is lying. Jackpot. We get 2 scum.

ND claims PR it gets more interesting.

Why and the hell should we shoot ND? I'm exposed and useless. Since this proves my claim, I at best get rb'd and saved tonight, then die N4. The only good I am is Conf Town if we wanna run the Vig Option again tomorrow.

[DemonRHK]

D) Also, if they stalked ND N2 and saw he's the miller, but a 2 for 1 at best seems strange.

[rdrivera2005]

D) Also, if they stalked ND N2 and saw he's the miller, but a 2 for 1 at best seems strange.

That's interesting, as Yav could be Stalker and could have tried to get a shot or a lynch on a Miller ND.
And shooting ND is the right thing to do as you don't risk shooting the Watcher or the Cop, he is scum or VT (Miller).

[thamrick]

If we keep you alive and you actually are the Watcher, it at least gives mafia a guessing game about who you watch, who Nurse saves.

If we shoot you and you are Watcher, yeah. We lynch Yav. But we lose your power.

If you aren't Watcher, it doesn't prove Yav is Cop. Or give us info about ND. It's possible you and Yav are both scum and stalked ND, found out he's Miller.

I don't see why you're willing to sac yourself to a gunshot as Watcher. Even if you are Watcher, if you're town aligned, it seems better to sac yourself to a NK.

[DemonRHK]

If we keep you alive and you actually are the Watcher, it at least gives mafia a guessing game about who you watch, who Nurse saves.

If we shoot you and you are Watcher, yeah. We lynch Yav. But we lose your power.

If you aren't Watcher, it doesn't prove Yav is Cop. Or give us info about ND. It's possible you and Yav are both scum and stalked ND, found out he's Miller.

I don't see why you're willing to sac yourself to a gunshot as Watcher. Even if you are Watcher, if you're town aligned, it seems better to sac yourself to a NK.

I'm always one to suggest the Martyr play. There's a reason I promised not to suicide hammer this game. It's not the RHK Special for nothing.

[ND]

Alright catching up now. Just saw the last page here.

[DemonRHK]

Anyway, my vote doesn't move. Scum going to comp us a handicap I'll take it with open arms.

Back to taking song requests I guess.

[thamrick]

Anyway, my vote doesn't move. Scum going to comp us a handicap I'll take it with open arms.

Back to taking song requests I guess.

The obvious one is Arms Wide Open. Hit me with that Creed.

[thamrick]

ND - you could just make it easy on us and fess up.

Or you could claim Miller.