Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[brainbomb]

I wasnt following you thamrick. I voted rj for absolutely no reason. I didnt think he was scum and I didnt care anymore at that pointm

[brainbomb]

I changed my mind on vash because he normally insists on my death when hes town.

[Maniac]

Bo is horrible af as scum

#bo is the worst???

This is not a joke. Its legit. He always gets caught easily as scum

In fairness to Bo he is also pretty terrible as town. I like people who are consistent.

[brainbomb]

I tried to ISO rjmcf last night before bed. It was like being a crackhead though. He did alright at being confusing.

My takeaway was
Mean - godfather
Yavuz - scum

But I also felt like jamie implied mean was town
So thats a mixup

[brainbomb]

Both jamie and rj listing mean as town


How on earth is Balki scum in that case?

[thamrick]

Bo won M20 as scum replacing a modkill. I thought he played really well that game.

Regardless, I don't have a strong read on Bo either way. I think he's presenting decent cases, which I see him doing either way, but I think they're helpful either way.

[brainbomb]

My analysis of both RJ and Jamie ISO puts scumteam at

{Ezio-yavuz--thamrick-MLQ}

[thamrick]

My analysis of both RJ and Jamie ISO puts scumteam at

{Ezio-yavuz--thamrick-MLQ}

You know that's 6 right?

[brainbomb]

My analysis of both RJ and Jamie ISO puts scumteam at

{Ezio-yavuz--thamrick-MLQ}

You know that's 6 right?

Yep.

[thamrick]

Man. If Yavuz and Rj were both scum, mafia team was screwed from the start.

[brainbomb]

If Balki was scum.

Two scum townreading a guy voting for their scumbuddy just makes so little sense

[brainbomb]

I like this queef person. But I kinda feel like they need to be sorted out asap

[thamrick]

Just because I didn't directly address someone more than twice doesn't mean they shouldn't be an acceptable lynch. I bet the majority of my acceptable lynch pool at that time consisted of people whom I hadn't addressed often.

rj's reaction was fishy because it seemed insincere. He said he was "totally blindsided by Jamie's flip." That came across as forced because D1 he seemed to have a slight scumread of Jamie - suspicion at least - so I'm not sure why he would have been shocked at the flip.

Your first point is fair. Doesn't mean I don't find it odd that you stayed far away from Rj's erratic behavior.

You didn't address my question about how your arrived at your vote.

Can you point me to where you are getting that Rj seemed to have a Jamie scumread?

I still really want an answer to this question Tom. I don't want it to get lost

[Tom Bombadil]

I don’t have an answer - but that is the impression I gr at the time. I’d have to relook at d1 to see what gave me that impression

[thamrick]

@Tom - Tell me if I'm summarizing this correct, your case against Rj was based on his fishy reaction to the Jamiet flip due to him scumreading Jamiet

[Tom Bombadil]

Yup - the reaction seemed forced and insincere. I’d like to think this is a better conversation for tomorrow though.

[yavuzovic]

My analysis of both RJ and Jamie ISO puts scumteam at

{Ezio-yavuz--thamrick-MLQ}

Start with me!
That would proves this claim is wrong.

[thamrick]

Yup - the reaction seemed forced and insincere. I’d like to think this is a better conversation for tomorrow though.

That's fine. In the meantime, reread D1 and tell me why you think the reaction seemed forced and insincere. Lots of things about Rj seemed off to me. That wasn't one of them.

[brainbomb]

Can you both offer an opinion on my analysis of rj and jamie soft clearing balki?

[brainbomb]

My analysis of both RJ and Jamie ISO puts scumteam at

{Ezio-yavuz--thamrick-MLQ}

Start with me!
That would proves this claim is wrong.

Are you asking to be cop scanned?