Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[Foxcastle]

All right, on with bit. ##VOTE BALKI

[DemonRHK]

I need two of those things don't I?

##Vote bozo

[Balki Bartokomous]

Well wait a damn minute. I think I may be clear. ##unend

[MeanLaQueefa]

I'm hoping balki just gets shot personally, but I don't have the gun to do it.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I think I'm at least clear of being Hooker.

Looks like Thamrick saved me Night 1. He posted me as one of his town reads, and Reedeer as a null read. No way he saves a null read over a town read I think.

If I was Doc saved Night 1, and there were 2 RBs, I cannot be Hooker. Or at least I could only be Hooker if Reedeer is my teammate who lied about his RB.

[Balki Bartokomous]

That means I can only be Godfather or on the scum team with Reedeer.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Here is Thamrick's EON1 post:

thamrick
Night-1 00:04
page 43 Top town reads:
Brainbomb
Balki
Foxcastle

Slight town:
DemonRHK (feeling less good about this after nighttime interactions)
Yavuzovic
MeanLaQueefa
Bozo
Bo
​
===========================
Something's amiss:
Tom Bombadil
Maniac
ND
reedeer

Scum:
Rj​mcf
Vashta

[DemonRHK]

I think I'm at least clear of being Hooker.

Looks like Thamrick saved me Night 1. He posted me as one of his town reads, and Reedeer as a null read. No way he saves a null read over a town read I think.

If I was Doc saved Night 1, and there were 2 RBs, I cannot be Hooker. Or at least I could only be Hooker if Reedeer is my teammate who lied about his RB.

Not true.

##GM Note:

The Hooker and Nurse can RB each other, yes. In that case, the Nurse's save would be blocked because kills happen later in the Order of Operations, but both RB's would go through as they are simultaneous.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Damn. I guess that's right. I could be hooker doing a simultaneous RB.

We should still map out the Saves and see if we can eliminate any scenarios. But that rule may mean that we can't.

Night 1: Balki Nurse Saved, Reedeer RBed

[DemonRHK]

I think you are right

N1: Balki was nursed, and reedeer was hook'd (could be a fakeclaim)

N2: Maniac was nursed (But not protected!), and tham was hook'd

N3: Tom was nursed (And saved), and RHK was hook'd

N4: ???

[MeanLaQueefa]

Why would the nurse or mafia target either of you day 1? Balki almost got lynched day 1, no way nurse would think mafia immediately wanted him dead even if he was town, too easy of a mislynch and would give town more info about that day's wagons. Mafia's role block on balki only makes sense if he is scum because he probably would have claimed a PR role when he was almost killed day 1, but didn't. He shouldn't have been a top target for scum to rb in any case, unless he is scum wanting a soft clear. I have no idea why a nurse or scum would target reedeer N1 though.

[Tom Bombadil]

WHo has a gun?

[Tom Bombadil]

Never mind. That’s a moronic question. Don’t answer that

[Tom Bombadil]

I think there is merit to a mass claim here and just using poe. But manic let me know your thoughts too

Gunsmith can be a clear. RHK, Cop and maniac and I will all be clears.

[Tom Bombadil]

But I’m fine lynching Balki and then mean if he flips town. I think he is scum, but I would have expected him to catch thams crumbs much earlier - and the fact that Tham stayed alive gives me pause that scum didn’t catch them, and I think Balki would have

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE Balki

[Tom Bombadil]

Eh ##vote end

[Foxcastle]

Also ##END

I think we should have more discussion about a mass claim before we take a step we can't walk back. So, uh, don't do that while I'm sleeping, please.

[rdrivera2005]

Sorry for being away most of the day.

RIP Tham, great job saving Tom

Why are you voting to end? This take away any responsibility for the lynch. I agree that Balki is a good lunch, but having a discussion, maybe another wagon would be best for town.
If the gunsmith delivered his last gun he can probably claim and tell who has the gun. This will give us another clear and a town guided shoot (probably on Balki). The gun owner should not tell before the GS say so.

[MeanLaQueefa]

Gunsmith, claim already and get cleared, then let's shoot balki and get on with our lives.