I see what you're saying, but I don't find it very convincing.Foxcastle wrote: ↑Tue Jan 30, 2018 7:51 pmI'm town reading Mean. In her P52 summary of everything, she says a couple things that I don't think scum coming off a night in the Mafia QT would say.
In reading ND, she says "He scum read snowy throughout the game, and that’s an odd thing to do if you’re planning on killing him at night when you’re the only person who has voted for him"
In reading Rjm, "He also scumread snowy in his reads at the end of night, which is a really odd thing to do if he knew he was going to die."
Scum don't go into the Mafia QT knowing who they will kill. If Mean were scum, she would have just spent 24 hours in the Mafia QT and would know that even if there's general consensus, scum don't go in knowing how the discussion will come out. So I see those as town slips, defaulting to how she understands the game is usually played face-to-face because she didn't go to the Mafia QT.
(1) Look at ND's post on page 36:
That was several hours into the night. I can see this as an argument from Scum MLQ. I feel like you're making some assumptions about what went on in the Mafia QT in this game. You're saying that, if MLQ were scum, the discussion about the NK target in the QT would have prevented her from faking this argument about ND. But...so many variables there. I mean, if Mafia decided right away to kill Snowy and there was little dissent, then the argument makes a lot of sense as one fabricated by Scum MLQ.I still think snowy needs to be next. His D1 play is so out of touch with what he usually does. It's lazy and scum-indicative. he needs to go next.
(2) Your argument does not make sense with respect to RJ because the RJ post she mentioned was at EON. Scum MLQ, in trying to make an argument to defend Scum RJ or to gain town cred/pocket RJ by defending Town RJ, might consider how RJ read the NK target in his EON reads, right?
Those arguments are not very alignment indicative to me.
