Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[rdrivera2005]

@RJ - You are right, it's pure WIFOM. And I really dislike this hard/good/bad players. Last game our vets get caught first 4days and a newbie won the game for scum. IMHO is a lot easier to get ND lynched then a lurker like Bozo for example.

[brainbomb]

So do you agree ND Is scum? or are you just saying bo is using town reasoning. I dont think we can know if bo is using real reasoning or if ND is just a nitwit. the case is from a mindset of lynch ND imo. Its purely based on wagonomics with no supporting material. ND played like a clueless drunken oaf.

[Rjmcf]

@Demon looking at rd again, there is a difference between not posting any explanation (Ezio) and saying [paraphrasing] "I'm not going to put much reasoning because I'm going with my gut" (rd). I agree, D1 rd looks pretty scummy, but that vote on Jamie goes someway to settling it for me. He's obviously not towncleared but I'm townleaning.

[ND]

Sorry not much time to do much today. Will try to read and catch up more tomorrow.

[Tom Bombadil]

I don’t agree that ND is scum. I am unconvinced - but that does not impact my read of bo.

His case is built on the notion that Jamie did not save himself and scumteam seemingly did not try to save him - which has merit. I’m not sure why you think the case is without merit.

And ND is certainly a nitwit, that’s never been in doubt.

[rdrivera2005]

@RJ - Just to put things clear, when you say Rd you mean Reedeer or me? I think it's Reedeer, but it's confusing to me sometimes.

[brainbomb]

@ND

You did say this however.
On page 18...

"-Jamie is a lazy voter tossing his votes around on lurkers to hide his play he is scum for sure-"

##Vote ND

[Rjmcf]

@RJ - Just to put things clear, when you say Rd you mean Reedeer or me? I think it's Reedeer, but it's confusing to me sometimes.

Shit I'm sorry, that sucked. I was focussed on reedeer and then saw someone mention "rd" and assumed they meant reedeer. I was meaning reedeer, I won't shorten either name much now so it's more clear.

[brainbomb]

- Reads -
Town
Maniac
Vash - he is completely town. Get off him.

Bozo - also town. Needs to move. There is nothing scummy about bozo

Reedeer - also town. Probably right on ezio!

Meme- welcome. Should be an upgrade but I townlean darg. For a variety of reasons. His suggestion on holstering is not a bad idea day 1. As lookin at the ws sheet everyone wanted to blast the same 2 ppl.

DemonRHK - a demon with ideas is town!demon. Hes also doin pretty good at presenting things. I improved on this as hes not doing anything harmful.

Rjmcf - too radical to be scum. Wants his vote to be courted.
Mean - doubt it. Too well spoken early. Fallen off late a bit.
Balki- using emotional arguments but maybe hes actually annoyed at being targeted. Im losing my edge on him as hes cooled. Hes let the game breathe which he doesnt do as scum. So, im gonna let the game breathe as well.



Scum 4/5 are right imo.

Tom

Bo

ND

Ezio

Foxcastle


Further elaboration later. For now shoot Bo and lynch ND or Tom.

[ND]

That read on Jamie was brilliant and if I do get lynched and when I flip town; no one will be calling me a nitwit.

Anyway, like I said I will do my best to post some more tomorrow. No votes from me right now.

[Balki Bartokomous]

One of the downsides of being a lawyer is that sometimes you have to spend entire days surrounded by lawyers.

They're the absolute worst. It's been a day.

In any event, I'm on an airplane. I've been overserved. And I'm taking questions.

[Balki Bartokomous]

While we wait for your questions, I'm going to perform some magic tricks for the GOD thread.

@GOD Thread, watch this.

So, vote count right now:

ND (3): Bo_Sox, Yavuz, bb
Vashta (2): Bozo, MLQ
Ezio (2): rdrivera, reedeer
Tom (2): Foxy Knoxy, RJ
Brainbomb (1): Vashta
MLQ (1): Balki
Balki (1): Ezio
Darg (1): Tom

It's halfway through Day 1. Really hard to say where the final wagons are going to end up. But there are 4 bad guys trying hard to get a mislynch today. So where should we expect they are?

- Spread out
- Almost all on town
- On wagons they think they can actually flip

From this, with 4 scumbuckets living, I'm willing to bet 25 slap bracelets and a bucket full of pogs that the there is exactly 1 scum among Vashta, Bozo, and MLQ, and exactly one scum among Ezio, Rdrivera, and Reedeer. That's cause Vashta and Ezio have done next to nothing and they feel like easy lynches. That could mean either (a) one or both are scum, or (b) there is exactly one scum on their wagon.

I am fairly certain Reedeer is Town, which means we have a 50/50 shot at hitting scum in Ezio and Rdrivera. Not bad odds at all.

Boom. Truth grenade. You're welcome.

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Foxy Knoxy, I see you.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Ha! Just disappeared. I don't see you anymore.

I'M TAKING QUESTIONS!

[Balki Bartokomous]

Quick update:

"Users browsing this forum: Balki Bartokomous and 1 guest"

Foxy Knoxy left when I called him out. But who is this mysterious guest?

@Mysterious Guest, let's dance.

[Foxcastle]

Oh, I'm back. My main question is about slap bracelets and pogs, though.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Update: It's getting crowded in here:

"Users browsing this forum: Balki Bartokomous, Foxcastle, rdrivera2005 and 1 guest"

[Balki Bartokomous]

Oh, I'm back. My main question is about slap bracelets and pogs, though.

I'm a child of the 90s. Sounds like you're not.

[rdrivera2005]

@Balki - You are probably right and this is why I am keeping my vote on Ezio. I find a bit weird Reedeer follow my vote in both days even scumreading me. What do you think about it?

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Foxy Knoxy, give me three bullet points right now on why Tom is scum. The three best, alignment indicative reasons.