MAFIA 48 -The Gladiator- GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[Nephthys]

Current POE

Carambola
Chaqa
Damo
DemRHK
e.m.c
Hosuke
Jamie
Percy
RagingIke
Temasek
Vaporwave
Vecna
xorxes
yuuki

[xorxes]

With regards to the Wagon

Xorx - Votes with 23hrs left so him having no content
Food - 2:47 left, posting garbage and unjustified scum reads
Tem - 30 mins left, Other wagon is town
Jamie - 41 mins left, mentioned above
EMC - 14 mins so his reaction to being a wagon and the wideposting

Scummy reasons - Xorx/Jamie
Town - Food/Tem/EMC

Jamie was OMGUssing and he was also a wagon so he was at least in part voting in self-defence. I don't see how that is scummy. Tem's reason is towny only if the other wagons really were town, which we don't know. I'm not sure I follow why you think emc's reason was particularly towny, but I don't think it was particularly scummy either.

[RagingIke297]

With regards to the Wagon

Xorx - Votes with 23hrs left so him having no content
Food - 2:47 left, posting garbage and unjustified scum reads
Tem - 30 mins left, Other wagon is town
Jamie - 41 mins left, mentioned above
EMC - 14 mins so his reaction to being a wagon and the wideposting

Scummy reasons - Xorx/Jamie
Town - Food/Tem/EMC

Jamie was OMGUssing and he was also a wagon so he was at least in part voting in self-defence. I don't see how that is scummy. Tem's reason is towny only if the other wagons really were town, which we don't know. I'm not sure I follow why you think emc's reason was particularly towny, but I don't think it was particularly scummy either.

That post of Nephs is a dumpster fire

[Nephthys]

With regards to the Wagon

Xorx - Votes with 23hrs left so him having no content
Food - 2:47 left, posting garbage and unjustified scum reads
Tem - 30 mins left, Other wagon is town
Jamie - 41 mins left, mentioned above
EMC - 14 mins so his reaction to being a wagon and the wideposting

Scummy reasons - Xorx/Jamie
Town - Food/Tem/EMC

Jamie was OMGUssing and he was also a wagon so he was at least in part voting in self-defence. I don't see how that is scummy. Tem's reason is towny only if the other wagons really were town, which we don't know. I'm not sure I follow why you think emc's reason was particularly towny, but I don't think it was particularly scummy either.

Hmm true but OMGUS still 40 mins out is different to OMGUS 10 mins out.

Tem's vote comes from a towny mentality. If I am 60% sure you are town and 50% sure someone else is town I would vote for them. While it is potentially weak reason I personally think it townier than scummier. Note I still scum read him.

EMC had a new perspective that made some sort of sense to me. Maybe he just phrased it differently but I liked it.

I also note you offered to defense as to why you parked your vote so far out and then sat back?

[Nephthys]

With regards to the Wagon

Xorx - Votes with 23hrs left so him having no content
Food - 2:47 left, posting garbage and unjustified scum reads
Tem - 30 mins left, Other wagon is town
Jamie - 41 mins left, mentioned above
EMC - 14 mins so his reaction to being a wagon and the wideposting

Scummy reasons - Xorx/Jamie
Town - Food/Tem/EMC

Jamie was OMGUssing and he was also a wagon so he was at least in part voting in self-defence. I don't see how that is scummy. Tem's reason is towny only if the other wagons really were town, which we don't know. I'm not sure I follow why you think emc's reason was particularly towny, but I don't think it was particularly scummy either.

That post of Nephs is a dumpster fire

You wanna provide some insight into it then?

[xorxes]

I also note you offered to defense as to why you parked your vote so far out and then sat back?

I "parked" it because I wasn't able to read the thread until approx one hour before EOD. I didn't think it was a bad lynch, that's why I didn't change it. In hindsight, I should have switched to Chaqa, but I didn't have that much time to analyze and I don't know that I would have done it if I had had time anyway.

[yuuki]

Jamie looks good from it though, I reckon its more towny that he would push it as hard as he did as scum.

This is just dumb logic. Can't give a free pass to Jamie after that shit he pulled.

[yuuki]

Current POE

Carambola
Chaqa
Damo
DemRHK
e.m.c
Hosuke
Jamie
Percy
RagingIke
Temasek
Vaporwave
Vecna
xorxes
yuuki

POE -> Pillars of Eternity? Path of Exile?

[Temasek22]

Jamie looks good from it though, I reckon its more towny that he would push it as hard as he did as scum.

This is just dumb logic. Can't give a free pass to Jamie after that shit he pulled.

He proceeds to instant regret that though, so we should be fine

[ND]

##GM NOTE
This is a note for clarity. If a player is jailed they are silenced for the night phase. This is not in the game start post. This GM NOTE is an amendment to that post.

[Temasek22]

The relative disinterest in the EoD makes me think mafia was not under any pressure. I'll have to think through the implications a bit more, but immediate thought is that Hosuke is probably also innocent and maybe Yuuki isn't scum and is just terrible. Will analyze more thoroughly after the night ends and we have another death to work with, I suppose.

Yeah, there was no movement on the yukki/Hosuke wagons. I suspect they are both town.

Vecna's quietude and then coming in with an attitude after the fact makes me wonder if they are scum.

I highly doubt Vecna is scum, he's probably my top town read.

yukki/Hosuke don't seem to be S/S at all, and they both seem towny, but I won't be shocked if either is actually scum

[e.m.c^42]

##GM NOTE
This is a note for clarity. If a player is jailed they are silenced for the night phase. This is not in the game start post. This GM NOTE is an amendment to that post.

huh

Well, everyone should post if they can, makes it easier/less guessing for later phases if something does occur.

[e.m.c^42]

POE -> Pillars of Eternity? Path of Exile?

Process-of-elimination

[worcej]

Great job guys. Now it's the victim blaming part of the program, right?

Yes. Prado wagon sucked. Blah blah blah.

[worcej]

##GM NOTE
This is a note for clarity. If a player is jailed they are silenced for the night phase. This is not in the game start post. This GM NOTE is an amendment to that post.

Important information to know...

[worcej]

Will do more analysis when I am at work in the AM. For now, I am drinking scotch and watching The Chain, because that's my Wednesday tradition.

[ItsHosuke]

Ok, I'm online, and that was weird. What have I done to deserve this?

[ItsHosuke]

I can only say after the EoD1 shenanigans, Temy and Jamie don't appear really good. While yuuki and Ike have now joined Cara and rdr in my group of strong townleans.

[Vecna]

The relative disinterest in the EoD makes me think mafia was not under any pressure. I'll have to think through the implications a bit more, but immediate thought is that Hosuke is probably also innocent and maybe Yuuki isn't scum and is just terrible. Will analyze more thoroughly after the night ends and we have another death to work with, I suppose.

Yeah, there was no movement on the yukki/Hosuke wagons. I suspect they are both town.

Vecna's quietude and then coming in with an attitude after the fact makes me wonder if they are scum.

My quietude?

This Prado wagon feels meh

Wagons should never feel good.

I'm surprised you don't know this?

yep, pile on chaqa, fuck the judge

[Vecna]

Current POE

Carambola
Chaqa
Damo
DemRHK
e.m.c
Hosuke
Jamie
Percy
RagingIke
Temasek
Vaporwave
Vecna
xorxes
yuuki

POE -> Pillars of Eternity? Path of Exile?

A man of refined taste