Mafia 47 - The Sixth Mass Extinction - GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[brainbomb]

its okay to be gay tangerine

[bozotheclown]

What he is implying is that the town will gain more information by claiming while also giving mafia all the information.

Tit for tat kinda thing, instead more like tit for game if we do it.

I understand, but disagree. The mafia can just fakeclaim the Vt roles, and roles that can't prove themselves yet (like the stick bug, which is a cop around turn four or something), so we're doing five coin flips, while the Mafia team now knows exactly who to kill to ensure that they are coin flip probabilities. This also redefines the game in a way I consider to be less fun, and I want future crazy setups like this.

Yes, Percy is definitely the Cop.

@Percy: Were you crumbing your role with this post?

[brainbomb]

I understand, but disagree. The mafia can just fakeclaim the Vt roles, and roles that can't prove themselves yet (like the stick bug, which is a cop around turn four or something), so we're doing five coin flips, while the Mafia team now knows exactly who to kill to ensure that they are coin flip probabilities. This also redefines the game in a way I consider to be less fun, and I want future crazy setups like this.

Yes, Percy is definitely the Cop.

@Percy: Were you crumbing your role with this post?

oof

[Vaporwave]

yiikes, baiting me to say offensive stuff

[bozotheclown]

Maybe I missed this, but didn't we already determine there's a small possibility of both Masons being mafia? Your way to clear them doesn't work in that scenario.

But again, I don't think we have to worry about this. The maf team has to kill the Masons before the endgame. We should focus on other ppl for now.

If the two people who claim to be masons are mafia, they don't have a QT and therefore cannot coordinate to prove that they are town.

We do have to worry about this because there is a possibility that the "masons" are not masons.

Ohh I see. Forgot maf didn't have day chat.

We would want their answer to be a long post with pre-determined differences to ensure scum don't have time to replicate it.

Maybe one posts with normal formatting.
The.other.posts.with.different.formatting.

@xorxes: What do you think of this town slip? How does it compare to your having to wait for a GM answer to know the scum were given a list of all five fake roles?

[xorxes]

My current thinking for the scumteam: Hosuke, Fox, Jamiet, flash, dargo

Possibly Chaqa instead of dargo.

Sorry Fox, I really hope I'm wrong because I want you to be town and that emc is the scum, but at this point I think it's you.

[brainbomb]

@bo_sox

It isnt scummy for you to convey to me why youre town. its an imperative because I am not a soothsayer. I cant just guess like im playing on deity mode and know exactly your alogn.

xorxes insists youre town for trying to lynch the vig.

this is the kind of reasoning and leniency being given to you.
anti town things = townbo


?

[brainbomb]

My current thinking for the scumteam: Hosuke, Fox, Jamiet, flash, dargo

Possibly Chaqa instead of dargo.

Sorry Fox, I really hope I'm wrong because I want you to be town and that emc is the scum, but at this point I think it's you.

yea probably every single one of those is town.

[Vaporwave]

Since we're talking Hosuke and people are voting for him, it is that bad to have his mason reveal? depending on who is mason, we can picture if they could be both scum

[Percy Williams]

I understand, but disagree. The mafia can just fakeclaim the Vt roles, and roles that can't prove themselves yet (like the stick bug, which is a cop around turn four or something), so we're doing five coin flips, while the Mafia team now knows exactly who to kill to ensure that they are coin flip probabilities. This also redefines the game in a way I consider to be less fun, and I want future crazy setups like this.

Yes, Percy is definitely the Cop.

@Percy: Were you crumbing your role with this post?

When I was replying to whatever I replied to, I was mainly thinking of the stick bug because that was my role. It would also be suspicious to know the details of a random role so I kept it vague, (because I am known to be dumb) and didn't want to reveal my role at this point. I meant to drop more crumbs, but I ended up revealing way to early.

[Vaporwave]

what are your current reads, Percy?

[bozotheclown]

Eh?

Oh, I thought we were just posting random things. The post at the same time strategy to find our masons is inherently flawed, as Itshosuke has made it clear that he and his partner are in different time zones.

Being in different timezones does not prevent them from being online at some agreed time together, which may be morning for one and late evening for the other, for example.

I'm going to ##VOTE ItsHosuke for now because there's something fishy going on when the two people with claimed powers that can threaten Mafia are the two leading wagons and there may be a powerthief on the loose.

Why are you voting a verifiable town role before the claim has been resolved? Doesn't your logic on Percy extend to Hosuke?

[Percy Williams]

I am super unsure this game, but I give solid Town to Brainbomb, Rdrivera, Damo, E.M.C^42, and espresso.

[xorxes]

If the two people who claim to be masons are mafia, they don't have a QT and therefore cannot coordinate to prove that they are town.

We do have to worry about this because there is a possibility that the "masons" are not masons.

Ohh I see. Forgot maf didn't have day chat.

We would want their answer to be a long post with pre-determined differences to ensure scum don't have time to replicate it.

Maybe one posts with normal formatting.
The.other.posts.with.different.formatting.

@xorxes: What do you think of this town slip? How does it compare to your having to wait for a GM answer to know the scum were given a list of all five fake roles?

I don't give it any weight. It could be real but it is also really easy to fake. I'm really null on EP. Currently I don't have a place for him in the team but I can easily see him there as well instead of flash or dargo for example.

As for my "slip", don't put any weight on that either. I don't do that kind of theatrics but you don't have to believe it.

Question for you though: did you ask the GMs about the fake role list and whether the roles were randomly assigned?

[bozotheclown]

Yes, Percy is definitely the Cop.

@Percy: Were you crumbing your role with this post?

When I was replying to whatever I replied to, I was mainly thinking of the stick bug because that was my role. It would also be suspicious to know the details of a random role so I kept it vague, (because I am known to be dumb) and didn't want to reveal my role at this point. I meant to drop more crumbs, but I ended up revealing way to early.

So this was meant to be a crumb?

[brainbomb]

thank you percy.

Im actually the mafia arsonist though.

[Percy Williams]

what are your current reads, Percy?

I want you to know that as soon as I posted the previous post, I immediately pushed post and wrote what could be a perfect response to this. I would have quoted this in that message if I had seen it. It's just my luck that things like this happen to me.

[Percy Williams]

thank you percy.

Im actually the mafia arsonist though.

[bozotheclown]

Ohh I see. Forgot maf didn't have day chat.

We would want their answer to be a long post with pre-determined differences to ensure scum don't have time to replicate it.

Maybe one posts with normal formatting.
The.other.posts.with.different.formatting.

@xorxes: What do you think of this town slip? How does it compare to your having to wait for a GM answer to know the scum were given a list of all five fake roles?

I don't give it any weight. It could be real but it is also really easy to fake. I'm really null on EP. Currently I don't have a place for him in the team but I can easily see him there as well instead of flash or dargo for example.

As for my "slip", don't put any weight on that either. I don't do that kind of theatrics but you don't have to believe it.

Question for you though: did you ask the GMs about the fake role list and whether the roles were randomly assigned?

Yes, before the game started.

[xorxes]

Oh, I thought we were just posting random things. The post at the same time strategy to find our masons is inherently flawed, as Itshosuke has made it clear that he and his partner are in different time zones.

Being in different timezones does not prevent them from being online at some agreed time together, which may be morning for one and late evening for the other, for example.

I'm going to ##VOTE ItsHosuke for now because there's something fishy going on when the two people with claimed powers that can threaten Mafia are the two leading wagons and there may be a powerthief on the loose.

Why are you voting a verifiable town role before the claim has been resolved? Doesn't your logic on Percy extend to Hosuke?

Have you read the last few pages?

Yes, ideally we don't lynch any of those three, but if the choice is among those three then I rather vote Hosuke because they can clear themselves if they are town and also because the other two are more valuable to town if they are town.

There is zero risk of mislynching Hosuke.