Mafia 42 - Space Ghost Coast to Coast - OFFICIAL GAME THREAD

[xorxes]

I just re-read and it does reveal the desperado. So we can play it either way, not sure which would be best. Vote or desperado.

How can wasting a vote on a known scum be better?

[ghug]

##vote Jamie.
##end

Wp Tom.

I don't think we should use desperato here. Stick to usual town PR. Don't claim unless you're under pressure or if scum outted you anyways.

Yeah, I think the real question is if we want to leave the scans alive to desperado later and save lynches. Does scum have any decent PRs?

[Tom Bombadil]

I just re-read and it does reveal the desperado. So we can play it either way, not sure which would be best. Vote or desperado.

How can wasting a vote on a known scum be better?

Because it would allow the desperado to stay hidden longer in case we need a chance late game for them to make a hero shot.

[xorxes]

I just re-read and it does reveal the desperado. So we can play it either way, not sure which would be best. Vote or desperado.

How can wasting a vote on a known scum be better?

OK, I see some possible advantages

[Ezio]

##vote Jamie.
##end

Wp Tom.

I don't think we should use desperato here. Stick to usual town PR. Don't claim unless you're under pressure or if scum outted you anyways.

Yeah, I think the real question is if we want to leave the scans alive to desperado later and save lynches. Does scum have any decent PRs?

Only roleblocker.

[xorxes]

I just re-read and it does reveal the desperado. So we can play it either way, not sure which would be best. Vote or desperado.

How can wasting a vote on a known scum be better?

Because it would allow the desperado to stay hidden longer in case we need a chance late game for them to make a hero shot.

Yep. Downside is we waste two days lynching known scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

Well played, Tom.

[LordQuas]

I just re-read and it does reveal the desperado. So we can play it either way, not sure which would be best. Vote or desperado.

it's actually still worth it I think since then we remove 2 scum today at MINIMUM, get a guaranteed town, and the desperado is going to guarantee have their shot tomorrow as well b/c no way scum ever kill them tonight

^^ desperado is also going to be guaranteed to live another day and get their 3rd shot off tomorrow

[ghug]

Well played, Tom.

Nice, you can retract now Tom.

[ghug]

Tom, why not claim everything EoN tonight?

[LordQuas]

Tom, why not claim everything EoN tonight?

bwuh?

[ghug]

Tom, why not claim everything EoN tonight?

bwuh?

As opposed to what he did do. Deny copness, get better reads, hope scum decides they have someone better to kill tomorrow.

[rdrivera2005]

I just re-read and it does reveal the desperado. So we can play it either way, not sure which would be best. Vote or desperado.

How can wasting a vote on a known scum be better?

Because it would allow the desperado to stay hidden longer in case we need a chance late game for them to make a hero shot.

Incredible job Tom.
The good part of not using Desperado is to keep it as a holy Mary. The bad part is we will have two days (short if we end) and two nights with no actual play.
Probably not using it is the best call.

[Tom Bombadil]

Tom, why not claim everything EoN tonight?

Its not a guarantee with my work and the deadline moved up an hour from "normal" that I would be able to post. Plus, I guess I got excited.

[LordQuas]

Tom, why not claim everything EoN tonight?

bwuh?

As opposed to what he did do. Deny copness, get better reads, hope scum decides they have someone better to kill tomorrow.

ah I see it, I wouldn't risk it myself. There's a chance he hit the RBer with one of his red peeks and killing that is SUPER valuable to town as well. This saves us from potentially getting another ML today as well /shrug

[LordQuas]

How can wasting a vote on a known scum be better?

Because it would allow the desperado to stay hidden longer in case we need a chance late game for them to make a hero shot.

Incredible job Tom.
The good part of not using Desperado is to keep it as a holy Mary. The bad part is we will have two days (short if we end) and two nights with no actual play.
Probably not using it is the best call.

... you mean hail mary? I think we use it since they are still going to get a guaranteed third shot tomorrow (or today if we wanna get spicy with it). We're not actually losing that much by using desperado shot today imo

[Ezio]

Because it would allow the desperado to stay hidden longer in case we need a chance late game for them to make a hero shot.

Incredible job Tom.
The good part of not using Desperado is to keep it as a holy Mary. The bad part is we will have two days (short if we end) and two nights with no actual play.
Probably not using it is the best call.

... you mean hail mary? I think we use it since they are still going to get a guaranteed third shot tomorrow (or today if we wanna get spicy with it). We're not actually losing that much by using desperado shot today imo

The third shit tomorrow is worth much less than shots later in the game when the scum pool had narrowed.

[bozotheclown]

I was fairly certain Tom was indicating he had a cop scan on Jamie, which is why I was voting and scum reading Jamie D2. ghug obviously picked up on it right away when he claimed a positive scan on Jamie. Based on the voting, there were a lot of town who missed it, but at least one scum understood what Tom was doing.

[LordQuas]

Incredible job Tom.
The good part of not using Desperado is to keep it as a holy Mary. The bad part is we will have two days (short if we end) and two nights with no actual play.
Probably not using it is the best call.

... you mean hail mary? I think we use it since they are still going to get a guaranteed third shot tomorrow (or today if we wanna get spicy with it). We're not actually losing that much by using desperado shot today imo

The third shit tomorrow is worth much less than shots later in the game when the scum pool had narrowed.

actually they can hold it another day if they want since

Scum has to kill Tom tonight or risk another cop peak
Doc heals Desperado N4
Shot day 4

/shrug I think it's aight but

[xorxes]

I was fairly certain Tom was indicating he had a cop scan on Jamie, which is why I was voting and scum reading Jamie D2. ghug obviously picked up on it right away when he claimed a positive scan on Jamie. Based on the voting, there were a lot of town who missed it, but at least one scum understood what Tom was doing.

You changed your vote from Jamie to thd right after Jamie voted thd