M1036 Flipless Coven Hunt I Game Thread

[miminena]

We don't allow posting at night on any site I've played on before, but as far as revealing anything he knows at his earliest opportunity? It's not what he did last game, but he also didn't wait very long either. IIIRC, he tried a single gambit which didn't immediately work and then spouted out with it shortly afterward before every other player had checked in, so it still could have theoretically yielded results.

In a game with an apprentice, it's not too bad, because generally a village apprentice is going to choose to back up the gravedigger vs other roles. (Last game there was an equivalent role to gravedigger so it would have been a worse play to reveal immediately.) There is always the chance that the apprentice is wolf sided, however, so that's a calculus. Most gravediggers don't take that into account, however. And really, because of the flipless alignment, outing yourself too early is less bad than in other games, typically.

I've never actually played with Will, just watched him play, so--take this for what it's worth? But my guess is that Will claims more conservatively about claiming than Chomps does by quite a bit and would have counseled against an immediate claim if they were in wolfchat together.

ah, i forgot about apprentice. that changes my thoughts on this a bit maybe. still think will/chomps is a rather likely pairing

rather likely? Do you genuinely think I in a 3 scum team choose to swap my vote last second to kill my wolf teammate and post him as mafia when there's no other role that can confirm this and a wrong count messes up with solving?

There's no mechanical benefit for w!me pushing w!will and claiminging the redcheck on him unless the team is exactly w!yazu as third who I was also voting for most of the day! You really see me as this super hyper busser that's trying to kill their teammates as fast as possible?

last time someone defended themselves in a game i was in by saying they would never be a super hyper busser they were scum so yeah

the damo kill does change my opinion on this a bit since he was pushing non bussers

[miminena]

meh actually wagon diversity is probably good

##vote butter

[miminena]

ah, i forgot about apprentice. that changes my thoughts on this a bit maybe. still think will/chomps is a rather likely pairing

rather likely? Do you genuinely think I in a 3 scum team choose to swap my vote last second to kill my wolf teammate and post him as mafia when there's no other role that can confirm this and a wrong count messes up with solving?

There's no mechanical benefit for w!me pushing w!will and claiminging the redcheck on him unless the team is exactly w!yazu as third who I was also voting for most of the day! You really see me as this super hyper busser that's trying to kill their teammates as fast as possible?

last time someone defended themselves in a game i was in by saying they would never be a super hyper busser they were scum so yeah

the damo kill does change my opinion on this a bit since he was pushing non bussers

fme bus credit is real and can easily outweigh losing a member

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

meh actually wagon diversity is probably good

##vote butter

miminena, what are you doing? They might decide you're antipairing with me!

[BunnyGo]

hello
I didn't have time to write any EoN posts but the odds of me dying were low anyways
yes I did show up almost immediately after EoN. This isn't the best phase end time for me
I still feel like bunny is scum due to the reaction test yesterday but bunny is posting a bunch so ill give him a break
glitterbomb has low participation and one vote, which looks quite like a scum trying to save a teammate
##vote glitterbomb for now

The reaction test that was both all in your mind and didn’t happen the way you described?

you dropped the gimmick almost immediately after something that would have caused you to lose interest in it if you were scum
as I mentioned, this wasn't what I expected to happen (that was a drop in posting), but it's still scum-indicative
also this "all in my mind" nonsense is illogical. There has to be a reason why I posted that question, so either I was reaction testing you or I'm lying.
why are you so focused on this?

I already provided the receipts that you’re mistaken.

In any case, you’re not like you’re town self.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

The reaction test that was both all in your mind and didn’t happen the way you described?

you dropped the gimmick almost immediately after something that would have caused you to lose interest in it if you were scum
as I mentioned, this wasn't what I expected to happen (that was a drop in posting), but it's still scum-indicative
also this "all in my mind" nonsense is illogical. There has to be a reason why I posted that question, so either I was reaction testing you or I'm lying.
why are you so focused on this?

I already provided the receipts that you’re mistaken.

In any case, you’re not like you’re town self.

your 'receipts' (sounds like a word a scum would use to signal btw) consist of saying that you intended on dropping the gimmick anyways
this is possible, but far more likely that you just dropped it in response to having to break it to answer my question

[Jamiet99uk]

RIP Damo

##Vote Diploma Cyan Dwarf Are.

[Jamiet99uk]

I wonder what role Damo was.

[BunnyGo]

Back after Shabbat. Shabbat shalom mother***ers. (A very traditional greeting)

[ButterscotchReader]

##vote butter

placeholder based on the nk before i look more into it. maybe not her but off the top of my head that's who damo was generally pushing

They were? Okay. I'll have to take your word for it since they made no impression upon me whatsoever.

[miminena]

##call gm

are we allowed to talk to GT in this game

[miminena]

##vote butter

placeholder based on the nk before i look more into it. maybe not her but off the top of my head that's who damo was generally pushing

They were? Okay. I'll have to take your word for it since they made no impression upon me whatsoever.

yeah, i quoted the post where he condensed his scum reads at some point after this one

[ButterscotchReader]

rather likely? Do you genuinely think I in a 3 scum team choose to swap my vote last second to kill my wolf teammate and post him as mafia when there's no other role that can confirm this and a wrong count messes up with solving?

There's no mechanical benefit for w!me pushing w!will and claiminging the redcheck on him unless the team is exactly w!yazu as third who I was also voting for most of the day! You really see me as this super hyper busser that's trying to kill their teammates as fast as possible?

I know this wasn't directed at me, but if you're feeling inclined toward playing that way this game, please feel free.

[GlitterBomb]

hello
I didn't have time to write any EoN posts but the odds of me dying were low anyways
yes I did show up almost immediately after EoN. This isn't the best phase end time for me
I still feel like bunny is scum due to the reaction test yesterday but bunny is posting a bunch so ill give him a break
glitterbomb has low participation and one vote, which looks quite like a scum trying to save a teammate
##vote glitterbomb for now

Low participation? I have way more than you. I just counted.

Also, go look at my past games. There’s only three so it’s not tough. I historically don’t vote a lot. I like my vote to mean something and to be based on something. But given this coming out of nowhere and that Damo was suspicious of you as well…



##vote DiplomacyandWarfare

[miminena]

actually possibly worth considering people outside of DW

ofc it might just be the simplest explanation and he is indeed scum but it might be someone on the periphery of damo's pushes who is generally town read otherwise

hence why i think wagon diversity is good here

[miminena]

actually possibly worth considering people outside of DW

ofc it might just be the simplest explanation and he is indeed scum but it might be someone on the periphery of damo's pushes who is generally town read otherwise

hence why i think wagon diversity is good here

actually not just possibly worth considering, they definitely should be considered

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

by the way bona is the sniper

[Jamiet99uk]

by the way bona is the sniper

There was just a whole conversation about how he claimed sniper.

Why did you feel the need to make this post?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

by the way bona is the sniper

There was just a whole conversation about how he claimed sniper.

Why did you feel the need to make this post?

because that's my watchman info

[Jamiet99uk]

by the way bona is the sniper

There was just a whole conversation about how he claimed sniper.

Why did you feel the need to make this post?

because that's my watchman info

....and why did you feel the need to claim Watchman at this point in time?