I was looking D1 again as it´s the best source of information and tried to do some vote analysis. Jamiet and DrCJG were both voting Xorxes until 5 hours to go. Then Jamiet changed to Damo, pushing his lynch. Two possible reasons for this move: Xorxes is scum and he was bussing or DRCJ is scum and he don't want to stay on the same wagon.
Later Dr moved to Worcej and Xorxes have no votes. Then with almost one hour to go, Ike voted Xorxes.
Then in the last minute Jamiet also changed his vote to Xorxes and tryed to get Bozo to also change. Then Dr also moved back his vote to Xorxes.
I know I am voting for Dr now, but this analysis is indicating me that maybe I am wrong.
I see two reasons for Jamiet moving from Damo to Xorxes: trying to effectively lynch Xorxes, something really unlikely as Xorxes can still vote for Damo or he wants to distance himself from Nepthys who were already voting for Damo and maybe get a tie and a possible lynch of Bozo and Damo in the following days. In this case I can't see a scum DrCJG also voting Xorxes at the last minute.
This make me think I could be wrong and Dr could be town and Xorxes isn´t that clear as I thought. I still think Bozo is town, can't see Jamiet pushing a scum mate to tie the vote the way he did (well, considering Bozo didn´t tie, it's possible, but all the other interactions between them point me the other way).
Then we have Brain. I really dislike most of the Brain play, specially on D2, and his comment about not having a Vig seems really like PR fishing.
So I decided to give another look at Jamiet and Nepthys interactions before I made my mind and what stroke me as interesting is how Nepthys defended Jamiet until the end but never gave a clear read on him. He also throwed shade at almost every other player beside Brain and Xorxes.
Nephthys
Day-1 22:50
page 9 /orig
Sadly, not much development so far.
Some more thoughts from what I can see
Bozo -slight townlean - comes straight in discussing claiming, did something similar in M40 (as scum). To his credit though, he does seem to be pushing it a little harder this game. Would like someone to weigh in a little on his town meta/refer me to such a game.
CJG - townlean - Was scum with me in cultafia and so I paid a reasonable amount of attention to his style of posting, seems different here.
Food - slight scumlean - awkward first posts but seems to be throwing the whole new thing around a little too much for my liking
Damo - scumlean - hasn't really contributed too much in my opinion, making a reasonable amount of posts about not much. Would like to hear some thought out opinions from him, notably very little reasoning behind most of his posts (#122).
Worcej - claimed town?
Everyone else is either null, hasn't posted enough or is called brainbomb.
Nephthys
Day-1 00:03
page 18 /orig
Just did some re-reading,
I find food, thd, worecj, Ike and damo to be relatively light on content.
For today I am willing to excuse food for being newer and still getting to grips with life.
Ike hasn't really been around at all but jumps on xorxes. I personally don't find the whole favours thing that concerning as of now.
Damo has ?decided? not to defend himself, would be perhaps open to giving him another day, if not though he's my first pick lynch tomorrow for now.
I am happy to lynch any of the above but honestly would prefer thd or worecj. I will alter my vote if necessary.
Nephthys
Night-1 22:51
page 20 /orig
↑bozotheclown: "Maybe Jamie is the scum, and the scum team is thdfrance, Jamie, brainbomb. Or maybe Jamie was bussing xorxes and it is ..."
What is the case on both jamie and brain (individually)
Does jamies extend beyond the defense of worecj?
Does brains extend beyond him not spamming?
Nephthys
Night-1 22:14
page 20 /orig
@bozo, would you mind posting a full read list for me, I'm struggling to put together some things.
With regards to your explanations I can see, to a degree, where you are coming from although I don't think Jamie would jump off a lead wagon when it is that close if he was scum. One vote would have swung it to either No lynch or Xorxes. I don't see a reason for a scum Jamie to change his vote last minute like that.
Personally I am town reading Jamie more now.
Nephthys
Day-2 43:27
page 29 /orig
Just read the last 5 pages or so, thoughts are,
- Food appears scummier
- I revert my townclear of CJG (was based of meta)
- Tdh is still my top scumread
- I don't understand the case on bozo (assuming it extends past the hypoclaim)
- Brain's excerpts from scum chat are my favourite thing in the world
- There still seems like a lot of filler posts from people (I want to especially mention worecj)
So, looking the posts above from Nepthys he do remember that Jamiet and Brain exist but either ignored them or townread Jamiet and softed a townread on Brain. To be honest, he also ignored Xorxes in almost all his posts. So, I think it´s either Brain or Xorxes.
The Nepthys interaction with Brain and my gut feeling is telling me it´s Brain.
##vote Brain