M1036 Flipless Coven Hunt I Game Thread

[Jamiet99uk]

I am probably dying tonight so questioning my standing won't generate helpful discussion

scum can afford to keep you alive for another day and kill you n2 so they can use their kill to hunt a different pr or make a reads-based kill

Accurate

[damo666]

An opinion you're entitled to. I disagree. I'm good with moving on for now. What would you like to spend our time and energy on?

Ok as an exercise let us suppose that we are both town and there was no bussing day 1 which of {Dip, Butter, Jamie} are the scumpair?

I am town.

Why does it have to be D&W and Butters?

Because the constraint was no bussers and Gbomb and I both town. That only leaves 3 left. I do not necessarily believe there were no bussers or that gbomb is town.

[BunnyGo]

I’m gonna throw this out there, and Bunny (or anyone else) please feel free to “hop” in if I’m stating something incorrectly. :) Bunny….hop….it’s funny.

Bunny claimed sniper.

Sniper missed, meaning they incorrectly guessed the role of who they were targeting.

So would it not give town more info to share who the intended target was and why?

I did NOT claim sniper. That was a joke.

Ummmm, post #483?????

Where on earth was it made clear that you were joking? Because I didn't gather that and I don't see how that was helpful or funny? If anything it appears MORE scummy to me.

You thought I was legitimately claiming to be a member of the scum team?

Ask me a question

what is your role and alignment

I am the Coven’s Sniper!

[BunnyGo]

Was just rereading and the silliness and earnestness of this post! It’s very funny and charming.

...and scummy?

VERY scummy!!!!!! It very much came across as "vote my way, I'm right on this, but I can't tell you why"

So maybe the argument could be made that in what world would a true mafia do that? "Vote with me because I say so" doesn't exactly hold a lot of weight in a game of secrets and deceit. That perspective makes me maybe see the earnestness you're pointing to. MAYBE....

It came immediately during a conversation about maybe the mice should claim, and then he said "umm...ohh...maybe I should do something I dunno"

IN CONTEXT it's very clear what's going on which is why I was laughing at his idea that he hadn't clearly outed a mouse.

[damo666]

I am probably dying tonight so questioning my standing won't generate helpful discussion

scum can afford to keep you alive for another day and kill you n2 so they can use their kill to hunt a different pr or make a reads-based kill

Accurate

However killing anyone else provides unnecessary information so I suspect Chomps will be it. Nobody else is particularly widely townread.

[BunnyGo]

unlikely unless you think both me and yavuz were lying for some reason and haven't been called out for it

Yeah. I’m pretty sure I know the sniper and was already town reading them before they missed a shot. I even think I know who they shot at.

yeah it was me and i guessed myself as sniper (i'm mouse so it failed)

(joke btw so to not cause confusion with claims)

the level of reading comprehension and conclusion drawing so far this game is below our normal standard...so I do suggest you make clear your irony.

[BunnyGo]

Towncore:

BofA
Mimi
Yavu
Bunny
Jamie
Chomps

In there is 2 mice, 1 gravedigger, 1 sniper, and probably a judge

POE:
Glitter
Butter
Diploma
damo


Easy game.

a bit interested on glitter not in town core? i have her noted down as the towniest player atm and i'm curious as to the opposite perspective

She reminds me in tone/posting style/focus/etc etc of her scum game (which I think was her last one).

Nothing I can clearly point to, and maybe it's just who she is.

[BunnyGo]

So you're claiming:

1) Chomps is town gravedigger -> Just is scum
2) Judge is town
3) yavu is scum
4) yavu decided to out the mice and target the one non-scum mouse?

Based on what happened today, yes those are current scenarios I’m mulling over as very likely in my head.

it's stuff like this i'm talking about. i haven't considered yet if her worldview is right or not but it does feel like she genuinely believes it

Yeah...her misreading my "claim" of being the Coven's Sniper seems...I guess towny? But she seemed a bit "confused" and earnest the game she was scum too.

[BunnyGo]

...and scummy?

Not to my eyes.

So your theory is town!yav decided to out town!mimi and ended up lucking into exposing scum Will. Yes?

yup

[damo666]

Assuming Chomps is not scum gravedigger who killed town Will (negligible enough imo)) then of the Will voters I think the only possible busser was Yav. This would make sense as Yav was trying to get mimi dk's which would ensure either he or Will got poison. Once it was clear mimi was not gonna be the dk he switched to Will which would gain cred if Will was dk'd but also gave hope of a tie.

Or Yav is town and scum are within {Dip, Butter, Gbomb, Jamie}.

Either way I think tomorrow's kill should be Yav or one of those 4 with Butter the least preferred.

[BunnyGo]

Assuming Chomps is not scum gravedigger who killed town Will (negligible enough imo)) then of the Will voters I think the only possible busser was Yav. This would make sense as Yav was trying to get mimi dk's which would ensure either he or Will got poison. Once it was clear mimi was not gonna be the dk he switched to Will which would gain cred if Will was dk'd but also gave hope of a tie.

Or Yav is town and scum are within {Dip, Butter, Gbomb, Jamie}.

Either way I think tomorrow's kill should be Yav or one of those 4 with Butter the least preferred.

I disagree that yav seems at all scummy.

he was very willing to go to Just too, AND the progression of his posts seemed authentic and not like he and Just had planned it prior.

[BunnyGo]

Assuming Chomps is not scum gravedigger who killed town Will (negligible enough imo)) then of the Will voters I think the only possible busser was Yav. This would make sense as Yav was trying to get mimi dk's which would ensure either he or Will got poison. Once it was clear mimi was not gonna be the dk he switched to Will which would gain cred if Will was dk'd but also gave hope of a tie.

Or Yav is town and scum are within {Dip, Butter, Gbomb, Jamie}.

Either way I think tomorrow's kill should be Yav or one of those 4 with Butter the least preferred.

There is a possible mech reason maybe to kill him anyways...but I'd rather just hunt scum.

[damo666]

Assuming Chomps is not scum gravedigger who killed town Will (negligible enough imo)) then of the Will voters I think the only possible busser was Yav. This would make sense as Yav was trying to get mimi dk's which would ensure either he or Will got poison. Once it was clear mimi was not gonna be the dk he switched to Will which would gain cred if Will was dk'd but also gave hope of a tie.

Or Yav is town and scum are within {Dip, Butter, Gbomb, Jamie}.

Either way I think tomorrow's kill should be Yav or one of those 4 with Butter the least preferred.

I disagree that yav seems at all scummy.

he was very willing to go to Just too, AND the progression of his posts seemed authentic and not like he and Just had planned it prior.

I think no busser slightly more likely than scumYav. How would you order {Dip, Gb, Jam, But}? Btw that's my order S-> T

[BunnyGo]

Assuming Chomps is not scum gravedigger who killed town Will (negligible enough imo)) then of the Will voters I think the only possible busser was Yav. This would make sense as Yav was trying to get mimi dk's which would ensure either he or Will got poison. Once it was clear mimi was not gonna be the dk he switched to Will which would gain cred if Will was dk'd but also gave hope of a tie.

Or Yav is town and scum are within {Dip, Butter, Gbomb, Jamie}.

Either way I think tomorrow's kill should be Yav or one of those 4 with Butter the least preferred.

I disagree that yav seems at all scummy.

he was very willing to go to Just too, AND the progression of his posts seemed authentic and not like he and Just had planned it prior.

I think no busser slightly more likely than scumYav. How would you order {Dip, Gb, Jam, But}? Btw that's my order S-> T

D&W >>> But > Gb >> Jam

[BunnyGo]

I disagree that yav seems at all scummy.

he was very willing to go to Just too, AND the progression of his posts seemed authentic and not like he and Just had planned it prior.

I think no busser slightly more likely than scumYav. How would you order {Dip, Gb, Jam, But}? Btw that's my order S-> T

D&W >>> But > Gb >> Jam

and put you (damo) tied with Butter

[miminena]

new page

how do you know this... are you being coached in scum chat

[ButterscotchReader]

ok so for low posters yesterday I see chomps, me, yavuzovic, jamie (this is by words, not by posts), will and damo
damo seems towny except for a vote history that is mostly bandwagoning
will is dead and probably scum
I have no idea what jamie is up to, and that slot is always hard to read so I'm putting a light scumread on that for now
yavuzovic is the most likely scummate for will and has a lot of low-effort posts
chomps is... the gravedigger? but also has like no opinions on anything other than bandwagoning("it sounds fun, ima do it")

So I don't even know how to calculate this or see isolated posts or anything. Could somebody help me, please?

[BunnyGo]

ok so for low posters yesterday I see chomps, me, yavuzovic, jamie (this is by words, not by posts), will and damo
damo seems towny except for a vote history that is mostly bandwagoning
will is dead and probably scum
I have no idea what jamie is up to, and that slot is always hard to read so I'm putting a light scumread on that for now
yavuzovic is the most likely scummate for will and has a lot of low-effort posts
chomps is... the gravedigger? but also has like no opinions on anything other than bandwagoning("it sounds fun, ima do it")

So I don't even know how to calculate this or see isolated posts or anything. Could somebody help me, please?

https://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/front_page

[BunnyGo]

ok so for low posters yesterday I see chomps, me, yavuzovic, jamie (this is by words, not by posts), will and damo
damo seems towny except for a vote history that is mostly bandwagoning
will is dead and probably scum
I have no idea what jamie is up to, and that slot is always hard to read so I'm putting a light scumread on that for now
yavuzovic is the most likely scummate for will and has a lot of low-effort posts
chomps is... the gravedigger? but also has like no opinions on anything other than bandwagoning("it sounds fun, ima do it")

So I don't even know how to calculate this or see isolated posts or anything. Could somebody help me, please?

https://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/front_page

Click Day 1

Or "Game Status"

Then you can see vote history, post history, and can click anything that's a hyperlink to see the posts where votes happened or ISO someone.

If you go up and click "Search among all messages" you can do other searches.

[miminena]

appreciate the +1s bongo

When you post based shit, I upvote it.

I did ask in my Discord journal about an upvote I got from Glitter on post number 509, and I couldn't decide what to make of it.

Why ask your journal instead of the person who did it??? I liked the spunk of the post. It reminded me of the feisty bunny I remembered from previous games. Nothing much to read into…

eh maybe this post feels a bit performative (although it is a good point so maybe not)

still generally think glitter is townier than not from d1 (and i see that bunny has responded to my question, i'll get to that in a bit)