M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[aarodactyl]

Aaro, everyone thinks you were very excited and townie the last time a PR claimed. Why aren't you excited and townie now?

1) did HR claim? I see a lot of talk about claiming. But really:

2) it’s been a rough day, and I’m on some new medication and it’s all making me pretty exhausted. It’s been making it rough to read closely

Also even HR if HR is priest, that doesn’t make us that much closer to finding scum. Even though they were rated low, I wanted to flip Damo and Bona more and that’s still true.

[aarodactyl]

Also when Durga claimed, we could catch a lot of scum. Now it just clears HR

[ghug]

Fair answers. Wanna ##VOTE damo?

Feeling a +1 from bona or celaph every time I shade one of the other new players is really weird.

[ghug]

Bona's cheeky like Donny Dude.

[ghug]

Bona, I townread Donny Dude for that cheekiness, but he was actually my scumbuddy. How does that make you feel?

[Bonatogether]

[Balki Bartokomous]

I feel like Flum is Town, FYI.

[ghug]

I feel like Flum is Town, FYI.

Do elaborate

[Balki Bartokomous]

But...I also think he’s smart and crafty, and Ime not sure I’ve ever seen him roll scum. So I am hesitant to say that...

But there ya go. I said it.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I don’t get the impression that Flum is putting something on. He has been present. He says what he thinks. He doesn’t seem to be putting in effort at window dressing. He is not dancing when somebody says “dance.” I liked his Day 1 point about HB, and I liked when he validated me validating him. I like that he’s been skeptical of me.

I think he’s town, damn it.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I also am not sure I’ve really tried hard to grok any of HR’s stuff on Flum. And I feel like HR, if Town, plays more to tell us all in the GOD thread how right he was than to help is all get to the right answer.

If someone has a persuasive case on Flum, come tell me. I’m sorry I haven’t scrutinized every page of this thread. If I’m honest, I have to admit I probably won’t have time to do that. So, here I am, tell me why I’m wrong about Flum.

[ghug]

I also am not sure I’ve really tried hard to grok any of HR’s stuff on Flum. And I feel like HR, if Town, plays more to tell us all in the GOD thread how right he was than to help is all get to the right answer.

If someone has a persuasive case on Flum, come tell me. I’m sorry I haven’t scrutinized every page of this thread. If I’m honest, I have to admit I probably won’t have time to do that. So, here I am, tell me why I’m wrong about Flum.

Can you give me your seven strongest reads on people, scum or town? Feel free to overachieve.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I also am not sure I’ve really tried hard to grok any of HR’s stuff on Flum. And I feel like HR, if Town, plays more to tell us all in the GOD thread how right he was than to help is all get to the right answer.

If someone has a persuasive case on Flum, come tell me. I’m sorry I haven’t scrutinized every page of this thread. If I’m honest, I have to admit I probably won’t have time to do that. So, here I am, tell me why I’m wrong about Flum.

Can you give me your seven strongest reads on people, scum or town? Feel free to overachieve.

Seven?

I think I’m looking for two scum in a pool of 11. So, you’re asking me to solve the game.

I believe I’ll have some time to read tomorrow, so expect more clear thoughts then.

Right now? I think ghug and Flum are town. Kgray likely town. Damo likely town.

HR is town of he’s Priest. Scum if he’s not.

New guys I just haven’t focused on at all.

Bozo — not sure. Maniac...? I guess probably town.

Hmmmm so maybe Chaqa is scum. (Checks Chaqa’s Day 1 vote). Damn.

Maybe aarodactyl is scum. Has he done anything townie?

[ghug]

I also am not sure I’ve really tried hard to grok any of HR’s stuff on Flum. And I feel like HR, if Town, plays more to tell us all in the GOD thread how right he was than to help is all get to the right answer.

If someone has a persuasive case on Flum, come tell me. I’m sorry I haven’t scrutinized every page of this thread. If I’m honest, I have to admit I probably won’t have time to do that. So, here I am, tell me why I’m wrong about Flum.

Can you give me your seven strongest reads on people, scum or town? Feel free to overachieve.

Seven?

I think I’m looking for two scum in a pool of 11. So, you’re asking me to solve the game.

I believe I’ll have some time to read tomorrow, so expect more clear thoughts then.

Right now? I think ghug and Flum are town. Kgray likely town. Damo likely town.

HR is town of he’s Priest. Scum if he’s not.

New guys I just haven’t focused on at all.

Bozo — not sure. Maniac...? I guess probably town.

Hmmmm so maybe Chaqa is scum. (Checks Chaqa’s Day 1 vote). Damn.

Maybe aarodactyl is scum. Has he done anything townie?

Why is damo likely town?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Can you give me your seven strongest reads on people, scum or town? Feel free to overachieve.

Seven?

I think I’m looking for two scum in a pool of 11. So, you’re asking me to solve the game.

I believe I’ll have some time to read tomorrow, so expect more clear thoughts then.

Right now? I think ghug and Flum are town. Kgray likely town. Damo likely town.

HR is town of he’s Priest. Scum if he’s not.

New guys I just haven’t focused on at all.

Bozo — not sure. Maniac...? I guess probably town.

Hmmmm so maybe Chaqa is scum. (Checks Chaqa’s Day 1 vote). Damn.

Maybe aarodactyl is scum. Has he done anything townie?

Why is damo likely town?

I found the math thing, and the stubbornness about the math thing to be towny. I found his town read of HB without much attempt to make it look well supported to be towny. I found his failure to vote for brain Day 2 to save his town-read HB to be towny.

Very generally: I don’t see Damo making an effort to please anyone or to try to demonstrate consistency.

[aarodactyl]

I also am not sure I’ve really tried hard to grok any of HR’s stuff on Flum. And I feel like HR, if Town, plays more to tell us all in the GOD thread how right he was than to help is all get to the right answer.

If someone has a persuasive case on Flum, come tell me. I’m sorry I haven’t scrutinized every page of this thread. If I’m honest, I have to admit I probably won’t have time to do that. So, here I am, tell me why I’m wrong about Flum.

Can you give me your seven strongest reads on people, scum or town? Feel free to overachieve.

Seven?

I think I’m looking for two scum in a pool of 11. So, you’re asking me to solve the game.

I believe I’ll have some time to read tomorrow, so expect more clear thoughts then.

Right now? I think ghug and Flum are town. Kgray likely town. Damo likely town.

HR is town of he’s Priest. Scum if he’s not.

New guys I just haven’t focused on at all.

Bozo — not sure. Maniac...? I guess probably town.

Hmmmm so maybe Chaqa is scum. (Checks Chaqa’s Day 1 vote). Damn.

Maybe aarodactyl is scum. Has he done anything townie?

I'm new as well btw.

[celaph]

This doesn't mean I townread HB. I'd need to reread his stuff first.

Not sure if this is a typo, but taking it at face value. I strongly believe that HB is town. I trust PE and am willing to sheep his D3 read.

[celaph]

Flum scumread damo d1, asked HB twice about his damo townread, says he would scumread damo but he trusts HR too much during d2. Wack, but not justification for a vote on its own.

He scumreads HB d2 after he does the earlier sheep. He then says he's been obvtowning him since d1, which is a flat out *lie*. This man is scummier than a sewage pipe. He switches between nullreads, scumreads, or mistrustfulness, and total townreads.

This doesn't mean I townread HB. I'd need to reread his stuff first.

Also, at least on my end, the urls are broken so I'm not sure which posts you're referring to.

[Maniac]

I’ve been trying to think how scum would think about having yoyo on their team. Obviously they wouldn’t be happy that he got modkilled and very unhappy he rolled communicator and presumably didn’t communicate in their QT thread much.

However yoyo is a born deep threat as his meta is to lurk and often lurkers get a pass until late game. Would that affect how other scum members approached the game knowing they already had a deep threat? Idk

When it became likely that yoyo would be modkilled would that affect how other scum members read him? Would they want to scum read him for some cred when he flipped. Or if they thought town would lose patience with yoyo and day-kill him, would they have listed him as scum in preparation for bussing him? Maybe.

I had six people scum reading yoyo. Chaqa, Damo, bozo, aaredactyl, vecna and celaph. Aarodactyl has corrected me and is off my list and vecna has flipped town. So that leaves four. I think we have at least one scum in this group.

I have a bad feeling about Chaqa. He isn’t active and hasn’t done anything to solve the puzzle as far as I recall. He may also have been trying to pocket me. So I’ll happily ##vote Chaqa

[celaph]

What's your opinion on ghug? Are you not at all concerned about ghug pocketing you?