webdiplomacy.net

Nephthys wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 5:01 am

@Kalel, who do you think should be stoned?

For my money first choice is Kit.. we've both been accused of SK, since I know I'm not then this would clear up that puzzle for me. It would also add information to the puzzle of the early game banishment. Something I still don't understand.
If the rest of town has this figured out and can explain it to me without giving scum intel on our thought process then I'll take it and pass my recommendation on to number 2.

Or Sulit... I know the team has strong scum on this one, but two of the traits I'm tracking which is low posts vs. quality posts is not fully convincing. It was one of the reasons I was behind the yuuki vote (not on the wagon but supportive), and we know where that went. I should probably be overruled on a better stoning to solve some outstanding puzzles, but I'm of the mind that it would be fantastic to be 100% sure of the next lynch. As the number get closer together being 100% would be great.

KalelChase wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 4:07 pm

rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 11:40 am

damo666 wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 10:35 am

At least 1 person offering themselves up for stoning is bluffing.

And offering in a contrived way like Kalel ("fine, but it will be a waste") means what?

Meaning it would be a waste for me. I clearly already know my identity, and thus I assert it would be a waste for the team. Ultimately, I don't think I'm a big piece in this puzzle, but if

It seems the only down side to having your ID cleared is that scum will know you're not SK, and you're likely the next to go... and thanks to good advice from others I no longer care about staying in, just the team winning (there's actually something to be said about learning more by seeing the endgame in the god thread (if I've got that terminology right)).

Sorry --- continuing from IF above...

If revealing my ID would solve a puzzle for the rest of town I'm all for it.

Stone Sulit. Them in the endgame is a disaster for having nothing to analyze.

Foxcastle wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 5:31 pm

Stone Sulit. Them in the endgame is a disaster for having nothing to analyze.

Agreed

I’m pretty sure Sulit is scum. We should stone Food or Fox or Kit.

Chaqa wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 6:06 pm

I’m pretty sure Sulit is scum. We should stone Food or Fox or Kit.

You being pretty sure does not solve the problem of if Sulit makes it to the end game.

And I would stone me later, as I have a roleblock claim that is at least something that can be evaluated and judged. We should stone someone who is a bigger question with less to go on.

Kitsune is a fine second choice to Sulit.

Foxcastle: Now you know that it was Maniac who roleblocked you (if your RB claim is true). With that information now available, can you reflect on why Maniac chose you for the roleblock?

Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 6:38 pm

Foxcastle: Now you know that it was Maniac who roleblocked you (if your RB claim is true). With that information now available, can you reflect on why Maniac chose you for the roleblock?

On mobile, so gonna be brief.

I speculated earlier that the scum team could include a player who I have played with a good bit before noticed I was not playing my usual style. My guess is still that they thought it could point to me being a PR and that’s why I was picked to be RB’d. I don’t think maniac has played enough to fit that description though.

We should lynch someone first, I think we are too focused on the stone now.
I have to re-read Maniac, but his doc claim isn't a mistake, he did it at night.
It pointed a not really experienced scumteam or an overly confident one.

Foxcastle wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 6:30 pm

Chaqa wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 6:06 pm

I’m pretty sure Sulit is scum. We should stone Food or Fox or Kit.

You being pretty sure does not solve the problem of if Sulit makes it to the end game.

And I would stone me later, as I have a roleblock claim that is at least something that can be evaluated and judged. We should stone someone who is a bigger question with less to go on.

Kitsune is a fine second choice to Sulit.

Stone away Foxpants. I’ll save you the trouble.

The stone isn't active until the next night phase, right? So we have another lynch yet before it's a real concrn.

Chaqa wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 7:50 pm

The stone isn't active until the next night phase, right? So we have another lynch yet before it's a real concrn.

Agreed with both Chaqa and RDR to focus on lynching. Hanging on until the top of the hour with bated breath.

Chaqa wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 7:50 pm

The stone isn't active until the next night phase, right? So we have another lynch yet before it's a real concrn.

Not D6?

=================================================================================

The remaining villains gathered together, The Collector hands the Power Stone to……. the Hulk? Red Skull hands the Space Stone to the Hulk as well????? What was happening? Suddenly the “Hulk” opens a portal using the Space Stone and the body of the real Hulk slumps out. The Hulk walks over to Gamora, produces a knife and stabs her. DAMO HAS DIED, HE WAS GAMORA, A VANILLA TOWN.

Loki calmly collects the Soul Stone

Captain America: “No, it can’t be”

Hulk changes shape to reveal himself as Loki.

Loki: “Surprise, the real hulk has been gone a long time”

Starlord: Guys, we gotta get those stones!!”

Red Skull: “It’s too late, we’ve guided ourselves to too many stones, its over”

Captain America: “No, it’s not”

He reaches for the Mind Stone, it’s not in his pocket. He looks around rapidly, then see The Collector looking at him and smiling. In his hand, the yellow infinity stone.

Captain America: “NOOOOOO” he runs for Loki

Loki poofs out from in front of him in a blue haze.

Loki: “Not today Cap”

The Collector hands the Mind Stone to Loki. Loki teleports in front of Thanos, and places the stone in his hand. It lights up in a beautiful orange hue. He takes the gauntlet off the Titans hand and places it on his own.

Loki: “Thank you Titan”

Loki uses the Reality Stone to turn the Titan to solid stone. The Mind Stone flashes, and Black Panther walks over to Loki and hands him the Time Stone.
Loki, flanked by Red Skull and The Collector, places the stones one by one in the gauntlet. He raises his gauntleted left hand, and…………. *Snap*


THE AVENGERS HAVE BEEN SNAPPED OUT OF EXISTANCE AND HAVE FAILED TO SAVE THE UNIVERSE

THE GAME HAS ENDED. THE MAFIA HAVE WON!!

KITSUNE (RED SKULL) SULIT (THE COLLECTOR) AND ESPRESSO PATRONUM (LOKI) HAVE SURVIVED
=====================================================================================

Good game :3

And a wonderful writeup by Ike.

+100

I don't understand

Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Sun Sep 29, 2019 8:02 pm

I don't understand

Scum got all the stones

Shit. When did they take the Mind Stone from me? I wasn't alerted.

Who was Thanos?

Scum got enough stones that they could tie the lynch, they consolidated the stones they had on the power stone holder, so they would have 6 votes, only 7 non-mafia left, they use the space stone to teleport a town out, it's 6-6, town can't lynch anymore.

1. Where does the setup say that Mafia autowin if they have the stones? Isn't that the SKs win condition?

2. Who was the SK? Did they die at the end?