Re: Mafia 42 - Space Ghost Coast to Coast - OFFICIAL GAME THREAD
Posted: Thu Feb 14, 2019 9:02 pm
i expect peter to get votes ASAP
https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/
https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=1260
already on it cuddy
We can't scumread him for lurking, that's acceptable but I can't townread him either without enough material. Also I'm writing on phone atm, I don't understand why people can't use phone.Anyways I'm on mobile til Friday night, will do what I can
I agree with this scum pool and believe there must be a scum in this list. If I'm right you're more clear, anyway I got good vibes from him.Scummy pool: RHK/ezio/Neph/peterlund/
What teh heck is this points system? Have you used this before?yavuzovic wrote: ↑Thu Feb 14, 2019 9:44 pm5 = towniest; -5 = scummiest
I just discovered bozotheclown is playing
Bozo: -2, he isn't playing, has a push on Xorxes - which makes me think they aren't aligned in same faction. However he made many posts before I came. I will take another look at him if I have time.
damo: -1, another low poster and unlike bozo he was posting some short sentences before that too.
DemonRHK: -2, very talkative and spamming the thread as a scum strategy :WP I would vote for him if it wasn't possible him to be a town avoiding the game.
DT: -1, I don't understand why he accused emc for poor reaction to Tom's death. (He can't be both scum and Vengeful Townie at the same time though. He must be marked )
e=m.c^2: 3, I like the way he posts. Active. @emc, were you from MU or is this your first game or did you play before me or do you have experience at mafia?
Ezio: -2, voted for me when I came first, I thought it could be something about CF but he didn't make a case on anything and lurked after that.
Dargorygel: 5, he killed 2 men, what does scum do? They kill man. This logic brings us to the conclusion, he is scum.
ghug: -1, he makes good posts, but this adjective is only valid when we talk about it's amount. Look at his posts, I don't see a real thing he said in D4 and 1 -2 good posts but not many in N&D3. However there's nothing I can use against him. Scummy null.
LQ: 2, I have gut feelings saying he is town, since we don't have evidence against this I will mark him
MoscowFleet (I don't like using this abbreviation): -2, nothing today, and only reviewing the last two posts at night. I got some scum impression from him. Don't really know why.
Neph: 0,We can't scumread him for lurking, that's acceptable but I can't townread him either without enough material. Also I'm writing on phone atm, I don't understand why people can't use phone.Anyways I'm on mobile til Friday night, will do what I can
Peterlund: -2, playing like busy, I hope he really is.. His last vote really makes uneasy.
Ike: 1, gut says townie, I read many posts but I don't really find anything to write here. He makes some good posts too but they're lost in other posts. Maybe I give too much point but since we don't have counter evidence...
rdrivera: 2, good and logical posts. Feels town. I don't really have a case but he is apparently not scummy.
Vaporwave: 2,I agree with this scum pool and believe there must be a scum in this list. If I'm right you're more clear, anyway I got good vibes from him.Scummy pool: RHK/ezio/Neph/peterlund/
Vecna: 0, not really scumreading him, but as I understand he didn't want decperado to shoot BB and Jamie - we all townread some scum at some point so this isn't really scum indicative but this is something suspect to do.
Xorxes: -1, I voted for him because he felt fake for a moment but I don't really remember what made me think that. But I know there was something in my mind when I voted. I actually asked why were we scumreading him bit people didn't reply or I don't remember. ##unvote until I decide who to vote.
You can add 5 for positive results, didn't you like it?RagingIke297 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 14, 2019 9:49 pmWhat teh heck is this points system? Have you used this before?
Hmm... maybe ghug is being coached then.LordQuas wrote: ↑Thu Feb 14, 2019 6:26 pmI find that most times people say this it ends up not being very truerdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 14, 2019 6:18 pmDon't try to apply standard logic to Yav, it won't work. Just saying...
people discredited ghug the same way but I think he's been playing aight this game, people discredit brainbomb the same way but very often that's not the case
/shrug
Good answer. I liked yavu's reads being based on independent thinking even if I disagree with many of them.
Would it tell you something if it was the first time he used it? Is it really so hard to understand what the points mean?RagingIke297 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 14, 2019 9:49 pm
What teh heck is this points system? Have you used this before?
I think you misunderstood what happened there. He didn't want desperado to shoot them because he wanted desperado to remain hidden, not because he thought that they were town.
Do you have any questions for me dargo, or is your decision final?
How much of the game have you actually read Yavuz? How are you typing up such big walls from your phone?yavuzovic wrote: ↑Thu Feb 14, 2019 9:44 pm5 = towniest; -5 = scummiest
I just discovered bozotheclown is playing
Bozo: -2, he isn't playing, has a push on Xorxes - which makes me think they aren't aligned in same faction. However he made many posts before I came. I will take another look at him if I have time.
damo: -1, another low poster and unlike bozo he was posting some short sentences before that too.
DemonRHK: -2, very talkative and spamming the thread as a scum strategy :WP I would vote for him if it wasn't possible him to be a town avoiding the game.
DT: -1, I don't understand why he accused emc for poor reaction to Tom's death. (He can't be both scum and Vengeful Townie at the same time though. He must be marked )
e=m.c^2: 3, I like the way he posts. Active. @emc, were you from MU or is this your first game or did you play before me or do you have experience at mafia?
Ezio: -2, voted for me when I came first, I thought it could be something about CF but he didn't make a case on anything and lurked after that.
Dargorygel: 5, he killed 2 men, what does scum do? They kill man. This logic brings us to the conclusion, he is scum.
ghug: -1, he makes good posts, but this adjective is only valid when we talk about it's amount. Look at his posts, I don't see a real thing he said in D4 and 1 -2 good posts but not many in N&D3. However there's nothing I can use against him. Scummy null.
LQ: 2, I have gut feelings saying he is town, since we don't have evidence against this I will mark him
MoscowFleet (I don't like using this abbreviation): -2, nothing today, and only reviewing the last two posts at night. I got some scum impression from him. Don't really know why.
Neph: 0,We can't scumread him for lurking, that's acceptable but I can't townread him either without enough material. Also I'm writing on phone atm, I don't understand why people can't use phone.Anyways I'm on mobile til Friday night, will do what I can
Peterlund: -2, playing like busy, I hope he really is.. His last vote really makes uneasy.
Ike: 1, gut says townie, I read many posts but I don't really find anything to write here. He makes some good posts too but they're lost in other posts. Maybe I give too much point but since we don't have counter evidence...
rdrivera: 2, good and logical posts. Feels town. I don't really have a case but he is apparently not scummy.
Vaporwave: 2,I agree with this scum pool and believe there must be a scum in this list. If I'm right you're more clear, anyway I got good vibes from him.Scummy pool: RHK/ezio/Neph/peterlund/
Vecna: 0, not really scumreading him, but as I understand he didn't want decperado to shoot BB and Jamie - we all townread some scum at some point so this isn't really scum indicative but this is something suspect to do.
Xorxes: -1, I voted for him because he felt fake for a moment but I don't really remember what made me think that. But I know there was something in my mind when I voted. I actually asked why were we scumreading him bit people didn't reply or I don't remember. ##unvote until I decide who to vote.
You really think CFox's spamming was scum motivated or is it just POE? Or is your read based on yavu's actions?