Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[bo_sox48]

The fact that none of this has come out at all prior to today is still getting to me, as if mafia was like “we can’t afford to kill him because we have to hunt down PRs and we don’t think bo is a PR, so let’s make sure we come after him today.”

What did you mean by this?

I mean that mafia wants me dead, thamrick, but they can't take up a night on me because they don't think I'm the cop. You're not mafia and I already know that, but you're also the only one that's actually been deluded into thinking before today that I'm mafia. Nobody else has. Why do you think is there all of a sudden attention being cast my way when the case that you built has existed for quite some time? It's all too easy.

[Tom Bombadil]

@ Balki - why did you give up on lynching Mean?

[bo_sox48]

I did reread him, he is one of my strongest townreads. I'm quite baffled how you ended up there as I consider you a pretty strong town player.

You put in a valiant effort, Tom, but you're just dead wrong on him.

[DemonRHK]

Oh god damn it

GET ON RD

[thamrick]

I can buy rdrivera bussing Jamiet D1. I can't buy him bussing RJ D2 as the Witch. That's scum's most powerful role imo. You don't risk giving that up by bringing him 1 short of vote lead with 6 mins to go.

[thamrick]

Oh god damn it

GET ON RD

This seems a bit of an overreaction with 20 mins still to go. Protecting Bo?

[Foxcastle]

Balki quotes:

"It also occurs to me, if Yavuz is indeed the Cop, there is a True Watcher around who knows that Yavuz is telling the truth and DemonRHK is lying. If we are about to lynch Yavuz, and Yavuz is in fact the real Cop, that would obviously be worth having the Real Watcher surface and say "DON'T LYNCH COP, LYNCH DEMONRHK!" Right?"

"If we get close to lynching DemonRHK, and we're wrong, there should be a Real Cop undercover who could come forward and say "STOP, DON'T LYNCH REAL WATCHER!""

Also, "WATCHER​: If we are about to lynch Yavuz, and you exist, and you know DemonRHK is fake claiming, obviously come forward to save cop. In that case, we'll still have Nurse, Watcher, and Cop going into the night, and we're probably better off having you guys in plain sight so that you can protect each other and Yavuz can keep getting scans off. There will only be 2 scum left in any event, and one of them is probably ND."

"I feel like we are almost in auto-win territory here."

"Real Cop, you should consider whether you have enough scan results to make this auto now. Think about how many PRs we have, how many scans you have, and how many people are left in the non-clear group. Basically, Town has to kill everyone in the non-clear group before Mafia kills all our clears. If we can definitely do that, we're in auto-win territory."

This all seems misguided.

[rdrivera2005]

Rdrivera is a fantastic lynch, Tom. I had planned on going through and rereading him to put together a case today, but as you can see, I haven't had time for this game. Even today, my day off, is being taken up by, yup, work. You should just trust me that rdrivera is the right lynch for today, do some rereading yourself, and cast a vote for him.

Making a case in the last 30 minutes is shitty even for you bo. I don't think you are a good lynch but if I ended lynched today you will regret as you will give more reasons for people go after you tomorrow.

[bo_sox48]

I can buy rdrivera bussing Jamiet D1. I can't buy him bussing RJ D2 as the Witch. That's scum's most powerful role imo. You don't risk giving that up by bringing him 1 short of vote lead with 6 mins to go.

Are you forgetting the godfather and the hooker?

[DemonRHK]

Oh god damn it

GET ON RD

This seems a bit of an overreaction with 20 mins still to go. Protecting Bo?

If my gut's right we're about to have a shitstorm, and I've been on rd for a while, so I'm more likely to side with bo on this.

[MeanLaQueefa]

I have skimmed the thread, there were a few questions for me I won't have time to get to until later tonight. I am leaning town on bo, but I could see him being a smart scum, but not enough to vote for him. I also think rdr is definitely town. So I'm staying on balki, hope you all see the light that he is scum. Be here for a few minutes for quick questions if you have them

[Tom Bombadil]

##vote Balki

I don't believe you bo, but I'm willing to wait it out. I can't imagine a world where rd is scum here. Maybe the miller based on your implications.

[bo_sox48]

Hell, the witch isn't even effective unless the mafia correctly predicts who gets visited. The mafia had no idea what kind of intel they were going to have come D3 back then, and Rj was a ticking time bomb for them.

[Tom Bombadil]

So why did rd lynch Jamie D1 with no reason - rd isn't as arrogant as some players here and try to do that for the glory of singlehandedly going deep for scum team. He just wouldn't do that.

[thamrick]

I mean that mafia wants me dead, thamrick, but they can't take up a night on me because they don't think I'm the cop. You're not mafia and I already know that, but you're also the only one that's actually been deluded into thinking before today that I'm mafia. Nobody else has. Why do you think is there all of a sudden attention being cast my way when the case that you built has existed for quite some time? It's all too easy.

That's not true. Brain called you scum. Balki called you scum. Rj called you scum but conveniently left you off his reads and never voted you.

And by "attention cast your way" do you mean me (the person you know isn't mafia somehow), Tom (our townclear), and Balki (who called you scum in his EoN post and who you don't want to vote)?

To be fair, I don't know why reedeer is on you.

[rdrivera2005]

I have to leave. If I am lynched, look who voted me last minute and if bo is still the other wagon, look at people who sited on the sidelines.

[Foxcastle]

Tham: Rjm left several people off his reads, including Mean.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 4.4

bo_sox48 (3): thamrick, reedeer1, Balki Bartokomous
Balki Bartokomous (3): MeanLaQueefa, Foxcastle, Tom Bombadil
MeanLaQueefa (2): rdrivera2005 Bozotheclown
rdrivera2005 (2): DemonRHK, Bo_Sox
thamrick (1): VashtaNeurotic
Yoyoyozo (1): Maniac

Currently NOBODY is set to be lynched.

Yoyoyozo still needs to vote.

You have 15 Minutes remaining.

[Yoyoyozo]

I didn't know we were so close to the deadline :/

I'm no where near finished here, so I'll just set my vote to
##VOTE no lynch
(if this is still a thing)

[DemonRHK]

I have to leave. If I am lynched, look who voted me last minute and if bo is still the other wagon, look at people who sited on the sidelines.

Now I'm sure. RD is scum.