webdiplomacy.net

well seeing as kaks probably gone for the day, ill lock in my read now
kak is cool, we are not killing kak today

further thoughts on snowy
snowys posts feel really empty for the most part
there doesnt seem to be much other than questions, and even the questions dont seem to be doing much digging
that said, i think its entirely possible snowy is just town having an off day
or maybe snowy is just bad at questioning, i havent played with them much
but until further notice, im happy to leave my vote here

Here is a survey/challenge for everyone: see how good your initial reads are by ranking all 17 players from town to scum. It is only 12 hours into the game, but I think this will be tougher for the mafia than the town.

Here is my list:

1. bozo
2. Kakarroto
3. BobMcBob
4. cel​aph
5. Bonatogether
6. Vecna
7. ghug
8. HB
9. lfischl
10. damo
11. rdrivera
12. Macca
13. snowy
​14. Maniac
15. Jamie
16. foodcoats
17. worcej

I pronounce worcej as war sedge

Bona is not town

##vote Bona

bozotheclown wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 11:04 am

Here is a survey/challenge for everyone: see how good your initial reads are by ranking all 17 players from town to scum. It is only 12 hours into the game, but I think this will be tougher for the mafia than the town.

Here is my list:

1. bozo
2. Kakarroto
3. BobMcBob
4. cel​aph
5. Bonatogether
6. Vecna
7. ghug
8. HB
9. lfischl
10. damo
11. rdrivera
12. Macca
13. snowy
​14. Maniac
15. Jamie
16. foodcoats
17. worcej

So I'm weal town without having posted. Sensible I suppose.

*weak

bozotheclown wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 11:04 am

Here is a survey/challenge for everyone: see how good your initial reads are by ranking all 17 players from town to scum. It is only 12 hours into the game, but I think this will be tougher for the mafia than the town.

Here is my list:

1. bozo
2. Kakarroto
3. BobMcBob
4. cel​aph
5. Bonatogether
6. Vecna
7. ghug
8. HB
9. lfischl
10. damo
11. rdrivera
12. Macca
13. snowy
​14. Maniac
15. Jamie
16. foodcoats
17. worcej

So Worcej is your top scum read, Snowy is only a week scumread by comparison, yet your vote is on Snowy.

I think your list is fake.

bozotheclown wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 7:52 am

foodcoats wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 1:45 am

Actually I’ll sheep snowy instead

##VOTE Vecna

Baah baah

Why snowy? It looks like you are trying to pocket him.

Bona and snowy are two on people that I’ve aggressively miskilled as town.

Also I think they both have good reads in general.

Also I didn’t want to inflate the ghug wagon so sheeped my other shepherd.

Vecna wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 8:28 am

BobMcBob wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 5:11 am

list of fully legit reads, this has never gotten me daykilled before
kakarroto is cool, can we keep him
bona is cool, and also has a decent chance of not being town, but still cool
snowy is not cool, don't like snowy
jamie is cool, in temper at least
bozo seems... like bozo
vecna will shortly proceed to be mad at me because this post is uncool
foodcoats is slightly cool
macca i need a little bit more time on, and more content from, seems very normal so far

I actually like such posts. I like your Bona take (because youre one of the few others that thinks that besides me).

I dont know why you think foodcoats is slightly cool though. Him sheeping the snowy vote on me seemed all kinds of weird. And he didnt do any real posting?

Thank you Vecna for obliquely pointing out that bob is scum for saying I am anything less than the King of Cool.

BobMcBob wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 9:21 am

oh yeah ill probably be asleep for eods unless i decide to radically flip my sleep schedule to get up earlier
which... would have other benefits tbh
ill consider it

Similar case here, but I'm not getting up.

celaph wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 10:06 am

Macca573 wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 1:58 am

Macca573 wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 1:57 am

Alrighty, Mafia time!

Firstly,
The last of my assessments are due this week, so expect lower activity, but it should go up.

Secondly,

oops... continue

That bozo-snowy interaction, very sus (not for bozo). ##vote snowy


I actually like bozo's idea, but I'll wait for a little more support before I participate.

Can you call out specific snowy posts that you dislike?

I feel like snowy's questioning of Bozo's focus on 3p was some of his better work so far.

I have a particular reason for the snowy read, it's not just one of my vibe reads. I believe that he scumslipped in those posts with bozo, but you're welcome to disagree.

damo666 wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 11:22 am

I pronounce worcej as war sedge

Weird.

I say “worse jay”

War Sedge sounds like a regimental order of battle in a fantasy book.

“He leads ten war sedges. How can he not be an honourable man?”

“You bastard!”

BobMcBob wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 4:16 am

well im all caught up
i dont like snowy
too many questions
not enough good stuff
i have had a 100% success rate catching mafia with this in my last 2 games
##vote snowy

Really just getting up and around here.

So Bob, until I read further, I think I have to disagree. I've been wrong about Snowy in the two (I think) games we've played together. I think the questioning is part of their profile. Their questions tend to dig in and encourage some "laying it out." Now I'll need to go back and reread their posts. I don't see "too many questions" as scum-indicative. What would be scum-indicative would be the disrupting and fluffy questions that divert town from linear solving.

Not to take anything away from your success rate.

I do see Snowy in the lead so obviously there are others that are agreeing with you. Must read more.

##VOTE Maniac

Seems like +EV

I need to sleep. But I'll make sure to do your thing Bozo in the morning.

Vecna wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 8:33 am

I keep being surprised by Hamilton Brian's Up/Down in playstyle. The variance in his play as town the last bunch of games has made it really hard to read him.

Here once again it feels like he starts on very low energy (complete 180 again from last game), but he does throw out a bunch of easy townreads. Does he do that because he feels its expected of him?

Yeah, that's my fault. I think it has to do with the quality of living I'm in currently. More stressors around than the last few times I've played. Hence the low energy. I thought me adding a joke for my first post would be a nice change but no one laughed. Sad clown.

Macca573 wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 03, 2021 12:44 pm

I have a particular reason for the snowy read, it's not just one of my vibe reads. I believe that he scumslipped in those posts with bozo, but you're welcome to disagree.

Are you asserting that you think bozo is scum with snowy? Just trying to clarify.

Fast reread of snowy but I am not seeing anything necessarily off in the questions. To me it reads as the Snowy I’ve seen.

What might be interesting would be the interactions with Bona which had some contention. Might be something to keep an eye on going forward. Mafia/ Ecoli doing some distancing? Again, not sticking to this hard and fast. Just something for under the hat.

ooh, a ranking list gambit?
sign me up!

1. bob
2. kak
3. macca
4. celaph
5. bozo
6. vecna
7. hb
8. worcej
9. damo
10. jamie
11. ghug
12. maniac
13. food
14. lfischl
15. maniac
16. bona
17. snowy

its something like that at least