Re: Mafia 47 - The Sixth Mass Extinction - GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]
Posted: Sun Jul 21, 2019 3:41 am
Before I get carpal tunnel, good night.
https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/
https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=1784
I agree with all of this about Percy. I am definitely more concerned about the masons (maybe that has sorted out already?) and adding them to our clears makes 4 cleared town and narrows down the pool of scum, which definitely would help.xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 8:30 pmIf Percy's claim is true, lynching him would be doing a huge service to Mafia. Agree?Foxcastle wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 8:20 pmI don't know why you're giving so much deference to claims, Xorxes. Nearly everyone's going to have claims, and scum assuredly do (because they can choose from a list whatever is most convenient). This is not a usual game where patience is a virtue when it comes to fake claims.
The mason claims are different though, because there are two of them and they have to be done in coordination. If Hosuke is scum and fake claiming, then that is actually much more likely to be clarified with patience than Percy's claim, which can't be CC'd and is open to the possibility that he could fake results (if we get that far into game).
If Percy's claim is false, tomorrow he will look even more suspect than today. Agree?
Given those two, what could possibly be the argument for lynching him today instead of tomorrow? There's no other scum candidate at all that would be less risky to lynch?
(Same thing applies to damo.)
Aside from all that, there's good reason to think Percy is town and his claim is true from the way he discussed massclaims with bozo way before he was under threat of being shot or lynched.
Nah, I am just doing my best imitation of a Vecna Wall of Posts as I get caught up from today.
+8damo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 10:23 pmWhy is everybody so protective of Masons? They're only glorified VTs.
Isn't it worth getting 2 town clears with a reveal and demonstration of contact?
Until such demo forthcoming ##Vote ItsHosuke.
You all really should listen to Xorxes. He makes perfect sense.
God damn you seem to move all over on your reads. It's hard to even keep straight thinking about how you must be thinking.Vaporwave wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 10:39 pmI've mentioned previously
bozo/damo and worcej/xorxes ships
so in bozo and damo, I'm pocketed by damo but I can sense something evil's about to happen, damo is way too townie for his own good imo, maybe he wants to impress his team, I'm leaning town otherwise I would tinfoil every 5 sec
bozo is town imo but again I sense an evil shadow, I have him as town in his category because he makes me twist and turn if I try to analyse more of his content
worcej/xorxes
I've stated that if there's a scumboy, it's xorxes. Well, I've changed my mind given recent posts by xorxes
it's worcej as scum...IF...yes a big If
Seriously, you post this and then say there is a scum between me and xorxes?Vaporwave wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 10:35 pmbozo - leaning townish
bo_sox scum potential alert
bomb - town ginger
chaqa - too buy but scum alert
damo - town
dargo - not present so scum alert
e.m.c - reserved scum alert
espresso - pocketed me beyond repair, don't ask
flash - could be
foodcoats - I think he got better, he pulled through
Foxy - conflicted, I guess he's town
Hosuke - mason, to be solved
Jamiet - always scum potential
Percy - town
rivera - town
worcej - town
xorxes - town
I haven't seen anything yet from him either and he did post. I imagine he still isn't cleared, so here we go: ##VOTE ItsHosukexorxes wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 10:40 pmBeing in different timezones does not prevent them from being online at some agreed time together, which may be morning for one and late evening for the other, for example.Percy Williams wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 10:32 pmOh, I thought we were just posting random things. The post at the same time strategy to find our masons is inherently flawed, as Itshosuke has made it clear that he and his partner are in different time zones.
I'm going to ##VOTE ItsHosuke for now because there's something fishy going on when the two people with claimed powers that can threaten Mafia are the two leading wagons and there may be a powerthief on the loose.
I myself know I cannot read bo because I scummed him HARD last game I played with him and he ended up being town.
Comments:brainbomb wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 11:37 pmMy biggest issue with this game right now is two-fold.
●Firstly theres 2 camps here. A ton of very derpy, kinda scummy middling town who dont seem very reliable. And I mean no disrespect but Percy, darg, chaqa, emc, hosuke, and vapor all seem totally pointless. None of their reads seem confident. they just look like easy lynchbait
●Then we have the hornets nest. The hornets are players like bo who should be stinging lots and lots. But instead of bo being aggressive, bo is just barely existant. And whats worse is, damo and xorxes have become hornets. But they arent stinging anyone. All damo and xorx are really doing is buzzing around this nest theyve created and firing back out at Camp 1. The middlers. The hornets are foxcastle, xorx, damo, who have all just felt combative but devoid of any actual rational arguments why anyone is scum. Its especially bad with xorxes. Damo looks wolfy in his every move and action.
the middling players seem to be very amatuer at applying reasoning, at hunting. and exuding skills of mafia.
Espresso is definetely trying. And of all the mid level townies I think hes probably least likely to be scum
My reads are like this
Scum
bo
dargo
chaqa
xorxes
damo
bozo
foxcastle
damo
vapor
null
hosuke
Town
Jamie
worcej
espresso
Clears
Rivera
Me
I dont think we can win this game presently.
In fact unless some very very serious effort comes from the middling and low town. We wont lynch a single scum this game.
Percy is possibly scum but his wagon grew way too easy. his defenses of himself as terrible
the timing on his claim was bad
the claim only makes sense as scum if hes a roleblocker or something decent.
as town its just bad. He probably had no reason to claim there as any align.
EMC is possibly scum but if not then xorx and fox need to die today. He seems okay in posts but hes really unhelpful and likely will get lynched no matter what.
Bozo looks definetely like scum. hes certainly been hard defended and saved on pretty.poor reasoning day 1.
vapor looks like a wishy washy celine dion song this game. unsure who he wants to white knight. what topic he wants to ramble about and then reverse position on anyway.
chaqa only pops in and relies on campy jokes and reminders his life is going well or his moms getting eyeglasses. hes basically telling his daily routine more than his reads.
Bo is just never like this. he probably bussed foodcoats and darg. unless darg and foidcoats are both town. which pretty much means we have no chance if true.
foodcoats posts are pretty ok. But his thread presence is beyond scummy. He ciasted day 1 and vote shifted late with no explanation. hes been dodgy, creepy,and inefficient.
I don't think you're looking hard enough if you cannot find something scummy from some of the current players...
Fuck this. ##vote VaporVaporwave wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2019 11:52 pmI'm also scared with xorxes, the tinfoil can start any second
I wanted for xorxes to grab the bull's horn and lead town into a concrete direction.
No town leader whatsoever
bomb, pull up your g-string, put sun lotion on your skin and let's ride the waves for success
you are the voice, just call it outright, if you want a bozosox wagon
chaqa bussing emc til last second and trying to get bozo instead in final tally