webdiplomacy.net

The tradition continues...

##VOTE Brainbomb

I think it's a bad idea for cannon shots to be rushed on behalf of the town before we know anything. I could potentially embrace the town collectively utilizing the cannons after EON1.

lol flash, we ain't voting yet

y2kjbk wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 9:22 pm

The only thing concerning reveals that I could see having merit would be from those that are town-clearing, but letting scum know where those items are would be a major downside to that.

A bigger downside is if they shoot one of the potential clears without giving them a chance to claim.

If we vote for one of the five PCs (potential clears) they should say they are one of the 5 without saying which one, then the nurses can protect them and we keep them safe for tonight. If they lie then we caught scum that will be exposed sooner or later.

Oh that is right. This is night.

##GM NOTE:

Please send your actions, questions, or any other concerns to BOTH Jamie and me.

y2kjbk wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 9:32 pm

I think it's a bad idea for cannon shots to be rushed on behalf of the town before we know anything. I could potentially embrace the town collectively utilizing the cannons after EON1.

But forcing the hand of Mafia is good too. If the Mafia has a cannon they will keep it for as long as possible because they will want to shoot claears with it. If they don't shoot who we tell them now we will know the cannon is with Mafia and eventually we will know who has what item so that holding the shot to shoot a clear will cost them.

man.

I sit out a bunch of games in a row. Get excited to get back in, and I can't even instantly vote ND? What kind of shit is this?

On top of that, whats the point of having cannons if they aren't hipfired without reasoning?

I think I like xorxes reasoning, but it might be a better play come N2. At least then when collectively deciding targets we have at least a bit to help us try to aim correctly.

To the five people with town-only items: please don't claim prematurely. The longer you stay hidden the better.

xorxes, you bring up valid points concerning your proposed plan.

...should we start claiming if we DON'T have a cannon?

y2kjbk wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 9:47 pm

...should we start claiming if we DON'T have a cannon?

First we need some consensus that this is a good idea.

Tom Bombadil wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 9:42 pm

I think I like xorxes reasoning, but it might be a better play come N2. At least then when collectively deciding targets we have at least a bit to help us try to aim correctly.

That sounds a lot like the reasoning for not lynching D1.

If we mis-shoot, we will still have the votes from N1 to analyze and they will inform our D1 lynch.

Also, by N2 two or more people could be dead and we may not be sure whether the cannons are still in play, thus making it easier for Mafia to hide if they have one of them.

##vote y2k for disenfranchisement.

Who are the five potential clears?

hello
##vote ghug
let's hope this doesn't turn out like last time

guys. its night.

Weird. I think this is a first for webdip. Has there ever been a night start? I can't remember if so. Tom is seeming scummy,

Wait its night wtf. ok bye