MAFIA 44: 'DREAMLAND' GAME THREAD

[e.m.c^42]

I haven't actually posted a reads list this game lol

have been sorta lurking; this morning I was (and still am) playing a live game (to Germany; did you guess me?)

[thamrick]

I haven't actually posted a reads list this game lol

have been sorta lurking; this morning I was (and still am) playing a live game (to Germany; did you guess me?)

Then you probably shouldn't comment on your live game.

[e.m.c^42]

oh shit, forgot about the anonymity thing

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok here's the sum total of Worcej's contributions.

Page 3:

Votes Damo because it's "tradition". (Damo went on to flip Town).

Comes up with the D3 single-vote alien hunting plan. (This was a good plan at the time and he gets clever points for it, but not necessarily town points since of course the Mafia want the Alien dead too).

Page 12:

Continues to discuss alien hunting plans.

Page 20:

Engages with me about Ezio's likely alignment. Doesn't think Ezio is Mafia.

Page 21:

Has a null read on me. Discusses my meta with Squigs.

Posts a read list. It is mostly a list of null reads. On this list I notice he reads Damo as a townlean. This is despite his vote being on Damo at that time.

Page 41:

Appears at EoD, just before Ezio retracts, and votes Ezio on the basis that Ezio is the Alien. Appears to leave before Ezio retracts.

Page 59:

Declares that Thamrick, Lord Quas, and RagingIke are his main scum suspects, because they moved off Ezio. Squigs and myself question Worcej on this point - for first saying the Alien should be left until D3, but then criticising people for not lynching the Alien claimant. I found this suspect at the time, but reading Worcej's responses on P.64 and P.65 I'm now more inclined to be persuaded of Worcej's thinking.

Worcej has done nothing of consequence on D2 however.

Conclusion at this point - Townlean.


Questions for Worcej:

1. Why did you list Damo as a townlean at a time when you were voting for him?

2. Do you still consider Thamrick, Lord Quas, and RagingIke to be your main scum suspects?

[Jamiet99uk]

I am now going to Iso Mr. Percival Williams.

[Vecna]

##vote neph - just in case, might not be able to be here eod

[Nephthys]

##vote neph - just in case, might not be able to be here eod

This is a little weak

[Jamiet99uk]

Percy Williams iso goes like this:

Page 12:

Votes for Worcej based on Ike's stupid list, with no justification other than "I'm good with this". Sheeping Ike's nonsense looks very odd.

Page 17:

Votes for Ezio because claimed Alien.

Page 24:

Points out that if Ezio is Town he could actually be resurrected.

Page 56:

"I think Ike legitimately didn't look at his role, he can't give himself away if he doesn't know."

This quote is highly suspect. Percy had been willing to sheep RagingIke's reads, whilst also thinking Ike didn't know his own role? Hmmm.

Page 70:

States he agrees with "$$ NO SHOOT" apparently unaware that by the time he posted this the Alien Raygun had already been fired...

Thinks I am town (well at least that's correct).

Has no scumreads.

Page 71:

Seems to be worried people will think he's the Alien.

Page 72:

Votes for Ezio.

Page 77:

Still has no scumreads. Is not Australian. Now has a scumlean, and it's Xorxes.


Questions for P-Willy:

1. Justify your D1 vote on Worcej please?

2. If you believed RagingIke's silly "I didn't read my PM" gambit, why were you also willing to follow RagingIke's suggestions at who to vote for?

[Nephthys]

Jamie, your rereads are pretty average,

You acknowledge that Worcejs vote was a joke but still question him on it, I don't think you picked up on his contradictory behaviour towards the end of eod.

Percy you don't even provide a conclusion and your second question makes no sense, if ikr didn't read his pm he would be playing as town therefore scimhunting.

What's up here man? This is really abysmal work

[Jamiet99uk]

Jamie, your rereads are pretty average,

You acknowledge that Worcejs vote was a joke but still question him on it, I don't think you picked up on his contradictory behaviour towards the end of eod.

Percy you don't even provide a conclusion and your second question makes no sense, if ikr didn't read his pm he would be playing as town therefore scimhunting.

What's up here man? This is really abysmal work

I wanted to understand Percy's thought process.

Thanks for answering for him so that he now doesn't have to. Great work.

[RagingIke297]

@Jamie

Iso me! Iso me next!

[Jamiet99uk]

As for a conclusion, I don't think Percy is the Alien, because I think that Ezio is. So Percy is probably a nervous town newbert.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Jamie

Iso me! Iso me next!

I shall now proceed to iso Dargorygel, and then Xorxes.

[bo_sox48]

I managed to come down with strep and feel like absolute crap. I'll try to read up but I doubt I'm doing much unless these painkillers are magical.

[Jamiet99uk]

Before anyone points out that Darg is dead - yes I know that, but we don't know his alignment. So a re-read is still in order.

[Nephthys]

Jamie, your rereads are pretty average,

You acknowledge that Worcejs vote was a joke but still question him on it, I don't think you picked up on his contradictory behaviour towards the end of eod.

Percy you don't even provide a conclusion and your second question makes no sense, if ikr didn't read his pm he would be playing as town therefore scimhunting.

What's up here man? This is really abysmal work

I wanted to understand Percy's thought process.

Thanks for answering for him so that he now doesn't have to. Great work.

Haha what's the point in asking forced obvious questions? I'm struggling to justify my town read of you right now

[Jamiet99uk]

Jamie, your rereads are pretty average,

You acknowledge that Worcejs vote was a joke but still question him on it, I don't think you picked up on his contradictory behaviour towards the end of eod.

Percy you don't even provide a conclusion and your second question makes no sense, if ikr didn't read his pm he would be playing as town therefore scimhunting.

What's up here man? This is really abysmal work

I wanted to understand Percy's thought process.

Thanks for answering for him so that he now doesn't have to. Great work.

Haha what's the point in asking forced obvious questions? I'm struggling to justify my town read of you right now

Why is it pointless to ask Percy why he was so comfortable to sheep Ike?

[LordQuas]

+town points to jamie for ISOing darg

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm in the process.

In the meantime, that was one hell of a chainsaw from Neph. If Percy happens to flip scum later, Neph probably is too.

[RagingIke297]

##vote Worcej

He's been around too long