MAFIA 64 - The Z Files - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[bozotheclown]

@bob - my modus operandi seems to be get DK early because I always look scummy, get fear NK if I evade a daykill, figure out the puzzle just before I get killed if I reach the mid game but fail to convince anyone. I never reach the end game. My stats are pretty good, my play is terrible.

Are you willing to say what you discarded, either town/not town, town/mafia/alien/SK, or the exact role?

See post 1284 - I discarded the commuter

Thanks, I missed that.

[BunnyGo]

this past summer I also won a game in champs as mafia which is even rarer for me.

If the point is you are good at mafia then I think you have made it.

not the point. point is not to belittle and slander me

OK, but Ezio is now just lurking here. You've done well.

I have maintained that I am an anti-town player...but I'm working on it.

What do you think of celaph?

[Hamilton Brian]

@celaph, how much weight do you think is reasonable in attributing to previous game performances? I'm just noticing you have been going back to a few very specific pieces to help contribute to a line of thinking in this game.

[bozotheclown]

Thanks. With the pandemics we can't travel, but I have a house close to the Beach and it's not a popular beach so we have plenty of space.

I finally caught up with the thread too.

I found that Bona exchange really annoying, as it's not how the game should been played, but I think Bona is town, I think scum Bona would have backed down after the pressure he got, but he double down. Also, to add a point, voting lurkers D1 sometimes make them magically apear...

I kinda like the Macca wagon, they didn't gave an impression and I usually tend to easily sort they as town.

I would not mind also a Maniac wagon, his total lack of content other then a weird vote on Brain isn't what I expect from him.

##vote Maniac

I do not like rdrivera pointing out he likes the Macca wagon but voting elsewhere, he could be leaving the Macca option open for a later vote. However, what concerns me most is rdrivera saying he usually sorts Macca correctly when they are town, because Macca has only been town for a full game one time, and in that game rdrivera was scum reading Macca as late as D4, when rdrivera voted for Macca.

Also, rdrivera's reason for not revealing his discard no longer hold up with most players already making a claim about their discard and the option to say only the alignment of his discard.

##VOTE rdrivera

Yep, you are right about Macca, he was town on M61 and was sus as hell. In my defense I probably confused him with Bob.

Anyway, pretty obvious I discarded a town card. To be honest, if I had a chance I would have picked Mafia, Alien or SK. I have been town for a long strike now.

I do not see how you could confuse Macca and Bob, so I am not convinced you were not fabricating a reason to scum read Macca.

However, Macca ended D1 voting for me when they were scum in M1015, coincidentally voting when damo was the only other player voting for me, but you and Macca could both be scum.

[damo666]

Why do you characterize it as hiding?

I disagree, I think there results so far have been informative.

Mmmmm? Please inform us then, or do something else in the meantime. I highly doubt it's taking all your mental energy to bookkeep that list. You haven't done much of note other than it so far, hence hiding. I'm sure you'll come out tonight with something, but so far you have nothing.

I prefer to see everyone respond first.

response

[bozotheclown]

Am I wrong in my assumption that usually scum don't know each other's actual roles until they can talk in scumchat? Because if not, then Maniac is really sus here.

I do not remember any game where I was scum that I did not know the roles of other scum on D1.

[brainbomb]

##Vote bunnygo

[brainbomb]

Bunny reacts to everything but lacks any actual effort to push anyone. hes the loudest bystander in our game.

[Hamilton Brian]

Interesting that celaph challenged Bona to ask them questions, and the questions seemed to be fluff pieces about performance in previous games.

@Bona, do you think Celaph is SO different this game as to be a different alignment than before?

Furthermore, hereviewtopic.php?p=213410#p213410 you indicated you'd vote brain over ezio. Why would you entertain brainbomb over anyone else right now?

[damo666]

Holey Smokes!

So very sorry for today. I am now a prefect, and the things I've had to do took much longer than expected.

I starting reading through at about 9:30 (it's now 9pm is Queensland, for reference) in my spare time, and have only just caught up to the present now.

Bob is right, I like to mark all posts I want to respond to, and then do them all at once. I will be writing those replies now.

Very sorry again.

Congrats them

[BunnyGo]

Am I wrong in my assumption that usually scum don't know each other's actual roles until they can talk in scumchat? Because if not, then Maniac is really sus here.

I do not remember any game where I was scum that I did not know the roles of other scum on D1.

Xorxes and I were your teammates. You were a traitor who didn't know us. You were the only one pushing me (correctly) the whole game.

[BunnyGo]

Bunny reacts to everything but lacks any actual effort to push anyone. hes the loudest bystander in our game.

Did you miss the Macca push? The rereads? The D1-ness of this...

cool story.

[Bonatogether]

Interesting that celaph challenged Bona to ask them questions, and the questions seemed to be fluff pieces about performance in previous games.

@Bona, do you think Celaph is SO different this game as to be a different alignment than before?

Furthermore, hereviewtopic.php?p=213410#p213410 you indicated you'd vote brain over ezio. Why would you entertain brainbomb over anyone else right now?

1) Yes.

2) Voting ezio doesn't give us as much info, but I wouldn't vote brain over everyone else, like I've said before.

[brainbomb]

its not a cool story bunny. ive been unsure about you all game and this reminds me of two games back where you got kinda weird about aaro.

I think macca is a safe push but to be exact you arent town and you re coasting on volume

[Hamilton Brian]

1) Yes.

2) Voting ezio doesn't give us as much info, but I wouldn't vote brain over everyone else, like I've said before.

Thanks for clarifying; I am intrigued how the other players on your list would give us a lot of info if flipped. Are you suggesting that from the VCA standpoint?

[brainbomb]

Also you seem to find things funny this game as opposed to forming opinions of your own

[BunnyGo]

Also you seem to find things funny this game as opposed to forming opinions of your own

Then you aren't reading what I'm putting out. You're too busy feeling hurt by Ezio who isn't even here. It's lazier than you

[brainbomb]

you mentioned the masons multiple times too in weird ways which makes me think youre an alien role that messes with their QT

[brainbomb]

Also you seem to find things funny this game as opposed to forming opinions of your own

Then you aren't reading what I'm putting out. You're too busy feeling hurt by Ezio who isn't even here. It's lazier than you

deflection is not your town style

[BunnyGo]

you mentioned the masons multiple times too in weird ways which makes me think youre an alien role that messes with their QT

What alien role messes with QTs?