MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[brainbomb]

Durga
Youre forgetting this guys played like 2 mafia games

If hes scum hes a first time scum.
First time scum are NOTORIOUS for doing gambit shit to get cred
First timers bus because they dont know what else to do in a pinch
They panic and many times see cannibalism as the only way to make it deep

[y2kjbk]

"If flash were scum" logic isn't the way to go, it's "If flash were town" logic.

[brainbomb]

Im fine with ND-Vecna-Yavuz dying before durga-ghug-flash I guess

[Durga]

I don't feel good about killing off Vecna. I feel like it's almost too... obvious. And his last posts felt good to me.

[y2kjbk]

I could lynch ND if he doesn't get modkilled or come back to the game with something legitimate.

[ghug]

Why?

The proof has been left as an exercise to the reader.

Has anybody done this exercise?

Sadly no.

[ghug]

You believe it when he says he believed your retraction?

Well no one stole my gun. If he was scum and believed it, that's two dead townies (because let's be real - the best play for scum would be to steal my gun, and use their two cannons (if Flash was scum) to shoot two townies actually leading the discussion). Instead you have dead scum and deadbeat Chaqa. Not exactly the play I'd want as scum!Flash or scum!anyone

Thief isn't necessarily scum.

[ghug]

Vecna's town.

[flash2015]

Too be completely fair. I would NOT have shot MoscowFleet that fast. I would want him and bb to battle it out first. I don't know why Flash was so rash, but that could have just been the excitement of a townie wanting to do something. I think if Flash was scum, he would have wanted the townie who had the cannon to use theirs up. I'm just really skeptical of wasting your cannon for town cred when he's an obvious night kill target now. It'll be more suspect if he survives a long time.

I agree wholeheartedly. I shot too soon. I got too excited with my first "PR-like" item. At least though I did better than y2k did with his vig shots last game...

[Tom Bombadil]

Why DemonRHK is scum

I’ve stated this before, but I feel like his entire N0 was a forced ploy to seem extra casual and laid back – overcompensating for some of the thrill of rolling scum. It just seems disingenuous.

Scumreads ND at the beginning of D1. Then starts questioning me and is suspicious of me for asking people to follow me onto ND.

Says:
“Tom you’ve never made a case on ND”
And: “ND hasn’t made a single post regarding the game and had been about as far from active as you can be without being named snowy. I got get how you’ve read him before he’s put anything of substance down.”

So its pretty clear that he made up a scumread on ND at the beginning of the day for no reason. Seems weird to be completely unwilling to vote someone that you scumread. Then votes me (the top counterwagon to a scum squiggles).

N1 tries to setup damo as a lynch prospect (that was undermined by the birthday card).

@RHK – Why did you scumread ND at the beginning of D1 and what changed?

[Tom Bombadil]

##vote DemonRHK

[y2kjbk]

Durga, it's very plausible scum believed your cannon claim and just wanted to let you misfire on your own terms.

[damo666]

The proof has been left as an exercise to the reader.

Has anybody done this exercise?

Sadly no.

Well help me out will you?

[y2kjbk]

flash, i saved last game blasting bo_sox, GTFO

[Durga]

You believe it when he says he believed your retraction?

Well no one stole my gun. If he was scum and believed it, that's two dead townies (because let's be real - the best play for scum would be to steal my gun, and use their two cannons (if Flash was scum) to shoot two townies actually leading the discussion). Instead you have dead scum and deadbeat Chaqa. Not exactly the play I'd want as scum!Flash or scum!anyone

Thief isn't necessarily scum.

That is true. And given your item got stolen, I'm willing to bet they aren't scum.

[flash2015]

flash, i saved last game blasting bo_sox, GTFO

I am talking about the last game we played together, Infinity War.

[damo666]

##unvote

[Durga]

Ok so y2k, damo666 and bb are confirmed town. Flash is very likely town. I have town reads on Tom and Vecna and xorxes.

I'm starting to think this is a very weak scum team. Largely because of the nk on bozo, the attempt on bb, and the roleblock on me.

[y2kjbk]

and i did pretty damn well this game i think with my item/role as well. my scum-reading is another matter.

[damo666]

Vecna's town.

reasoning?