MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[brainbomb]

Flash saying dont shoot can also be 1 wolf to save bullet

Durga/flash can both be scum. Its well within boths meta

[y2kjbk]

We don't have to doubt him about his actual game-affecting actions, which is that he had a gun and claimed it and shot scum-scanned MF. That in isolation is not a clearing action.

[Tom Bombadil]

Flash saying dont shoot can also be 1 wolf to save bullet

Durga/flash can both be scum. Its well within boths meta

Brainbombs Razor - the most contrived explanation is the best

[ghug]

Flash saying dont shoot can also be 1 wolf to save bullet

Durga/flash can both be scum. Its well within boths meta

Brainbombs Razor - the most contrived explanation is the best

+1

It's also not at all within Durga's meta.

[Durga]

We don't have to doubt him about his actual game-affecting actions, which is that he had a gun and claimed it and shot scum-scanned MF. That in isolation is not a clearing action.

Its pretty goddamn clearing. What lunatic would shoot their own. But like, its also a stupid push in general. Who else do you feel is scum? Because I think it's about time we move on from spamming about Flash being scum. He is not being lynched. Not now anyway.

[flash2015]

Flash saying dont shoot can also be 1 wolf to save bullet

Durga/flash can both be scum. Its well within boths meta

That is a stretch. I haven't been scum yet, so you don't know how I will play as scum (I don't even know how I would play as scum).

[brainbomb]

##Vote ND

[ghug]

ghug, do you think flash is town, or you more think lynching him is just generally not smart right now given the circumstances of preceding actions?

I have a few doubts, but the process facts are enough to put him near the top of my town list.

[damo666]

Moscow flip clears me for sure

Why?

The proof has been left as an exercise to the reader.

Has anybody done this exercise?

[y2kjbk]

I remember a game when I was scum with Tom, and Tom bussed the hell out of all of us buddies and ultimately won the game at the end surviving multiple mislynches. Bussing isn't dumb.

[brainbomb]

When im doubt lynch ppl who aint doing a damn thing

[y2kjbk]

Especially if Day 1 starts with a guilty scan.

[Durga]

I remember a game when I was scum with Tom, and Tom bussed the hell out of all of us buddies and ultimately won the game at the end surviving multiple mislynches. Bussing isn't dumb.

No, bussing isn't necessarily dumb all the time. But actively shooting someone on your minuscule scum team with your fancy item is.

[brainbomb]

No issue killin off vecna-yavuz-nd as our next 3

[y2kjbk]

He didn't shoot him out of the blue, he shot him before you could.

[Durga]

He didn't shoot him out of the blue, he shot him before you could.

I had my claim retracted and hadn't been online yet to say I still had the gun.

[y2kjbk]

You believe it when he says he believed your retraction?

[Durga]

Too be completely fair. I would NOT have shot MoscowFleet that fast. I would want him and bb to battle it out first. I don't know why Flash was so rash, but that could have just been the excitement of a townie wanting to do something. I think if Flash was scum, he would have wanted the townie who had the cannon to use theirs up. I'm just really skeptical of wasting your cannon for town cred when he's an obvious night kill target now. It'll be more suspect if he survives a long time.

[Durga]

You believe it when he says he believed your retraction?

Well no one stole my gun. If he was scum and believed it, that's two dead townies (because let's be real - the best play for scum would be to steal my gun, and use their two cannons (if Flash was scum) to shoot two townies actually leading the discussion). Instead you have dead scum and deadbeat Chaqa. Not exactly the play I'd want as scum!Flash or scum!anyone

[damo666]

Just done a reread of ghug and not so convinced of his scuminess any more. Can anyone explain why he says the Moscow flip clears him (he won't do it himself).