webdiplomacy.net

Grogg:

Lady Andoryn. I see you in market while I fix holes.
Grogg wish to...
Grogg wish to give you this!

(He lays flowers at your feet)

I will honor this council and do whatever grogg is asked

GM NOTE:

The proposal to switch the game over to discord only is valid. However, the forum serves a valuable purpose for many roles and when the official game begins colony management will be much more important.

We do not advise you to disregard his request.

Our team is having alot of fun and will go whatever path the players prefer. Tgat being said, roleplaying is a part of this game not all of it.

I am in favour of the forum.

I confess that roleplaying is something that I enjoy.

I vote in favour of hiring Grogg.

Forum or Discord, both are good to me. Secret playing on Discord is good but WebDip forum is easier for me. I think we should continue playing on two different sites.

And Brain, you should update legislation proposals because memorising every proposal doesn't sound good.

I don't want to vote about Grogg, it's left to fellow councilors to decide.

##CALL DUNGEONMASTER

Can we please have a vote count on all currently tabled proposals?

All proposals with their vote counts can be tracked here:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing

This is what a formal phase charter will look like:

Proposal 0.1.1 - Establish a Baronry in Esfillied at hex location 36, 16
Yea Votes - Kench, yav, PW, worcej
Nay Votes - Jamie
--Proposal Passes--

Proposal 0.1.2 - Establish a baronry in Hanaved
Yea Votes - Jamie
Nay Votes - Kench
--Proposal Fails--

Proposal 0.2.1 - Select Wood Elves for starting population
Yea Votes - Kench, yav, PW, worcej
Nay Votes - Jamie
--Proposal Passes--

Proposal 0.2.2 - Select Humans for starting population
Yea Votes - Kench, PW, Jamie, worcej
Nay Votes -
--Proposal Passes--

Proposal 0.3 - Accept the King's gracious offer of (3) Food, (2) Horses, (1) Stone
Yea Votes - Kench, yav, PW, Jamie, worcej
Nay Votes -
--Proposal Passes--

Proposal 0.4.1 - Crisis Option A: Entire party respond to the fires in the riverside district.
Yea Votes -
Nay Votes - yav
--Proposal Fails--

Proposal 0.4.2 - Crisis Option B: Ignore the fires.
Yea Votes - yav
Nay Votes -
--Proposal Passes--

Proposal 0.4.3 - Crisis Option C: Individual party members opt in to the quest "Fires by Riverside."
Yea Votes - yav
Nay Votes -
--Proposal Passes--

Proposal 0.5.1 - Hire Valeria as a specialist
Yea Votes - Jamie
Nay Votes - Kench, yav, worcej
--Proposal Fails--

Proposal 0.5.2 - Hire Grogg as a specialist
Yea Votes - PW
Nay Votes -
--Proposal Passes--

##Call GM

Out of interest, how are the proposal pass/fails being decided in the above? My understanding was that a proposal required at least 3 votes in favour of it to be officially considered, at which point the proposal passed/failed based on a majority vote.

It's not such a problem for Proposal 0.4, which has effectively been nullified by outside events, but why does Proposal 0.5.2 pass if the only person to have voted on it is PW?

Dearest Grogg, despite the latent creepiness

... I see you in market while I fix holes...

I can hardly refuse such a lovely gift.

##Vote Yes - Proposal 0.5.2 Hire Grogg as a specialist

##Vote Yes - Proposal 0.5.2

##Vote Yes - Proposal 0.5.2

In regards to voting in Discord - it's rough for me to access it when at work, but easier at home. That being said, I think using Discord for the RP side and the forum for colony management and proposal voting is much easier for me.

As you may have noticed, I am more into this for the colony management side, but do think it's fun to read what you all are doing in Discord :)

Kench wrote: ↑

Thu Jun 28, 2018 1:50 pm

##Call GM

Out of interest, how are the proposal pass/fails being decided in the above? My understanding was that a proposal required at least 3 votes in favour of it to be officially considered, at which point the proposal passed/failed based on a majority vote.

It's not such a problem for Proposal 0.4, which has effectively been nullified by outside events, but why does Proposal 0.5.2 pass if the only person to have voted on it is PW?

I haven't modified my code for determining pass/fail from the last sim yet. I believe the current code will result in pass if there are more yes votes than no votes. You guys are welcome to establish a different system.

thamrick wrote: ↑

Thu Jun 28, 2018 2:40 pm

Kench wrote: ↑

Thu Jun 28, 2018 1:50 pm

##Call GM

Out of interest, how are the proposal pass/fails being decided in the above? My understanding was that a proposal required at least 3 votes in favour of it to be officially considered, at which point the proposal passed/failed based on a majority vote.

It's not such a problem for Proposal 0.4, which has effectively been nullified by outside events, but why does Proposal 0.5.2 pass if the only person to have voted on it is PW?

I haven't modified my code for determining pass/fail from the last sim yet. I believe the current code will result in pass if there are more yes votes than no votes. You guys are welcome to establish a different system.

Um, so "passes" in your post above means it is set to pass if it stays like that at phase end, not that it has *been* passed?

Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Thu Jun 28, 2018 2:53 pm

Um, so "passes" in your post above means it is set to pass if it stays like that at phase end, not that it has *been* passed?

Correct. Votes are finalized at the end of the phase. Until then, you are welcome to change your votes or propose new proposals.

WHY ARE WE PLAYING ON SIGN UP THREAD?

yavuzovic wrote: ↑

Thu Jun 28, 2018 4:31 pm

WHY ARE WE PLAYING ON SIGN UP THREAD?

Because signups aren't over for several more days

Yavuzovic has a point. The game has actually started and it's quite misleading for this to be called a "sign up" thread at this point.

##CALL GM


The map does not appear to have numbered hexes? What is this numbering?

Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Thu Jun 28, 2018 5:24 pm

##CALL GM


The map does not appear to have numbered hexes? What is this numbering?

You can enable it on your end. Expand the map in the top left and it is one of the options in the menu bar.

http://imgur.com/gallery/kUleI7S
http://imgur.com/R39c9lt
http://imgur.com/LtFHeYo
http://imgur.com/MhtVvmK

Uthwick: I have redrawn them! It took me hours councillors.