MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

A shot rings out!

Justaguynamedwill has died he was Ryan Paevey a big city Mafia Goon

Oops, shit. Wont happen again

[brainbomb]

As Jamie would know he would reveal as Watcher in the event of his death do you not think he would be more careful in wording his EON msg had he got no results?

Not necessarily, he may have thought Bonatogether was the best DK D3 regardless.

That clears things up

You died Will,
please cease posting

[bozotheclown]

some opinions I have

Fun sponge BunnyGo has proven himself to be an unreliable, as he has made his opinion based on my jokes, which he would have no knowledge of if this is Norma for me or not. So yeah

Unless he’s just trying to get an easy miskill that Spirit pointed out early. Which in that case looks like a mafia inclined Spirit trying to justify an easy miskill on me.

Coming back to my jokes, one thing Jamie brought up was my joke about ND being a bad mafia partner. This should be disregarded as it is a joke.

Knowing how it feels to be aggressively targeted by a town ND, I can safely say that his actions of craziness happened too early to be natural (or at least natural for ND)

Yes, bona does make some good points, but no, they cannot make up for NDs antics, and Bona may just be trying to save a doomed situation.

On the other hand, ND may have just been acting stupid and Bona now has to pick up the pieces.

Unless any new information or counterclaims come out, I believe Bona is the best target. He has been put into an unfortunate situation though, and I do commend him for his good threat level control.

Anyways I just wanted to rant about something

Let’s do this guys

Losing ND is tough, but losing Bona is not

##VOTE ND

Yuck at the last sentence. Also, you gotta vote for Bona unfortunately. Voting ND is not valid anymore.

In time, you will come to understand

Once Bona flips mafia

If Bonatogether is mafia, this is some strange bussing coordination.

[bozotheclown]

If Just is mafia, that would mean 12 players ended D1 voting for mafia. Even if all of the mafia were bussing, that does not seem particularly likely.

Do you really think afia would only bus more than one of their own? Seems way too risky with no communication. Heck, I think all the mafia may have ended up on sweet at some point, but so believe at least one had to have been on me or Macca

If Just is mafia, he may be confirming that the remaining 3 mafia voted for sweetandcool during D1. He also seems to be saying that one mafia voting for sweetandcool moved to him or Macca before EOD, because we know sweetandcool voted for him. The only player that meets that criteria is Temasek.

So maybe it is Just/Temasek/ghug? That would also help explain ghug's D2 T vs. T conclusion based on the questionable apathy claim.

This theory is not disproven yet either.

[heartthrob24909]

A shot rings out!

Justaguynamedwill has died he was Ryan Paevey a big city Mafia Goon

WHOA! Ka-chow

[Bonatogether]

when it was 3-3-3-2 macca-sweet-just-bona at T-0:45 on eod1, why does the macca wagon collapse? just votes for it at :41 but all other votes are either for just or sweet

[Bonatogether]

highly curious

[BunnyGo]

A shot rings out!

Justaguynamedwill has died he was Ryan Paevey a big city Mafia Goon

Hell yeah!

Bona next. They were DEFINITELY distancing each other today when pressure started.

[BunnyGo]

I don't mind being Vig fodder btw

Chaqa voters, what do we think of this? Why would he say this?

I don’t really think you can psycho analyze chaqa because he has done so much random shit over time that it’s impossible to just assume he will be reasonable.

This is the way

[BunnyGo]

Holy fuck - D1 was S vs S lol

Can someone at a computer start putting together some color coded VCA of crucial decision points D1 and D2?

[BunnyGo]

Why is it obvious that he is not the real doctor?

It’s such a dumb decision on the doctors part to reveal so early. I am 95% sure this is a fake claim so that Bona can save his own ass.

I am 95% sure Bona is the actual doctor with Will’s flip now revealing he was scum.

Nah. Go reread their interactions today

[BunnyGo]

The assumption about Jamie could be wrong, and Bonatogether's claim is not a good claim as mafia either. Also, the mafia have a ninja.

And roleblocker...they probably used both on spirit.

Honestly, with a watcher in play, I’d expect scum to withhold the RB.

I don’t think Just advocates that. I don’t think Bofa does either. Depending on their last teammate…

[BunnyGo]

when it was 3-3-3-2 macca-sweet-just-bona at T-0:45 on eod1, why does the macca wagon collapse? just votes for it at :41 but all other votes are either for just or sweet

This is a good question

[ghug]

when it was 3-3-3-2 macca-sweet-just-bona at T-0:45 on eod1, why does the macca wagon collapse? just votes for it at :41 but all other votes are either for just or sweet

when it was 3-3-3-2 macca-sweet-just-bona at T-0:45 on eod1, why does the bona wagon collapse? just votes for macca at :41 but all other votes are either for just or sweet

[ghug]

More seriously, the only unknown alignments in the remaining votes are Bozo and damo. Will picked Macca over sweet, and then a bunch of dead townies and bozo voted for the other two to make it a three day race, and then Will switched to sweet once sweet had taken the lead.

[BunnyGo]

when it was 3-3-3-2 macca-sweet-just-bona at T-0:45 on eod1, why does the macca wagon collapse? just votes for it at :41 but all other votes are either for just or sweet

when it was 3-3-3-2 macca-sweet-just-bona at T-0:45 on eod1, why does the bona wagon collapse? just votes for macca at :41 but all other votes are either for just or sweet

This is a better question

[BunnyGo]

More seriously, the only unknown alignments in the remaining votes are Bozo and damo. Will picked Macca over sweet, and then a bunch of dead townies and bozo voted for the other two to make it a three day race, and then Will switched to sweet once sweet had taken the lead.

Are you at a computer where you can tell me this story in colored vote status format?

[ghug]

More seriously, the only unknown alignments in the remaining votes are Bozo and damo. Will picked Macca over sweet, and then a bunch of dead townies and bozo voted for the other two to make it a three day race, and then Will switched to sweet once sweet had taken the lead.

Are you at a computer where you can tell me this story in colored vote status format?

I am always on my phone, but I find the bot pretty useful for these things.

[Temasek22]

Nice one guys. When was the last time both the top two wagons were scum D1 anyway?

[bozotheclown]

Nice one guys. When was the last time both the top two wagons were scum D1 anyway?

They were in M1026 until the last minute.