MAFIA 78: Random Facts [GAME THREAD] - [HIDDEN]

[Princess Neon]

i swear to god i've played here since 2020 and i cannot remember a SINGLE instance in which someone was voted out for being a sub

I can remember it because my first game here I defended a sub by saying we should judge the sub on their own merits and everyone acted like that was an insane take.

And in every game I've been in the subs have been killed because of how their slots acted before the sub. Which is frankly... anti sub.

??? are you saying we can't use the play of previous players in the slot? because that is a genuinely insane take.

this is a nutty post

if you HAVE INFO, you USE INFO

I mean when the whole reason to suspect someone is that the person before them didn't participate

That's kinda Level 0 and well just kill town.

[Bonatogether]

I can remember it because my first game here I defended a sub by saying we should judge the sub on their own merits and everyone acted like that was an insane take.

And in every game I've been in the subs have been killed because of how their slots acted before the sub. Which is frankly... anti sub.

??? are you saying we can't use the play of previous players in the slot? because that is a genuinely insane take.

this is a nutty post

if you HAVE INFO, you USE INFO

I mean when the whole reason to suspect someone is that the person before them didn't participate

That's kinda Level 0 and well just kill town.

yeah that's bs

[Princess Neon]

i seriously don't understand in what world this was a good play

Like most of them really

i literally don't even know what to say to you

you're just wrong

Except I'm not

[KoalaAttack]

I'm not moving my vote. But just want to throw out that Chaqa seemed really sus D4 and really town this day. Idk how to make sense of that

But I'll figure that out later

Someone had to pick up the slack now that Eden's gone.

I typed this up before remembering Eden was mafia, but I'm going to post it anyway for posterity and posteriority.

Mate, come on...

I am literally thinking here going "maybe I should reconsider Chaqa trolling being Suspicious in light of their actually useful engaged participation today" ...

And what does Chaqa do? Why, Chaqa posts The Mother Of All Troll Posts of course. The funny Family Guy video notwithstanding.

I am... impressed. And back to Suspicious.

[Bonatogether]

Like most of them really

i literally don't even know what to say to you

you're just wrong

Except I'm not

yet here we are

[Princess Neon]

This is a funny comment because Bozo is the only person who's been right lol

It's even funnier because bozo is a wolf lol

This comment is either:
1. Scum Neon outing her teammate
2. Scum Neon shading Bozo
3. Town Neon shading Bozo

weird comment all ways

Or... get this... it is town Neon who thinks Bozo is scum lol

[Bonatogether]

It's even funnier because bozo is a wolf lol

This comment is either:
1. Scum Neon outing her teammate
2. Scum Neon shading Bozo
3. Town Neon shading Bozo

weird comment all ways

Or... get this... it is town Neon who thinks Bozo is scum lol

isn't that just 3

[Chaqa]

I'm not moving my vote. But just want to throw out that Chaqa seemed really sus D4 and really town this day. Idk how to make sense of that

But I'll figure that out later

Someone had to pick up the slack now that Eden's gone.

I typed this up before remembering Eden was mafia, but I'm going to post it anyway for posterity and posteriority.

Mate, come on...

I am literally thinking here going "maybe I should reconsider Chaqa trolling being Suspicious in light of their actually useful engaged participation today" ...

And what does Chaqa do? Why, Chaqa posts The Mother Of All Troll Posts of course. The funny Family Guy video notwithstanding.

I am... impressed. And back to Suspicious.

If it's any help, this is just how I am.

In D&D today I played an Arcane Trickster Rogue Centaur, name Clyde Dale.

[Princess Neon]

I have to revisit. Was Eden trying to fact check you, or trying to fish out the real doc? Idk the answer yet

I know the answer.

I've given it to you. It's also extremely obvious to me in hindsight since I know I'm town.

Reread Edens interactions with and about me assuming I'm town and tell me what you see.

'assume i'm town. reread those interactions, and look at how they confirm my towniness'

I am asking you to reread something with the opposite of your current bias. It's truly not that unreasonable

[BK3K]

If neon flips town, what would that mean for suspects?

On one hand, i think her death is only hey own fault.

On the other hand, Chaqa and bona and advocating the hammer. Bus? But so am I so that's flimsy.

God, i hope she flips scum. Thinking about the implications tho

[Princess Neon]

I'm not moving my vote. But just want to throw out that Chaqa seemed really sus D4 and really town this day. Idk how to make sense of that

But I'll figure that out later

Chaqa is town. Don't kill Chaqa.

Also if 1 more person end votes on me I'll self hammer

[Princess Neon]

I'd be pretty mad but don't worry you can all keep blaming me in DVC.

What is a DVC?

Dead villager chat.

[Chaqa]

It's even funnier because bozo is a wolf lol

This comment is either:
1. Scum Neon outing her teammate
2. Scum Neon shading Bozo
3. Town Neon shading Bozo

weird comment all ways

Or... get this... it is town Neon who thinks Bozo is scum lol

Yes, see #3.

[Chaqa]

If neon flips town, what would that mean for suspects?

On one hand, i think her death is only hey own fault.

On the other hand, Chaqa and bona and advocating the hammer. Bus? But so am I so that's flimsy.

God, i hope she flips scum. Thinking about the implications tho

I think at this point I'm locked in on it being Lfischl and TFB.

I think Eden was their deep threat.

But maybe Koala.

[Princess Neon]

What even is a hard claim if it isn't harder than a regular claim

I mean. It's a hard claim lol. I just know that you can fake a hard claim and be town and have people realize it lol. Ive been on the other end of someone fake hard claiming lol

[Princess Neon]

??? are you saying we can't use the play of previous players in the slot? because that is a genuinely insane take.

this is a nutty post

if you HAVE INFO, you USE INFO

I mean when the whole reason to suspect someone is that the person before them didn't participate

That's kinda Level 0 and well just kill town.

yeah that's bs

It's not...

[Princess Neon]

I'm not moving my vote. But just want to throw out that Chaqa seemed really sus D4 and really town this day. Idk how to make sense of that

But I'll figure that out later

Someone had to pick up the slack now that Eden's gone.

I typed this up before remembering Eden was mafia, but I'm going to post it anyway for posterity and posteriority.

Mate, come on...

I am literally thinking here going "maybe I should reconsider Chaqa trolling being Suspicious in light of their actually useful engaged participation today" ...

And what does Chaqa do? Why, Chaqa posts The Mother Of All Troll Posts of course. The funny Family Guy video notwithstanding.

I am... impressed. And back to Suspicious.

Chaqa is town

[Princess Neon]

i literally don't even know what to say to you

you're just wrong

Except I'm not

yet here we are

The 8 people alive here in this one webdip mafia game... as it turns out... are not the judge and jury on if something is wrong or not. And if a play is bad or not. Thankfully.

[KoalaAttack]

do we need one or two more hammers

We'll need five hammers on Neon, so two more. One, if Koala hammers.

Koala actually went back and re-read The President & The Princess as per Bozo's request. Did not find anything besides many layers of WIFOM-like "yeah, could be either world of Mafia team-work or Eden trying to cross-check Neon".

I agree it's a legit and non-trivial possibility Princess Neon is telling the truth. But I just don't see how we can tell definitively. This is frustrating, because I still have a bunch of suspects, and we are quickly running out of MKs, but it is what it is. I agree with everyone who said we need the data from this flip to move forward.

So... Koala was about to vote to end. But then Koala got distracted trying to make sense of the newest round of Chaqa-trolling and claiming to take up the torch from President Eden.

[Chaqa]

The biggest thing for me is, if Neon is town, why did Rivera die?

Mafia wouldn't have much reason to disbelieve Neon, so Neon IS town, then I think that changes my view on the scumteam quite a lot.

I don't, for example, think a scumteam of 2 of B3K3/TFB/Lfischl/Chaqa would be expected to pick up on Rivera being the Doc, you know?