M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[kgray]

Maniac, HR, and goldie should probably be considered as well.

It's not really fair to put HR and Maniac in the same clump as goldie imo. They at least provided original reads and thoughts about the game.

I'd be fine with goldie.

[damo666]

damo, why do you find HR's case more persuasive than Jamie's?
(also still waiting on anyone to explain why explicitly posting that I'm going to "tactically lurk" is scum-indicative, or ask why I did that, or something)

I don't particularly. I just think TFB is scummier than Fox.

[Fluminator]

From my point of view it's very interesting that your argument totally changed from attempting to revise your original claim, to now saying you were just trolling, right after Chaqa took his vote off you and said he thought you were just trolling.

I don't consider what I did was trolling there.

omg Flum. If you're trolling now you need to say so, please

Our joke phase was going especially long this game (and we were all less funny than usual so it wasn't even an enjoyable joke phase)
I saw an opportunity to take us out of it after Bozo's post about me saying I was town because I claimed town.
My motive was not to just troll! That's a bit reductive and my mafia game identity is a little more than just trolling people!

[Jamiet99uk]

I've got a friend coming over this evening so it's possible this is my last post.

I have made my position regarding Fluminator clear.

I think that he is scum.

I know that he made a false claim about his "truth tell". I've proved this to you. I've posted the evidence. His responses to this proof, to me, appear shifty, and he has changed his excuses more than once.

My vote is staying on Fluminator.

You decide.

[Fluminator]

At this point if Flum is town he is actively distracting the rest of town from finding scum.

Why do you think I came clean?
You're the one who isn't moving on.

[rdrivera2005]

FOR THE LOVE OF JEEBUS
I have posted documentary evidence of someone making a false claim, on the basis of which they were specifically asking everyone to trust them as lock-town.
If that is not a good reason to vote for someone I don't know what is.

SO WHY AREN'T ANY OF YOU VOTING FOR HIM???

Because I am not that sure scum will make such an easy disproven claim. But his last posts makes me consider voting him.

[BesharamSabi]

VOTE COUNT VERSION 1.08

Tell Tom he's the best gm

TheFlyingBoat: (4) Hellenic Riot, damo666, Durga, kgray
celaph: (3) BusinessLamp, Fluminator, DemonRHK
Fluminator: (2) Jamiet99uk, TheFlyingBoat
BobMcBob: (1) Maniac
Bonatogether: (1) ghug
Chaqa: (1) Bonatogether
damo666: (1) Donny Dude
DeathLlama8: (1) bozotheclown
Durga: (1) Chaqa
Foxcastle: (1) BobMcBob
Hellenic Riot: (1) goldfinger0303
Unvote: (1) DeathLlama8
No‑Kill: (1) rdrivera2005

Non-votes: celaph, Foxcastle

AS OF RIGHT NOW BOATMAN IS ABOUT TO SET SAIL TO THE AFTERLIFE

EOD IN 5 HOURS AND 45 MINUTES

The U.S. founding fathers' name for the American Revolution was 'The War with Britain'.

[Chaqa]

At this point if Flum is town he is actively distracting the rest of town from finding scum.

If by "the rest of town" you mean yourself

There's a lot of other players, take a break from Flum for a bit

[Chaqa]

Maniac, HR, and goldie should probably be considered as well.

It's not really fair to put HR and Maniac in the same clump as goldie imo. They at least provided original reads and thoughts about the game.

I'd be fine with goldie.

Having read their ISOs, it's pretty demonstrably false that any of them have done anything meaningful or original.

[Chaqa]

The TFB wagon stinks

[TheFlyingBoat]

Maniac, HR, and goldie should probably be considered as well.

It's not really fair to put HR and Maniac in the same clump as goldie imo. They at least provided original reads and thoughts about the game.

I'd be fine with goldie.

Having read their ISOs, it's pretty demonstrably false that any of them have done anything meaningful or original.

HR did initiate an attack on me for reasonably original reasons, reasons I think don't hold up, but they were at least given. He then did disappear again. Maniac has just seemed insane to me thought maybe that's just his schtick, idk.

[kgray]

Maniac, HR, and goldie should probably be considered as well.

It's not really fair to put HR and Maniac in the same clump as goldie imo. They at least provided original reads and thoughts about the game.

I'd be fine with goldie.

Having read their ISOs, it's pretty demonstrably false that any of them have done anything meaningful or original.

HR literally started a TFB wagon lmao

Maniac at least made a case for scum!Bob

[rdrivera2005]

i lied i did look into it further even though it's 1am

not to be too focused on the stuff about me, but rdi's reactions of doubting me at first and then seemingly coming around strike me as more genuine than celaph just slight town-reading me. if a potential route as mafia is about blending in and making non-controversial posts so as to not draw attention, i feel like celaph is moreso doing that.

which is also kind of why i townread bona decently strongly. the easy thing to do as scum is to just support/back the likeable new guy. him going against the grain a bit with that is a harder sell to make, so it feels more genuine.

I really like this post. The comment about Bona is exactly what I am feeling about him.

And no, I am not buddying anyone.

Have you met Bona?

Personally obviously not. But I don´t think I have either met him outisde of webdip Mafia. Why?

[TheFlyingBoat]

It's not really fair to put HR and Maniac in the same clump as goldie imo. They at least provided original reads and thoughts about the game.

I'd be fine with goldie.

Having read their ISOs, it's pretty demonstrably false that any of them have done anything meaningful or original.

HR literally started a TFB wagon lmao

Maniac at least made a case for scum!Bob

SNIPED

[rdrivera2005]

Bozo / Flum/ Durga / celaph are my PoE for today.

Kgray and Bona and Jamie are very town

Agree on Jamie and Bona.

Don´t want to kill Durga or Bozo.

Why Kgray is very town?

[kgray]

Bozo / Flum/ Durga / celaph are my PoE for today.

Kgray and Bona and Jamie are very town

Agree on Jamie and Bona.

Don´t want to kill Durga or Bozo.

Why Kgray is very town?

Why not bozo? Is this going to be another game where scum!bozo doesn’t do much and his teammates protect him because he’s good when he’s town?

[kgray]

Ghug should not be this silent on the Jamie/Flum stuff.

##vote ghug

[Chaqa]

Bozo / Flum/ Durga / celaph are my PoE for today.

Kgray and Bona and Jamie are very town

Agree on Jamie and Bona.

Don´t want to kill Durga or Bozo.

Why Kgray is very town?

She's a dog person

[ghug]

Where is HR and goldfinger?

I must admit I'm finding this game tough going at the mo.

Goldfinger's house is full of water.

Sounds fishy

[kgray]

Maybe he’s just behind. I still like that vote though.