M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Donny Dude]

bona and tfb have good vibes. p town.

durga bad vibes tbh but i'll look the other way

So it was blamp
Blamp Can I ask what about Durga gave you bad vibes ?
And what made you look the other way?

[kgray]

I call you scummy for saying you won't vote +1ers. You know that's what I'm talking about, but you defend the comment calling bona cringe instead. Why's that?

Why are you intentionally misrepresenting the situation? That’s sus

How did I intentionally misrepresent the situation?

Pretending that boatman responded to one thing "instead" of the other when he clearly responded to both? Obviously?

[Durga]

What do you make of Kgray Jamiet?
I feel like the push by Ghug this early is a town indicator compared to scum ghug for me.

I don't know about Kgray. Not very active so far outside of commenting on TFB and Ghug. Need to see more. No town vibes today. Kgray usually.... tries?

I find Ghug hard to read although there are some little tells he has, which I have my eyes, ears, and nostrils open for.

That's fair.
I do have to agree with your damo take above.
I was going to use blamp as a Durga reader but now don't think thats a good idea.

You should be able to read me better than someone who's never played mafia with me...

[kgray]

Bad damo vibes

"Bad" as in "bad at the game" or "evil Damo buddying town Jamie" ?

I don't think the goal is to buddy necessarily, but the latter.

In what way is damo making an unexplained, confident, early townread scum!damo?

[kgray]

Some random D1 thoughts so far
============================

Ghug his normal D1 shitposty self mostly but let's see.

Kgray called TFB scummy but then also said Ghug was intentionally misrepresenting TFB's posts and seems to have come round on TFB not being scummy after all.

Foxington B. Castle has hardly contributed at all, yet took the time to write a big long post waffling on about people's serotonin levels.

Rdrivera seeming pretty earnest and interested in looking for meaningful content.

Bob and Bona posting quite a lot, but not saying anything.

Chaqa posting very little but occasionally +1-ing people's posts, so apparently lurking.

Deathllama8 outright lurking and admitted as much (which ain't no defence).

Business Lamp seems cautious but engaged so far, I have no particular reason to suspect him.

Hellenic Riot and Maniac haven't showed up yet. Sad.

What do you make of Kgray Jamiet?
I feel like the push by Ghug this early is a town indicator compared to scum ghug for me.

Would you think that about any push ghug made or only a good one? And do you think ghug's push on boatman was a good one?

[Donny Dude]

I don't know about Kgray. Not very active so far outside of commenting on TFB and Ghug. Need to see more. No town vibes today. Kgray usually.... tries?

I find Ghug hard to read although there are some little tells he has, which I have my eyes, ears, and nostrils open for.

That's fair.
I do have to agree with your damo take above.
I was going to use blamp as a Durga reader but now don't think thats a good idea.

You should be able to read me better than someone who's never played mafia with me...

That's probably true although it does not beat actually knowing said person.

[kgray]

I was going to use blamp as a Durga reader but now don't think thats a good idea.

This would be ok if you could be sure that BizLamp and Durga are on different teams. But if you can be sure of that.... well...

Yeah there was a post by blamp that made me think he is new and knows Durga but the fact he pointed out one of Durgas scumtells but then ignores it in a later post as I recall sort of raised my eyebrow.
Let me put it this way: Its something I want to keep an eye on for later as It is d1 and blamp did have a point I felt about the pocketing.
On a different note
##vote damo

Why damo?

[Jamiet99uk]

I was going to use blamp as a Durga reader but now don't think thats a good idea.

This would be ok if you could be sure that BizLamp and Durga are on different teams. But if you can be sure of that.... well...

Yeah there was a post by blamp that made me think he is new and knows Durga but the fact he pointed out one of Durgas scumtells but then ignores it in a later post as I recall sort of raised my eyebrow.
Let me put it this way: Its something I want to keep an eye on for later as It is d1 and blamp did have a point I felt about the pocketing.

On a different note
##vote damo

That is such a different note that I would invite you to talk about it.

Why Damo?

[Donny Dude]

Some random D1 thoughts so far
============================

Ghug his normal D1 shitposty self mostly but let's see.

Kgray called TFB scummy but then also said Ghug was intentionally misrepresenting TFB's posts and seems to have come round on TFB not being scummy after all.

Foxington B. Castle has hardly contributed at all, yet took the time to write a big long post waffling on about people's serotonin levels.

Rdrivera seeming pretty earnest and interested in looking for meaningful content.

Bob and Bona posting quite a lot, but not saying anything.

Chaqa posting very little but occasionally +1-ing people's posts, so apparently lurking.

Deathllama8 outright lurking and admitted as much (which ain't no defence).

Business Lamp seems cautious but engaged so far, I have no particular reason to suspect him.

Hellenic Riot and Maniac haven't showed up yet. Sad.

What do you make of Kgray Jamiet?
I feel like the push by Ghug this early is a town indicator compared to scum ghug for me.

Would you think that about any push ghug made or only a good one? And do you think ghug's push on boatman was a good one?

For the first one, any push ghug made, although you have a point that scum ghug could be doing it for towncred if aware of his own meta enough, the fact the scum ghug is super not pushy and more jokey is a difference.
For the second one, Not particularly ,it d1, there was an emotional component to him coming back to questioning again, that came off as wanting an answer instead of just asking for the sake of doing so to appear active.

[celaph]

you know that feeling when you walk/drive past a cop and your heart starts racing even though you are a law-abiding citizen?

that is how i feel any time i press the submit button

I only feel this way when I am scum....

I felt similarly to how Lamp is describing at the start of my very first game. I also think he'd be far less likely to admit his anxiety as scum.

[Donny Dude]

Why Damo?
He has posted in the game Endvoted on a lurker, and I want to see where some pressure might do and as I recall Damo meta is pretty different between alignments

[kgray]

What do you make of Kgray Jamiet?
I feel like the push by Ghug this early is a town indicator compared to scum ghug for me.

Would you think that about any push ghug made or only a good one? And do you think ghug's push on boatman was a good one?

For the first one, any push ghug made, although you have a point that scum ghug could be doing it for towncred if aware of his own meta enough, the fact the scum ghug is super not pushy and more jokey is a difference.
For the second one, Not particularly ,it d1, there was an emotional component to him coming back to questioning again, that came off as wanting an answer instead of just asking for the sake of doing so to appear active.

Okay, I actually think scum!ghug is more likely to be serious early, but I see where you're coming from.

I know the subject matter of the push is sort of whatever because it's so early, but can you let me know if you think it seemed like ghug was misrepresenting the way boatman defended himself? It seemed really odd to me but nobody else seems to care, and deathllama even +1'd ghug's offending post, so I want someone else's opinion.

[celaph]

In fact so many people are so absent and/or disengaged so far. If I wanted to pressure "low posters" that's like half the players. What's the matter with everyone?

I think activity will pick up today

Dislike this need to justify early D1 inactivity.

[celaph]

In fact so many people are so absent and/or disengaged so far. If I wanted to pressure "low posters" that's like half the players. What's the matter with everyone?

I think activity will pick up today

Dislike this need to justify early D1 inactivity.

He then went on to actually be active which is good.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why Damo?
He has posted in the game Endvoted on a lurker, and I want to see where some pressure might do and as I recall Damo meta is pretty different between alignments

Oh, you think that, do you?

Last game town!Damo was aggressively wagonned to death by town while the remaining scum sat and watched. I'm not sure this community is very good at spotting the differences between Damo's town meta and his scum meta. But maybe you will do better.

[Jamiet99uk]

^ Sorry Donny, that was slightly abrasive of me. Let's see what Damo has to say to you later.

[Donny Dude]

Would you think that about any push ghug made or only a good one? And do you think ghug's push on boatman was a good one?

For the first one, any push ghug made, although you have a point that scum ghug could be doing it for towncred if aware of his own meta enough, the fact the scum ghug is super not pushy and more jokey is a difference.
For the second one, Not particularly ,it d1, there was an emotional component to him coming back to questioning again, that came off as wanting an answer instead of just asking for the sake of doing so to appear active.

Okay, I actually think scum!ghug is more likely to be serious early, but I see where you're coming from.

I know the subject matter of the push is sort of whatever because it's so early, but can you let me know if you think it seemed like ghug was misrepresenting the way boatman defended himself? It seemed really odd to me but nobody else seems to care, and deathllama even +1'd ghug's offending post, so I want someone else's opinion.

Ghug was being serious and very literal reading it again.
I also think tbf answers later on explain his point too. I do get somewhat where Ghug is coming and is trying to get a clear answer. I do buy tbf's later posts on uhh page 11 about the scrutiny.
I don't think ghug was misrepresenting and I think the fault lies in that miscommunication of serious versus jokey.

[Donny Dude]

^ Sorry Donny, that was slightly abrasive of me. Let's see what Damo has to say to you later.

Yeah, and Im god...

[Bonatogether]

Yeah last time we were scum together we absolutely tore up the town. Made 1 successful nightkill in 4 nights or something.

wat

i dont remember that

i only remember only getting caught on a copscan

That also happened. And I killed myself. But we also failed ~3 NKs.

checks out, best scumteam

[Bonatogether]

i am now cosplaying as bona