Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

General discussions that don't fit in other forums can go here.
Forum rules
Feel free to discuss any topics here. Please use the Politics sub-forum for political conversations. While most topics will be allowed please be sure to be respectful and follow our normal site rules at http://www.webdiplomacy.net/rules.php.
Message
Author
User avatar
brainbomb
Posts: 21950
Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 3:20 pm
Karma: 9988
Contact:

Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#1 Post by brainbomb » Sun Mar 01, 2020 5:41 am

The Roman Legions were known for meticulous record keeping. And yet there is no Roman record of Jesus. Was it all just made up to cause unrest? Was there a motive to cause challenges to the authority of the Roman empire to stabilize Jerusalem?

Why did the Roman Legions lie about Jesus?

User avatar
Jamiet99uk
Posts: 29456
Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2017 11:42 pm
Location: Durham, UK
Karma: 18257
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#2 Post by Jamiet99uk » Sun Mar 01, 2020 5:45 am

I mean, I'm not a Christian myself, but I don't think that is true.

Tacticus, a Roman senator, wrote about Jesus, and in particular described the crucifixion.
1

User avatar
brainbomb
Posts: 21950
Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 3:20 pm
Karma: 9988
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#3 Post by brainbomb » Sun Mar 01, 2020 5:46 am

but did he make it all up.

scholars think yea

Baldor
Posts: 3
Joined: Mon Oct 21, 2019 11:56 pm
Karma: 1
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#4 Post by Baldor » Sun Mar 01, 2020 7:05 am

Is there a surviving record of every crucifixion in the Roman empire? There is no reason to believe they even attempted that kind of record keeping and very unlikely that such a record would have survived to the present time even if they did record it.

Octavious
Posts: 3844
Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 4:16 pm
Location: The Five Valleys, Gloucestershire
Karma: 2605
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#5 Post by Octavious » Sun Mar 01, 2020 10:16 am

The Roman's had great record keeping and, much like we do now, when the records no longer served a purpose they were destroyed. One of the finest sources of Roman writing in existence comes from a failed attempt at record destruction at Vindolanda.

PRINCE WILLIAM
Posts: 913
Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2017 11:17 am
Karma: 1041
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#6 Post by PRINCE WILLIAM » Sun Mar 01, 2020 11:25 am

Romans kept records for many things, from the census of the Empire's people to trials records. But, there is a problem with Jerusalem. At 70 AD the Jews raised (once more) against the Romans. This time was a strong rebellion and Romans had a hard time subduing it. Fed up with the situation they destroyed Jerusalem and ploughed the soil as was their punishment in such cases (as they did in Carthage) and then they built a city on top of this, Aelia Capitolina. This had a double effect much was destroyed and what wasn't ended buried deep. Today is calculated that Jerusalem of Jesus' era is thirty metres below the modern city.
4

PRINCE WILLIAM
Posts: 913
Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2017 11:17 am
Karma: 1041
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#7 Post by PRINCE WILLIAM » Sun Mar 01, 2020 12:33 pm

This explains the loss of many records.
Yet there are records of Jesus life and the trial. For the latter, Pilatus was called to explain to emperor Tiberius along with High Priest Annas and Caiaphas. Annas died at the voyage but the other two appeared in front of the emperor. Pilatus was exiled to Vindobona (near today's Vienna) but Caiaphas was executed not having the benefit of Roman citizenship.

User avatar
flash2015
Gold Donator
Gold Donator
Posts: 3200
Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 7:55 pm
Location: Planet Earth
Karma: 1155
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#8 Post by flash2015 » Sun Mar 01, 2020 7:55 pm

Most of the records of Jesus are decades after his death (Tacticus who Jamie mentioned wrote about Jesus around 116 AD - Tacticus was born at least a couple of decades after Jesus died)...so it is certainly possible that he didn't exist at all. Many historical scholars have compared what is written about Jesus in the new testament to other mythical texts and there are lots of similarities (e.g. ideas of virgin birth/resurrection came well before Jesus). The Jews too were obviously influenced by Zoroastrians when they were captive in Persia.

It is difficult to prove a negative though. Someone tomorrow could find official records showing Jesus official trial and execution. I suspect he probably did exist but just like many other historical figures his life and times were wildly exaggerated.

User avatar
Fluminator
Posts: 4808
Joined: Thu Oct 05, 2017 8:50 pm
Karma: 3305
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#9 Post by Fluminator » Sun Mar 01, 2020 10:28 pm

Almost every scholar thinks Jesus existed. The question is who was he really.

BobMcBob
Posts: 3150
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2019 6:28 am
Location: Also Not Austalia
Karma: 2122
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#10 Post by BobMcBob » Mon Mar 02, 2020 6:19 am

The correct answer is no. They don't prove he didn't exist, and they don't prove he did either. But given that religion is inherently metaphysical and cannot be proven or disproven, it's kind of a useless argument to have.

MajorMitchell
Posts: 1396
Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2017 4:05 am
Location: Now Performing Comedic Artist Dusty Balzac Bush Philosopher from Flyblown Gully by the Sea
Karma: 719
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#11 Post by MajorMitchell » Mon Mar 02, 2020 1:05 pm

Succint and to the point. Well done BobMcBob . I agree.

MajorMitchell
Posts: 1396
Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2017 4:05 am
Location: Now Performing Comedic Artist Dusty Balzac Bush Philosopher from Flyblown Gully by the Sea
Karma: 719
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#12 Post by MajorMitchell » Sat Mar 14, 2020 3:48 pm

Perhaps the Scientology gang or the Mormon mob may have records purporting to prove the non existence of the Roman Empire?
1

teacon7
Posts: 1253
Joined: Fri Oct 06, 2017 7:48 pm
Location: Midwestern USA
Karma: 141
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#13 Post by teacon7 » Sun Mar 15, 2020 12:22 am

Why do you ask?

MajorMitchell
Posts: 1396
Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2017 4:05 am
Location: Now Performing Comedic Artist Dusty Balzac Bush Philosopher from Flyblown Gully by the Sea
Karma: 719
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#14 Post by MajorMitchell » Sun Mar 15, 2020 4:29 am

Why do you ask why I ask?
1

Puscherbilbo
Posts: 46
Joined: Tue Jun 25, 2019 9:11 pm
Karma: 7
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#15 Post by Puscherbilbo » Sun Mar 15, 2020 7:45 am

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GzjYmpwbHEA

This debate sums it up quite nicely and is fairly easy to understand for lay people. To my knowledge Price should be considered qualified but his positions hinges on quite a few extremely fringe subarguments which make his conclusions highly speculative since they more or less depend on each other.

If you have further questions the author of this blog is extremly more equipped to answer them properly. (and willing for a small few). Since proceeds go 100% to charity i highly recommend:

https://ehrmanblog.org/

Some points of this i would like to adress:
- "Scholar" is not a defined terminus and this is a topic particularly many people that are not qualified to speak on do. Not every PhD or other equivalents qualify you.
- While Roman society produced lots of written documents (literacy ~10% of population) the bigger issue is transmission. With the notable exception of Egypt (i think) records from the Roman provinces usually survive only as inscriptions or by chance. So our knowledge is much more partial than you might imagine.
-The historical Jesus was from Roman perspective not a very important person. So there basically is not much reason to expect early attestation except from possibly local documents (much did not survive, c.a.). Basically after the crucifixion Jesus was dealt with from Roman point of view.
- Jesus however is attested in the Synoptic Gospels (Mark, Luke, Matthew) and the letters of Paul which scholars believe to be earlier than Tacitus and indepent from one another. Mainstream scholarly opinion also postulates independent sources for synoptic Gospels and Pauls letters which predate these texts but did not survive outside them called "Q", "L", "M" and for Paul "creeds and hymns" dating back within few years of Jesus´death.
- Basically nothing is known about Pontius Pilate except his prefecture in Palestine. There are some jewish sources about that (Philo, Flavius Joesphus). Everything else is probably later christian legendary.
- Some of the more colourful descriptions of Jesus´ life and ministery in the gospels are indeed not uncommon amongst Jewish and Greek-Roman contexts. However those same stories also are applied to persons who undoubtedly existed (Caesar and Octavian e.g.). This is mostly a literary device and while it calls into questions those narrated details it does not call into question the historicity of Jesus.

User avatar
Fluminator
Posts: 4808
Joined: Thu Oct 05, 2017 8:50 pm
Karma: 3305
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#16 Post by Fluminator » Thu Mar 19, 2020 5:11 pm

If Jesus didn't exist, then how do you explain all these churches?
And then who would God's son be?

User avatar
flash2015
Gold Donator
Gold Donator
Posts: 3200
Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 7:55 pm
Location: Planet Earth
Karma: 1155
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#17 Post by flash2015 » Fri Mar 20, 2020 2:24 am

Richard Carrier vs. Ehrman would be a much better debate (Richard Carrier much better explains the mythicist argument)...though perhaps there is too much bad blood between the two. He has a blow by blow rebuttal of the arguments Ehrman brought up in the debate here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kOu2s31xt4

Crazy Anglican
Posts: 310
Joined: Fri Oct 06, 2017 12:04 am
Karma: 285
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#18 Post by Crazy Anglican » Fri Mar 20, 2020 9:33 pm

My question for a mythicist would be when does it stop being myth?

Okay Jesus is a myth (never seen any evidence to make me believe this but for the sake of argument granted)

Then his disciples would probably have to be myths as well since the stories about the me have them going across the known world preaching about Jesus and going to rather gruesome deaths without recanting (so it's easier if they are myths too because they probably aren't simply liars what would the motive be?)

Then there is Paul (universally he seen as a real guy letters and all) So what? He hijacks a gnostic Jewish sect and invents a historical Jesus and his disciples (Who live concurrently with Paul and Paul interacts with them). Then you have the problem of the Sect of Thomas in India who Paul simply could not have had a hand in founding.

Crazy Anglican
Posts: 310
Joined: Fri Oct 06, 2017 12:04 am
Karma: 285
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#19 Post by Crazy Anglican » Fri Mar 20, 2020 9:42 pm

Basically upon what evidence can you say that the Thomas credited with founding the sect in India isn't the disciple? And if he is the disciple, then how do you account for him being an eyewitness to the existence of the historical Jesus?

Crazy Anglican
Posts: 310
Joined: Fri Oct 06, 2017 12:04 am
Karma: 285
Contact:

Re: Do Roman records prove Jesus' existence was a hoax?

#20 Post by Crazy Anglican » Fri Mar 20, 2020 9:52 pm

Now admittedly I am using a tongue in cheek approach (using a possible legend to support a possible myth) to highlight the weakness of the mythicist approach that, as far as I can tell, boils down to denying the existence of a person by basically discounting the evidence provided by anyone who ever professed to meeting him.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 116 guests