Putting in a vote just in case I get too involved in work (my timezone in US EDT so end of day is 5pm for me) to come back and I don't want to be modkilled for not voting. I also don't want this vote to potentially taint any existing wagon (i.e. the wagon is invalid because "newbie" is on it): ##VO...

Vecna wrote: ↑

Mon Jul 16, 2018 12:54 pm

Seems the bot hasnt picked up on the 2nd night kill yet.

It has both deaths registered, the RagingIke death had to be repeated so it shows as though he died during D2.

Putting in a vote just in case I get too involved in work (my timezone in US EDT so end of day is 5pm for me) to come back and I don't want to be modkilled for not voting. I also don't want this vote to potentially taint any existing wagon (i.e. the wagon is invalid because "newbie" is on it): ##VO...

I have been giving some thought to the N1 killings. In particular, I honed in on @DrCJG, and also revisited @Vecna. I looked at @DrCJG's postings through D1, and I found the following: p3 - Evil twin comment - incriminated @Yavuzovic, with the throwaway line "I only hunt scum now". p7 - he observed...

Still, @Bismarck:

If someone was town, what would the pro-town reasoning be for claiming, before the fact, that even if you werent' Roleblocked, you would lie about having been Roleblocked? What is the pro-town reason for doing that?

I can't find one.

Either:

1. Nobody was Roleblocked, or
2. Brainbomb is scum and was Roleblocked by his own team as in #2 above, or
3. The Mafia Roleblocked their NK target (probably Ike).

@Jamiet99uk I think your analysis is a little flawed. Let me elaborate. Let's assume BB claim that he was RB'ed is TRUE. Since both kills happened (and we all agree it is a little early for the JOAT/VET kills) then BB can't be either SK or the Ninja, since those two people did the respective killin...

^ I purport that since no-one has counter-claimed the RB, the likelihood of those three scenarios is #2, #1, and #3, in that order.

Also I fully plan to claim roleblock regardless of if I really get roleblocked. So be prepared to try to figure out if its true Okay so actually this is worth thinking about. Why would someone commit themselves to claiming a roleblock regardless of the truth of the situation? Let's think about this...

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Mon Jul 16, 2018 12:50 am

I was actually roleblocked but its not like anyone would ever buy it. So its rather dumb to ask me. Does a single person believe me? No.

Why did you deliberately set up a situation where nobody would believe a roleblock claim if you made one? Why did you do that?

That includes the four numbers I consider to be most likely to be our enemies. @jamie: is "3 9 11 14" some agreed mafia QT code for "Brain, Fox, Peter, Teacher" being your enemies? Are these four the biggest enemies of you and mafia winning the game? Lol such a cryptic code. You are a genius Peter.

^ classic anchoring

That just looks way more like youre searching for logic to protect your ninja or rb instead of genuine thoughts. The wagon grew quickly because there were proper reasons for it. The other wagon grew quickly because it would otherwise potentially end up on scum Peter, hence there is some scum paddin...

damo666 wrote: ↑

Sun Jul 15, 2018 12:02 pm

So Jamie I assume 3 9 11 14 includes SK?

And I assume you mean Brain, Fox, Peter, Teacher.

I think you have a MINIMUM of one right and highly likely a MINIMUM of one wrong.

That includes the four numbers I consider to be most likely to be our enemies.

@Jamie - Brain explained the SK gambit in a way that makes sense. He was trying to call the shot onto his scummiest read. Not crazy about it, but also never played with an SK so hadn't thought of this. He did do that, and yet he has also persisted to claim that he is SK and laugh about the fact tha...

Brainbomb, meanwhile, must be assumed to know who the SK targeted, by virtue o of claiming to be the SK himself, if you believe that.

I am a little behind, so I am going to go back to the beginning of D2. Since DrCJG was the traitor, we do not know which kill was the NK and the SK. There are other possibilities as well, there could have been a kill by the JOAT or veteran, with the NK or SK getting saved or the NK and SK target be...

Teacher2 said: (but it is probably too early for a Vet-JOAT attack so two kills make sense), and Doc-JOAT would know if you were protected, which makes you a semi-town clear but also an incomprehensible save target since you were pretty mixed-read. The Veteran does not "attack", their kill only happ...

worcej wrote:
@Jamie, if he flips town at EOD, what will be your defense for hyper focusing him?

He is claiming to be the Serial Killer. Why would you *not* lynch someone who is doing that?

3.
9.
11.
14.
Bingo.